Nothing is necessarily as you thought it was, and you should never believe what you're told until you've had a chance to study it for yourselves
Nothing is necessarily as you thought it was, and you should never believe what you're told until you've had a chance to study it for yourselves
NavigationThe World
Our writersPopular Articles |
![]() |
Off Shoring of Jobs
I would like to know if there are mechanisms in place to monitor the number of jobs US companies are sending off shore? The current unemployment rate in this country is at an all time high. I have been in the Information Technology field for over 20 years. I lost my job due to off shoring. There was an article in the February 3 issue of Business that stated five years from now, 4 million IT jobs will have been moved to India and other countries. Who is monitoring this process??
Submitted on Wed, 2003-04-23 23:00
Re: Off Shoring of Jobs
I wonder the same thing, and also, how can we prevent this from happening in the first place? I see many jobs being given to people in other countries, then products being sold here for a pretty mark-up. Its not just the IT world, its happening with factory jobs as well. I live in Canton Ohio, which is a hot seat for many factory jobs. In the past year or so, I heard that the Hoover Plant will be shut down within 5 years and the jobs will be transferred off shore. Then I wonder if Timken Roller Bearing is going next. As a youngster, I remember TV Commercials and Billboards all over the place telling us to Buy American. Maybe that is what we need to convince the greedy to stay here. If we dont buy their products because they move offshore, then maybe other companies will get the message and think twice before they leave. That may be easier said than done, but it might convince at least some companies to stay. I know its hard to Buy American now days with globalization in progress, but maybe we should just not buy specific companies products, like Hoover for example, that have decided to go offshore and leave hundreds to thousands of Americans, their main consumer, without a job. Then the companies will eventually have to downsize because of the decreased consumer base, and that would be the trend. But of course, we ultimately need someone to keep track of who is going offshore, and we must let the people know!
Re: Off Shoring of Jobs
Unfortunately, your efforts are futile. Offshoring is and will continue to be the modus operandi. The ball has started rolling and will not stop. For instance, you need a flashlight to find "made in the USA" in a Wal-Mart store, or even a Nike store, which I have first hand experience, being a former supplier to Nike who has lost his job to offshore sourcing. The answer, in my own humble opinion, is to adapt. Observe what is happening and react to it before it leaves you in a situation where you are stuck, waiting for regulations or quotas against foreign made products. This isnt an answer that everyone wants to hear, but it is an unavoidable truth. Those same folks who are out of work or even hanging on by a thread, are those who are shopping at Walmart. It is a cycle that will not be broken by being passive.
?
What happened to the American Dream? Don't tell me that companies who have decided not to value you as retainable are at fault for making a profit by moving your position off shore. This continued appearance of victimization by Americans is sad to see. Always blaming others for the choices they each make. Do you all live in such a vacuum that you have not prepared for the eventuality that your career may have to be augmented with more education, more versatility, more flexibility, hell more anything? You deserve the bed you have made for yourselves.
There is no logic presented
There is no logic presented in the argument.
Why "Buy American" instead of, for example, buying New Yorkian?
If you live in New York should you not ensure whatever you buy is made in New York and New York only? Would it not be a horror if you were to purchase something from Ohio? God forbid Texas!
Of course within New York itself one should shop local, only buying cars, air con, areoplanes and mustard manufactured on your own street, created by materials mined or whatever from your local park. Right?
Obviously enough, that wouldn't work. The way to get the very best use of resources and materials, both for the money and convenience and so on, is by diversity of sources. If the very best aircraft, for the money, are made in Texas, buy Texan.
What good would it do for people in New York to have to pay import tariffs, or charge taxes to "external" companies in places like Texas? How does paying more for a product actually help you? These things do not help YOU, they only help the companies selling to you - by making life harder for the competition that wants to supply you the same products cheaper.
It only makes sense when YOU are the actual supplier, or employed by the supplier. Then of course you'd like high tariffs or restrictions on anyone else. That's plain greed and envy, nothing to do with being "American" or anything else.
Why SHOULD people in America have to pay higher prices when they could buy the same thing cheaply from China or India? What right do you have to force them to pay more? If you live in New York what's the difference between China or Texas? You're still "exporting jobs" while importing goodies.
For that matter, why SHOULD people in China be poor? What's the point of America being "rich" if you can't afford to buy stuff? For example, from China?
Why should rich people be rich and poor people poor? Well there are lots of reasons perhaps but arguing for policies or government action to enforce that has nothing to do with fairness or ethics now, does it?
In truth all you are seeing is the market balancing things out, just on a larger scale than New York and Texas. Modern telecommunications, the spread of language, more efficent transportation and so on, all mean that today you don't have to pay $80.00 for an item you could have for $8.00 - if you buy it from China.
It's only a bad thing for those still trying to sell the same thing for $80.00 and losing customers. You should only make money in business, be it as an employer or employee, by making other people happy. Not by getting the government, mafia or some other mob to cripple your competitors at the expense of everybody else.
W.
Post new comment |
![]() |
ElectionsMost discussed articles... |
Posts: 1
Joined: 2003-04-23