Not logged in on "Lords reform proposals published"

Not logged in — Mon, 14 Jul 2008 23:29:31 +0100

I love the way the papers (at least the online editions that I've seen) are reporting it as simply a factual "and the electoral system will be either First Past the Post or some proportional system". Its as though they see the two are broadly similar and its just a matter of preference; akin to someone asking you "would you like custard or cream with your pudding, sir?" Many in the media (OpenDemocracy excepted) seem to have failed to understand - or at least report on - what a fundamental difference the choice of system makes. While some are picking up on the Nick Herbert bit of PR-bashing, or the difference between Labour and Tory policies on systems, very few are actually examining what it might mean in practice .... or what it says about the respective parties.

Lords reform proposals published, Tom Griffin

Tom Griffin — Mon, 14 Jul 2008 16:36:27 +0100

Tom Griffin (London, The Green Ribbon): Jack Straw has today published the Government's white paper on reform of the House of Lords.

The proposals call for a chamber which is 80-100 per cent elected, with members serving a single non-renewable 12-15 year term and a third of the chamber retiring at each election

One key point that emerged from Anthony Barnett's discussion with David Marquand below is that the choice of electoral system is likely to be crucial, not just to the future of the second chamber, but to the case for reform of the Commons.The White Paper leaves that issue very much open:

The Government proposes that members of the second chamber should be elected directly. There was not consensus about the system that should be used for such elections. The Conservative Party favours a First Past The Post system. The Liberal Democrats favour the use of an open list or Single Transferable Vote system. The Government believes that further consideration should be given to the options of using either a First Past The Post, Alternative Vote, Single Transferable Vote (STV), open or semi-open list system. The Government would welcome views on what system should be used for elections to a wholly or mainly elected second chamber.

open Democracy News Analysis - Lords reform proposals published, Tom Griffin - Comments

Not logged in on "Lords reform proposals published"

Lords reform proposals published, Tom Griffin