Quote of the day

My students taught me that everything was personal - history, politics, foreign relations - but this approach creates boundaries as well as connections

Syndicate content

Navigation

terrorist rehab and prevention



Posts: 519
Joined: 2005-02-27
Interesting

I didn't about either of these projects. The Saudis are not known for their leniency, so I imagine that the prisons are not so much for terrorists as those who may be suspected of becoming terrorists. I may be doing them a disservice in saying that, but I would imagine that anyone who commits an act of terrorism in Saudi would not be expected to be rehabilitated, unless this is a new word for spending 30 years in jail or getting executed.

The wall is a huge construction. Here I believe that it is to stop illegal immigration rather than terrorism, as they say. Saudi is a very rich country with a majority of (legal) immigrants. The indigenous Saudis would not want immigration to get out of hand. They are very comfortable with the situation as it is. I suppose it would double as a protection against terrorists, but I don't think this is a prime goal. Anyway, Saudi does a proficient job in generating its own terrorists and exporting them.




Posts: 918
Joined: 2004-10-07
The audacity of walls!

I can't believe the audacity of the Saudis to build an Apartheid Wall with Iraq!!!

--

Boring and enraging Liberals with the truth since 2004




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
Quote:Typically in Saudi

Quote:
Typically in Saudi Arabia, there are eight to ten prisoners held in a cell at one time [3]. In other detention facilities up to 30 individuals may be housed together in a single group cell. In the new facilities, prisoners will be housed in individual cells or perhaps sharing with another inmate

I wonder how they determine who is a significant security risk.
I bet a few if them would prefer the special treatment to just being a regular ole criminal.




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
more walls

India builds a 2,500-mile barrier to rival the Great Wall of China

Quote:
Villagers on the Bangladesh border say the fence will cut them from their homeland




Posts: 918
Joined: 2004-10-07
More "Apartheid Walls"

Isn't it amazing what some people will do to protect their homes and families?  Even to the point of building "Apartheid Walls!"

I've been to "Chop-chop Square" in Riyadh where public executions and maimings are performed.  No--I would never attend one.  But I am wary of Saudi "justice" and wonder what kind of public relations motive the monarchy has for this latest construction project.

--

Boring and enraging Liberals with the truth since 2004




Posts: 1307
Joined: 2003-05-03
Border Wall

The Israeli Wall is not a border wall. It's in Palestinian Territory.




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
Eric, Quote:TO REACH the

Eric,

Quote:
TO REACH the baked earth of his mustard field each day, Mohammed Safiqual Biswas must pass coils of barbed wire and armed guards and show his identity card at a security check.
The problem is not where Mr Biswas has come from, but where he is going to. His fields lie 60 miles east of Calcutta, right in the no man’s land between India and Bangladesh.

Quote:
The problem India faces is that 100,000 of its citizens live and farm on a 150-yard patch of land hugging the international border known officially as “the zero line”, and they live on the wrong side of the fence’s designated path.

Entire villages, including schools, temples and mosques lie in what will effectively become no man’s land. Although Bangladeshis and Indians along the border have lived cheek by jowl for decades, and share the Bengali language and culture, relations between them are strained by suspicion.

I am discussing how to fight terrorism, maybe I should have called this thread how to deter terrorist attacks, or just Terrorism Thread #3
The security barrier has been successful in decreasing terrorist attacks for Israel, and other countries build walls for that reason. With that said, I doubt it is fair, but what would be an acceptable response to terrorist attacks, anyhow? Using the tactic of terrorism to fight creates a war against citizens.

from what I understand in reading abdulksaida's posts, who I had considered a moderate, she is not interested in a two state solution anymore. I don't know if that is a popular opinion with Palestinians, but with that mentality in mind what relevance is there to discussing what is fair about a security barrier without wanting a two state solution? Its a all or nothing discussion where examples of palestinian suffering demanding sympathy & requesting validation as the real victims are mentioned for the purpose of illustrating that Israelis need to leave. How will anyone concede a point when the intent and direction of those comments is to dispute the right of Israel to exist as a nation when that is not negotiable.I feel the same about arguments that try to point out that the Palestinian people should overthrow Hamas with the knowledge of how they got control of Gaza.
Less demands of appropriate sympathy and support for extremist sides of the conflict would be helpful in learning about the facts of that conflict, but that would be another thread.




Posts: 498
Joined: 2006-09-23
how u know iam against 2 states

cnadace

i dont know how u interpret my post, iam only defending my people and cant propose anything, nothing was proposed from israel, beleive me israel dont want 2 state, they want a jewish state only and that what i can understand from why they are prolonging .

