Russian war, Georgian democracy

What is the war between Georgia and Russia about? Tbilisi's education minister sets out a strong case

About the author
David Hayes is deputy editor of openDemocracy, which he co-founded in 2000. He has written textbooks on human rights and terrorism, and was a contributor to Town and Country (Jonathan Cape, 1998). His work has been published in PN Review, the Irish Times, El Pais, the Iran Times International, the Canberra Times, the Scotsman, the New Statesman and The Absolute Game

He has edited five print collections of material from the openDemocracy website, including Europe and Islam; Turkey: Writers, Politics, and Free Speech; and Europe: Visions, Realities, Futures. He is the editor of Fred Halliday's Political Journeys - the openDemocracy Essays (Saqi, 2011)

What is the war between Georgia and Russia about? Ghia Nodia, theminister of education in Georgia, wrote in his first openDemocracyarticle (“The war for Georgia: Russia, the west, the future”,12 August) that the conflict - “unexpected and anticipated at the sametime” - that “Moscow wants to teach Georgia a lesson for Tbilisi's openand defiant wish to become part of the west; it wants to send a messageto the United States and Europe that it will not tolerate furtherencroachment on its zone of influence; and it wants to make clear toother countries in its neighbourhood (Ukraine first of all) that theyare in Russia's backyard and should behave accordingly.” The mainobjective of Russia’s action in “Georgia proper”, he writes,”is regimechange”.

Now, in a follow-up contribution (“Russian war and Georgian democracy”,22 August), Ghia Nodia argues that Georgia’s institutions havedisplayed resilience and demonstrated their integrity in withstandingthis Russian ambition.

The threat to Georgia, he writes, means that “the moral andpsychological aspect of the war is no less important than theterritorial one”. He acknowledges that an accentuation of existinginternal political strains in Georgia will be part of the war’sfallout, but contends that overall Georgia can be said to have won a“moral victory”. The lessons are for far more than Georgia alone, hesuggests.

This is a contribution to openDemocracy’s and openDemocracy.net/Russia's extended and continuing analysis of the August 2008 war, which includes articles by (among others) Neal Ascherson, Zygmunt Dzieciolowski, George Hewitt, Ivan Krastev, Evgeny Morozov , Donald Rayfield, and Thomas de Waal.

This article is published by David Hayes, and openDemocracy.net under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it with attribution for non-commercial purposes following the CC guidelines. For other queries about reuse, click here. Some articles on this site are published under different terms. No images on the site or in articles may be re-used without permission unless specifically licensed under Creative Commons.