Part of the openDemocracy Network

Power2010

Breaking the monopoly of the professional politician: Guy Aitchison's idea for popular forums in Parliament
 

When you're in a hole, stop digging: Pam Giddy's advice to MPs who still don't get it
 

Ending the divine right of political parties: Steve Hawkins makes a radical suggestion
 

Les Miserables and Power 2010: John Jackson diagnoses the political class's selective crisis-mongering
 

A call to oD readers: Helena Kennedy calls on oD readers to support Power2010
 

More in this series

Submit your idea for the Power 2010 pledge.

The British Crisis

Do the public really want to change ‘the system’?: Stuart Wilks-Heeg presents polling evidence
 

Don't trust MPs' constitutional poker: Guy Aitchison supports the call for a citizens' convention
 

Brown's 'National Council for Democratic Renewal': Anthony Barnett on the Prime Minister's desperate proposal
 

More in this series

Navigation

delicious | digg | reddit | newsvine | furl | google | yahoo | technorati | diigolet

Syndicate content

Don't mention the war (on terror)

4 - 02 - 2008
delicious | digg | reddit | newsvine | furl | google | yahoo | technorati | diigolet

Jon Bright (London, OK): One of the aspects of the global war on terror which, as it were, would have been funny if it wasn't so tragic, was the often repeated desire to "win hearts and minds": often repeated by people who seemed to be going out of their way to do exactly the opposite. Forward Thinking's new report on "Forgotten Voices", which investigates the opinions of young Muslims through conversations with their peers, exposes the extent of the damage - and the rather worrying level of concern Muslim youth feel about their lives and their prospects. It reveals both that a "great majority" of them felt "British", and yet also felt isolated within their society - fearful of their prospects of educational and professional development.

Policy does affect this - but it is the general tone of the public debate which they referenced most often - particularly a constantly negative portrayal by the media. This portrayal is reinforced by careless use of language: the idea of "Islamic" terrorism, for example, has always been problematic (while the word "Islamofacism" has, I hope, gone the way of the Dodo). There are people in the world who desire to murder civilians through violent attacks - but to allow their violence to be in the name of a religion is to allow them possession of an enormous worldwide faith with which they have little right to. God is routinely invoked as justification for all sorts of violent acts - lets not forget that leaders of both the UK and US also spoke to their various Gods on the eve of war with Iraq.

However, some crumbs of comfort appear to come from a leaked Home Office document today, which also seems to bear out the idea that Brown is far more wise to the politics of naming than his predecessor. Despite claiming not to be a list of "what not to say", this document advises civil servants on the power of the language they use to describe problems - advising them not to refer to "Islamic extremism" when talking to "Muslim communities," for example, but instead to refer to "violent extremism."

"Evidence shows that people stop listening if they think you are attacking them" it says. Excellent. It's just a shame that it's taken them this long to grasp what looks like a fairly obvious point. When Hazel Blears goes to these communities with her £45 million for tackling extremism locally, will she be able to earn their trust by rebranding "islamic terrorists" as "violent criminals"? Or will she be simply perceived as part of a government which is still practically committed to the war on terror, only no longer rhetorically? Far too early to tell: but governments should always be applauded for talking sense, and this is, at least, a genuine attempt to think about the politics of hearts and minds.

This article adheres to the openDemocracy.net principles.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Ray Bell (not verified) said:

Tue, 2008-02-05 20:54

And those dreadful concoctions "Islamacist", "Irani" and "Afghani" too, I hope.

Ray Bell (not verified) said:

Mon, 2008-02-04 14:55

"It reveals both that a “great majority” of them felt “British”, and yet also felt isolated within their society "

I think the number who feel English in England is much more significant. Most Scottish Asians feel Scottish, and many of them do not feel British at all... in Wales, the equivalent appears to be somewhat the case, but in England the emergence of English Asians seems to be stuttering away.

Britishness has been fading ever since the Empire fell apart, and the WWII generation die off, and it won't be with us much longer. Therefore it's unhealthy for Asians to latch onto a dying identity, and moreover one connected with an Empire which colonised Pakistan, Bangladesh etc.

Nestor the Chronicler (not verified) said:

Tue, 2008-02-05 18:25

It's good to hear that the term "islamofascism" has 'gone the way of the dodo' somewhere in the world. Here in the US it has become a mantra of am talk radio hosts who use it to influence a disproportionate amount of Republican voters.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><b> <i> <br> <p> <div> <img> <map>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
More information about formatting options

Books from Amazon

Email Alerts

Fill in the form below to sign up to our automatic daily alerts, or weekly editorial summary (you will be taken to another page to confirm which options you want).

Enter your Email


Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz

They say about OK

"the ever-stimulating OpenDemocracy"
Ekklesia

"See OurKingdom to keep up"
South Belfast Diary

"...an essential guide to understanding the dynamic constitutional situation..."
Peter Oborne

"...becoming a daily read for me."
Iain Dale

"To make sense of it all, check out OurKingdom..."
Matthew d'Ancona

"Worth a look...it is, however, recommended by Matthew d'Ancona."
The Wardman Wire

"Fast becoming the best political website around"
Tom Waterhouse, CEP

"...attracting energy from a range of contributors."
thenextwave

"...looks very promising..."
The England Project

"The excellent new OurKingdom blog from OpenDemocracy..."
The Green Ribbon

"On the internet, I keep in touch with openDemocracy, a website on global current affairs, and its useful offshoot, OurKingdom"
Andreas Whittam-Smith

"thanks to the fine folk at OurKingdom, (who manage to communicate a variety of perspectives in the way that only a decent group blog can)"
Nostalgia For the Future