 




Posts: 1307
Joined: 2003-05-03
Tear down that wall!

"In setting the Barrier's route, Israeli officials almost totally ignored the severe violations of Palestinian human rights. The route was based on extraneous considerations completely unrelated to the security of Israeli citizens. A major aim was to build the Barrier east of as many settlements as possible, to make it easier to annex them into Israel ." Israeli Center for Human Rights

The world supreme court has decided that the Wall must be torn down and it's the responsibilty of all governments, including the US, to make sure this is done. Barriers between states are quite usual. The Israeli Wall does not mark out a recognized border but land which Israel has stolen.




Posts: 1566
Joined: 2005-03-26
Herric Becomes Redundant and Tiresome

Herric;

World Supreme Court, the Wall, stolen land?

You have already brought these arguements up and they have been dismissed each time. Don't you get tired of hearing yourself rant?                                                                           

 The World Supreme Court as you call it, has no jurisdiction in this matter according to its own rules.                         

 The wall has saved Israeli lives from suicide bombers. As a result Palestinian terrorists have resorted to random rocket attacks from Gaza into Israeli settlements.                    

 Such random attacks have cost a great deal of sympathy for the Palestinian cause. The most recent attack which wounded  Israeli civilians and touched off celebrations in Gaza is a prime example.

Let's hope you have not descended to the same mentality.

Do you have something new to add? 

 

 

 




Posts: 1566
Joined: 2005-03-26
Abdulksaida Says She Has No Answers

Abdulksaida;

"...i am only defending my people and cant propose anything..."

Perhaps that is why this conflict has dragged on for 60 years without resolution.

How about a different strategy? All the others have failed so far.




Posts: 498
Joined: 2006-09-23
iam a lay person

Ttrryosborn

what u think i will propose ? even though if i  propose, do u think they will listen to me? who Iam? iam only one of the 6 million refugee in this world, so iam suffering as them, i know the type of suffer differ, but all palestinains are suffering.

did any one in the world listen to us and how we live and reach to live a decent live , and that for me and some by even the suffer of our parents, and others even cant have anything.

i told u and all , that the proposal and solution is in the hand of US and israel only and even no one in the world, they are both countries who are not serious to solve it and i swear and that is clear to all people who read history and also nerutral

only i propose that we are refugee to come back to our homeland and i think that is legitamate asking and my right and the right of all refugee palestinians whom till now dont forget theri homes and many still have the key of their homes with them.




Posts: 1307
Joined: 2003-05-03
Disrespect for World Court

Any cretin, however morally depraved, may say anything whatsoever about the World Court, just as any criminal may reject the law of the land.




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
not sure why I bother

abdulksaida wrote:
i dont know how u interpret my post, iam only defending my people and cant propose anything,

from your right of Israel to exist but where, post

abdulksaida wrote:
it is a human nature that each people have a right to exist , but as palestinians were already exists in their own land, so israeli people have to exist in another place.

Quote:
one question to all OD , why the world choose exactly palestine to settle jewish and not another country or at least built for them another country and draw lines for their country in vacant place and let it an ideal place for them to live. Imi wrong or not human in that proposal.

And some of your reply to a link I posted about some Arab media criticizing Hamas

Quote:
as i say i will respect those voices whom also say all the suffer of palestininas are not with hamas or fath or any group , the source of suffer is when israel stole our land and make palestininas without degnity scattered all over the worl, the arab voices have to be neutral and know that all the world fight hamas as it based on relegious roots and that is the only reason, and they have to ask them selves why palestinians elect hamas, as corruption was auful in the previous group and the whole world fight for those people. The arabs have at leas if they want to condemn hamas to start first with israel and US wich they have the solution right now if they wish, but for othe agenda, i dont know are we all arabs writers are stupid and dont know who start the struggle and misery of palestinians , it is israel and US and after we know the root of the conflict then we will come and condemn each other, really it is shame as we cant see the correct path to follow, and what is planned for us, and many times hamas didnt launch any usuless rockets and israel starts to be angry as if israel wants hamas to launch rockets to kill all palestinians and collective punishment,

So...taking some of your earlier posts and your response to criticism of Hamas in mind I said what I did about you not supporting the two state solution. Was I wrong?




Posts: 1307
Joined: 2003-05-03
not sure why I bother

Despite being thoroughly brainwashed by the American media, you've got some residual sense of decency.




