Quote of the day

Nothing is necessarily as you thought it was, and you should never believe what you're told until you've had a chance to study it for yourselves

Syndicate content

Login

Login or Register to be identified in your comments

Email & RSS

Sign up to oD's editorial summaries email:



Add oD to your Netvibes: Add to Netvibes

5050

Virtual Violence

Zohra Moosa, 05/12/07

16 days banner - blue

Girls need modems

Cyber violence against women is on the rise yet many countries' laws still do not have ways of addressing it in part because of the nature of the 'crimes' involved.

The fact that cyber violence happens virtually rather than face-to-face can make it more difficult to take action on it for any of the following reasons:

  • There may not be any physical evidence that it is happening for a forensic analysis, for instance, especially if it's in chat rooms that don't log messages
  • It may be difficult to link abusive behaviour to actual known people if perpetrators are using screen names
  • The violence may be directed at online representations of women, which themselves may be degrading or visually violent, rather than known or actual individual women

However it would be a profound mistake to suggest that the line between the real and the virtual is as firm as the above suggest. For example, while the personas in online community forums are virtual and their acts in turn are carried out digitally, the motivations behind the acts are not virtual and nor are all of the implications as the Second Life 'virtual rape' incident demonstrated. In fact, as this article in Wired discusses, the sense of violation and trauma from a virtual rape are not only real, but are intricately related to the fact that participating in online communities requires a level of psychological engagement that is higher precisely because physical relations are removed.

There are also a number of ways in which online violence interacts with and reinforces offline violence and vice-versa as Shariff and Gouin discuss in their extremely revealing paper (pdf) on the subject of cyber bullying in schools. Importantly, their research has found that girls and women are the primary targets for cyber bullying and gender and sexual harassment are the most prevalent forms of such bullying.

The virtual and the real are also linked as a result of the ways the former is used to facilitate violence in the latter. For instance, in an article on ICTs and violence against women, AWID outlines how perpetrators of domestic violence have monitored their partners' internet usage and telephone communications as well as using GPS (global positioning systems) to track their partners. Cyberstalking is not only real, it led to Valarie Sparacio's murder.

Bringing perpetrators of cyber violence to justice is an ongoing challenge. The fact that it is easier to preserve anonymity online makes it difficult to 'catch' someone in the act. Indeed, the relative immunity to being identified is one reason that those who would otherwise not participate or who would usually be more restrained can be found to be perpetrating some of the grossest abuses. In addition, the nature of the abuse involved can make it more difficult to prove that someone has been attacked. For example, some would argue that a person could simply exit a forum if they felt that they were being unwillingly pursued by an online persona.

In an attempt to redress the balance, a number of projects that use ICTs to eliminate violence against women have emerged, including this blog. Take back the tech, which Jessica profiled on Monday, is an excellent example of such a project, with links to many other fascinating online initiatives including one in India, one in South Africa and one in New Mexico. There's also a relatively new blog for survivors in the UK. Add your voice to the effort by commenting on this post below.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><b> <i> <br> <p> <div> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
More information about formatting options

Remember to login to have your comments properly attributed

Login or Register to be identified in your comments

50.50 blogroll

16 days contributors

CAADA
EVAW
Fawcett Society
Forward thinking
Hayah
Kubatana
International Women's Health coalition
One World Action
OWFI
Panos
Pathways of Women's Empowerment
Patricia Daniel
Scarleteen
The F Word
Ultra Violet
UNIFEM
WAITS
WomanKind Worldwide

Blogs

Bitch pHd
Feministing
Feministe
Feminist Law Professors
Girl Drive
I blame the patriarchy
Pandagon
Shakesville
The Margins
Radical Doula
Women of Color

Organisations

Afghan Women’s Network
Africa's women speak out
African feminist forum
AMANITARE
Amnesty Ireland

Brene Brown
BRIDGE

CAMFED
Center for Women’s Global Leadership

Democracy School
DemocraShe
Desert voices

Education for peace in Iraq center
Equality now
EVAW

FAIR Fund
Federation of African women educationalists
Femmes Africa Solidarite
FEMNET
Fundacion Rigoberta Menchu

Genanet
Gender and Media Southern Africa
Genderlinks
Green Belt Movement International

Iranian Women Cultural Center
Iraq Speakers Bureau
Irish Joint Consortium on Gender Based Violence
Isis
IKWRO

Jerusalem Center for Women
Just Associates

Kosova Women's Network
Kubatana
Kvinna till Kvinna

Organization of Women’s Freedom in Iraq

Parents Circle - Families Forum
Peacewomen Across the Globe

PEKKA - Women Headed Household Empowerment Program

Shirkat Gah - Women’s Resource Centre
Straight Talk
Stop Honour Killings

The Alliance for Arab Women
The Green Belt Movement

Uganda Women’s Network

V- Day Karama

WEDO
WIDE
WILPF representative
Womankind Worldwide
Women for Women’s Human Rights
Women Law and Develeopement in Africa
Women Watch
Women’s Initiative for Gender Justice (WIGJ)
Women’s League of Burma
Women’s Center for Legal Aid and Counseling
Women’s Initiatives for Gender Justice
Work of Women

Youthrive

50.50 Pictures

50.50 projects

Pathways of Women's Empowerment

Women UNlimited

16 days against gender violence

Nobel Women's Initiative

 women talk to the G8

World Social Forum

Resolution 1325

Renga