Quote of the day

This isn't the sort of thing society grows out of. It's the sort of thing that society grows into

Clay Shirky for Felix Cohen

Syndicate content

Natur Karta


Posts: 496
Joined: 2006-09-23

while i was watching aljazeera tv in arabic, their was an interview with rabbist called david wize as i think, he speaks much about his jewish group natur karta, and so they are very close to most of us palestinians and that is an answer to TT and jo and others here in OD who thinks we hate jewish for only their relegion. The true jewish relegion is fair and our struggle is with zionism .

Do u know about that jewish group ?




Posts: 1551
Joined: 2005-03-26
Abdulksaida Accepts The

Abdulksaida Accepts The Rights Of Jews?

Neturei Katur is a sect of the Jewish faith. Like the Zionists, they believe the Jews have a right to the Holy Land. They differ in that they feel the Jews are forbidden to have a state until the return of the Messiah. This brings up some interesting questions.

1)  Are you saying now the Jews do have a right to the Holy Land at a future date?

2) Many followers of Neturei Katur reside in Jerusalem. Is it okay with you is they stay until the Messiah returns?

 




Posts: 496
Joined: 2006-09-23
from the interview , the

from the interview , the rabbist say that God choose for us not a state , we  did much sins and we must not have a state. that is their faith and not mine

really i was astonished to hear what he said, it is for me the first time to hear that. He didnt say that we want state when jesus comes. He said that zionists take many false execuses as also hallucast to have its own agenda.

many new ideas i heard from that rabbist. jewish can live in palestine as before and we dont do massacres to them as they did to us.




Posts: 496
Joined: 2006-09-23
Addition he didnt mention

Addition

he didnt mention the future, he said for ever , he consider that it is a will of God and also even when jesus will come again, he will rule in just and as we beleive also he is muslim and follower of our prophet.

That rabbist knows that now israel is a terrorist state and illegal.

 




Posts: 1551
Joined: 2005-03-26
Get The Whole

Get The Whole Story

Abdulksaida;

Click to Wikipedia.com and look up Naturei Katur. They firmly believe  the Holy Land will belong to them WHEN the Messiah returns. They just think the Zionists jumped the gun.           

In the meantime  it is nice of you to let them  stay in Jerusalem until they inherit everything.

A Holocaust agenda?                                                      

You should also look up the Holocaust on Wikipedia. It was the Nazis who had the agenda--against Jews.

Massacres?                                                                   

Isn't the Mideast a long history of massacre? Who threw the first stone?




Posts: 496
Joined: 2006-09-23
i read it from wikipedia

i read it from wikipedia more slowly, i didnt hear him , but even though , when jesus will come , he will rule in justice and nobody will discard any person if he dont kill others. When God (Allha) reveal the 3 holly relegions in palestine, it means that all have to live together peacfully and if they really apply they true relegions so no conflict will be.

what is happing now that zionists steal the country and give it to secular jewish using the execuses of hallucaust . It is only politics and not true fact. Really if the real judiasm is applied now in palestine,  so jewish themselves will return back our land to us.




Posts: 1551
Joined: 2005-03-26
Land? What Land? Naturei

Land? What Land?

Naturei Katur only talks about Jews waiting for the Messiah to have a NATION. Nothing says they can't have land until then. What property does Naturei Katur own now?

BTW. How many Arabs owned land (not just lived on it) prior to l947? 

No conflict when the Messiah returns?

Why not now?

 




Posts: 275
Joined: 2005-04-21
And here we go again...

And here we go again...




Posts: 496
Joined: 2006-09-23
TT i dont think now the

TT

i dont think now the peace is near ,  even though all palestinians dream of it, but in the real life we think it is too far. you asked why not now?

ask the zionists , they dont want peace. When messaih come , i think,  their will be no zionists and no conspiracies any more, so peace will be prevailed  and justice will predominate.




Posts: 275
Joined: 2005-04-21
When did I say that you hate

When did I say that you hate them because they're jewish?




Posts: 13
Joined: 2008-04-30
Hi abdulksaida There's some

Hi abdulksaida

There's some audio and text at http://www.ihrc.org.uk/060702/ which outlines the views of Naturei Karta .

Rabbi Ahron's talk at http://www.ihrc.org.uk/060702/papers/ahron_cohen.pdf is well written and explores the tensions between Judaism and Zionism.

Enjoy 




Posts: 496
Joined: 2006-09-23
freethepeeps thanks a lot

freethepeeps

thanks a lot for the article, really i enjoy it very much, my computer is not well to listen to others. i will try to fix it .

i really enjoy the article by Rabbi Ahron Cohen wich really reads all my thoughts and go aside with it as if he expressed my opinion.

iam as a palestinian and all of us dont hate jews created by God and they are people to be respected even more if they follow they real Toarat as it was revealed and our struggle is with zionism and we are palestinians and jews are semitism , so we are the same in that . thank u




Posts: 496
Joined: 2006-09-23
also with the 60 aneversary

also with the 60 aneversary of israel establishement their is a dark mark in other side of their neigbors, the same before 60 years we are palestinians discarded from our own land and one of them  was my father and his and other journey of torture and suffer begins till now . But now my father went to heaven ( mercy on him ) before returning back to jerusalem were he born and always dream of the day to return back.

really it is sad for us palestinins while israeli are celebrating , we are crying .