Posts: 1566
Joined: 2005-03-26
Earning Respect

Herric;

"...say anything ... about the world court..."?

How about the fact that by its own rules, the World Court cannot issue a binding verdict without the prior consent of all parties to submit?

It is important to know that many UN resolutions and World Court opinions are non-binding and therefore worthless.




Posts: 1307
Joined: 2003-05-03
International law is binding

An advisory opinion by the World Court indicates the relevant binding provisions of international law. The Israelis are legally bound to knock down the Wall. As a criminal state with the support of the United States, they aren't doing it.




Posts: 1566
Joined: 2005-03-26
Herric Is Confused Again

Herric;

"An advisory opinion by the World Court indicates... international law"?

You really don't know what you're talking about AGAIN.

By your own hand, you wrote that the World Court issued  an "opinion", not a law, regarding the Wall. Opinions are not law and do not have the force of law, especially when the World Court's own rules stipulate that all parties must agree to submit to arbitration in order for a DECISION to be binding.

There are more opinions about the Wall than just the World Court's. Some support, some oppose, some want to adjust the wall.

Who Makes Laws?

It is not the duty of courts to write law. Their job is to intrepret  law. The UN has written no laws, or mandates (only some non-binding resolutions) which have the force of law.

The only mideast mandates issued by the UN concern the yearly renewal of its mandates authorizing the US and Britain to stabilize Iraq. That mandate was renewed recently for another year with the approval of the Iraqi government.

But hey. All is not lost. Since you're such a believer in international decisions, you can agree that the UN mandate on Iraq IS binding.




Posts: 1307
Joined: 2003-05-03
"opinion", not a law

A legal opinion states what the law is. It is the law that is binding. Criminals, of course, refuse to be bound by the law. Idiots are unware of the difference between 'an opinion' and 'a legal opinion'.




Posts: 1566
Joined: 2005-03-26
Herric In Circles

Herric;

The difference between legal opinion and opinion? Again, you fail to comprehend the point which is the difference between legal opinion and enforceable l

Legal opinion is just that--opinion. It is not enforceable law,  especially when the court's own rules require both side to submit to its decision to be binding and one side has not. 

In the case of actual binding mandates. Iraq has agreed to the UN mandate extending US and British efforts to stabilize the country for another year. Does it hurt you to hear that?

Perhaps one day the concept will become clear to you.




Posts: 215
Joined: 2006-06-29
abdul

abdulksaida wrote:

Ttrryosborn

did any one in the world listen to us and how we live and reach to live a decent live , and that for me and some by even the suffer of our parents, and others even cant have anything.

The palestinians don't want t olive a decent life. They want a glorious death.

only i propose that we are refugee to come back to our homeland and i think that is legitamate asking and my right and the right of all refugee palestinians whom till now dont forget theri homes and many still have the key of their homes with them.

Sorry love but this will never happen. The majority of palestinian 'refugees' aren't actually refugees and haven't set foot in the land. Its time you stopped whingeing about being a refugee and did something with your life.




Posts: 215
Joined: 2006-06-29
eric

The courts' ruling was a joke and NON BINDING. However, its clear that the barrier has saved hundreds of lives so calling for it to be pulled down is tantamount to calling for people to be murdered.




Posts: 918
Joined: 2004-10-07
STILL No Excuses!

Abdulksaida, 

Quote:
what u think i will propose ? even though if i  propose, do u think they will listen to me? who Iam?...i told u and all , that the proposal and solution is in the hand of US and israel only...

How convenient.  When the world says enough whining and be part of the solution, you and the rest of the Palestinian apologists fall strangely silent on the issue of real options that require YOU to take responsibility for your future,

Play the part of the helpless victim and point elsewhere for solutions.  Israel and the US have to provide Palestinian solutions?  NO!  Not here--not now.  Palestinians need to be part of the solution--not just part of the problem.  What should you do? Your options are the same as all Palestinians.   Here's a shopping list of ideas and I'm sure there are more.

  • Overthrow Fatah and Hamas who perpetuate your suffering by refusing to negotiate for peace. 
  • Elect a government that rejects terror and commits in its platform to negotiate in good faith with Israel for peaceful solutions to conflict. 
  • Openly advocate the peaceful existance of BOTH Palestinian AND Israeli states.
  • Step forward to publically advocate 2-state solution.
  • Campaign for Jordan to return land stolen from the Palestinians.
  • Other ideas?

Just once, I want to see you have the courage to stop being a victim whining for sympathy for your people and speak out.  There is nothing stopping you from offering YOUR solutions right here on OD. 

You are stronger than you know.  It's time you learn it.

--

Boring and enraging Liberals with the truth since 2004




Posts: 918
Joined: 2004-10-07
Palestinian women need to be part of the solution!

Yet another Palestinian whine-fest posted on OD that echos Abdulksaida's refusal to be part of the solution.

And yet Abdulksaida and Eric and the rest of the Palestinian apologists conveniently ignore criticism from their arab brothers! No comment on Mustapha's post? Does it strike too close to the truth?

http://opendemocracy.net/blog/jane_gabriel/for_the_first_time_we_feel_we_are_helpless_a_message_from_women_rights_advocates_in_gaza

Yet, one of her own arab brothers, Mustaphah B  answers that article better than me.

Quote:

Ladies,

The only violence the Gazan's are at the hands of, is their insane government that cares little for their welfare. The problems there would be solved if Hamas gave up on trying to destroy their neighbor and start to build a country of their own. The electricity shortage, as the world knows, (At least those that pay attention) is caused deliberately by Hamas to show the world the demonic nature of the "Zionist Entity." I have seen many staged pictures of kids with candles in the street, with streetlights blazing. Pictures of kids with candles with the lights on the wall on.

When is the world going to wake up and and witness this fraud. These statements reek of deliberate bias caused by the fact that if these women told the truth, they would not still be in Gaza writing about it. They would be wrapped in sheet, in a trench, buried up to their waist, with medium sized stones battering their upper bodies until they were dead. I've witnessed it and the world needs to know that these women are crying for help. They need not liberation from the "Zionist Entity," but from their captors, the usurpers and perverters of the Prophet Mohammed's words, Peace be upon him.

The narrative of the plight of Gaza is a sham and a fraud. The gender violence is being committed by Hamas. When will you progressive western women get that idea through your heads? Your political leanings blind you to the reality and the plight of women in radical Islamic countries. Better to criticize "The Zionist Entity," than tell the truth. Your hypocrisy is a crime against humanity!

--

Boring and enraging Liberals with the truth since 2004




Posts: 918
Joined: 2004-10-07
Incessant quibbling over courts.

Eric,

Too bad you prefer to quibble over the World Court instead of discussing how the Palestinians can peacefully negotiate for a homeland.  Seems you are more interested in revenge than solutions. 

--

Boring and enraging Liberals with the truth since 2004




Posts: 1566
Joined: 2005-03-26
What Herric Wants

IM

Herric wants whatever the latest ranters tell him to want. It is obvious from his own writings.




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
That was funny, Eric.. I

That was funny, Eric.. I chuckled. Thanks for the near compliment.




Posts: 1307
Joined: 2003-05-03
Negotiations

Israel demands endorsement of their crimes and a period of calm while they digest their ill-gotten gains and prepare for the next assault on normal standards of decency and the requirements of justice.




Posts: 215
Joined: 2006-06-29
Israel to demolish Gaza

eric_5 wrote:
Israel demands endorsement of their crimes and a period of calm while they digest their ill-gotten gains and prepare for the next assault on normal standards of decency and the requirements of justice.

Hopefully soon Israel will re-take Gaza. Should give you something to whinge about.




Posts: 117
Joined: 2006-11-12
What a total punk you are!!

What a total punk you are!! Why not move to puke land and live awhile with these subhuman scabs. Hey, you can even become another dumbass like rachel corrie and die because of stupidity.




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
RE: Negotiations

Eric,

How is avoiding negotiations going to help Palestinians?




Posts: 275
Joined: 2005-04-21
Five second time limit for answering questions once buzzed

Oh, oh, I know this one! Really I do!!

 

Nup, gone.




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
I'm just a question askin'

I'm just a question askin' but get no answerin' kind of gal.




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
Joseph McBloggs

I am still waiting for a guest list to be IM'd to me which should hopefully be today, then you and the rest of the opendemocracy folks I've defeated can return without fear :-)




Posts: 275
Joined: 2005-04-21
Whoa, hey, now wait a

Whoa, hey, now wait a minute: Who have you defeated??




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
No offense intended Joe, I'm

No offense intended Joe, I'm just sick of this site.




Posts: 275
Joined: 2005-04-21
Ah, right. Why'd'you think

Ah, right. Why'd'you think I've been pretty quiet? I'm only here out of boredom - also no offense intended ;)




Posts: 551
Joined: 2005-12-24
I didnt think much about it,

I didnt think much about it, and no offense taken.