Quote of the day

The sudden assertion of human criteria within a dehumanising framework of political manipulation can be like a flash of lightning illuminating a dark landscape

Vaclav Havel

Syndicate content

Login

Login or Register to be identified in your comments

Everydaylifemodern

Email & RSS

Sign up to oD's editorial summaries email:



Follow oD on Twitter


Add oD to your Netvibes: Add to Netvibes

openDemocracy likes

SORRY ABOUT YOUR DAD: A GESTURE BRITAIN OWES TO THE SLOVENES


Posts: 4
Joined: 2003-04-17
By Marcus Ferrar When Tony Blair welcomed Slovene Prime Minister Janez Janša at Downing Street in December, seeking support for Britain’s EU budget policies, it would have been awkward if he had asked the Slovene how his family was. The truth is that Janša’s father has for 60 years been feeling bitter about the British. In May 1945, the British Army in Austria tricked this teenage soldier into climbing aboard a train, and sent him back with 12,000 others to Slovenia (then Yugoslavia). Janša senior was one of a handful who escaped execution on his return because he was too young. The avenging Partisans, to whom the British delivered their enemies, disarmed and locked into cattle trucks, slaughtered all the rest. In this blackest moment of Slovenia’s history, one per cent of the nation was put to death. So it is no thanks to the British that today’s Slovene Prime Minister came to be born. The British knew his father and all the rest were likely to be killed. As liaison officers with Tito, British officers had witnessed the Communist-led Partisans fighting a ruthless civil war with anti-Communist Slovene Catholics, who fled to Austria in 1945. Does this matter, 60 years afterwards? Does Mr Blair therefore owe something to the head of a government which nowadays often sides with Britain in EU debates? Nobody doubts any more that handing over the surrendered Slovene soldiers was wrong. It contravened Geneva conventions on treatment of prisoners of war. The Yalta agreement between the wartime Allies called for repatriations, but only of Soviet citizens. The British respected these commitments towards German soldiers, as well as other anti-Tito forces such as the Chetniks. But the Slovenes were forced back to their deaths. Many British soldiers involved were sickened at their orders. Tony Crosland, later a Labour Foreign Secretary, described it as “one of the most nauseating and cold-blooded acts of war I have ever taken part in.” Nigel Nicolson, author, publisher and Tory MP, considered it “one of the most disgraceful operations British soldiers have ever been ordered to undertake.” Rank-and-file soldiers were said by their chaplain to be closer to mutiny than ever before during the war. So why does no British authority acknowledge a wrong that was obvious to the common British soldier at the time? In response to enquiries after the war, the British government denied the repatriations of Slovenes ever took place, and has never said otherwise since. The Slovene Prime Minister’s father knows what happened, but not apparently the British government. John Corsellis and Marcus Ferrar, authors of the recently-published book Slovenia 1945, wrote to Mr Blair asking him to make a gesture of regret: an honourable admission to a friendly nation that the British, who had much to be proud of in the war, were also capable of making a lethal mistake. The Cardinal Archbishop of Westminster, the Anglican Bishop of Oxford and the Labour head of the British-Slovene Parliamentary group have written to the PM in support. Foreign Secretary Jack Straw replied to the authors that he well understood “the pain that so many must feel, sixty years on,” adding “it is right, as Europe recalls the suffering endured by all nations during that time, that we too remember the tragedy that befell the Slovene people.” Kind words, but did the tragedy just befall the Slovene nation? This continues to evade the truth that the British sent the soldiers back. Present generations do not need to take responsibility for mistakes of men long dead, but we should show what values we now stand for – especially towards a nation which today shares the same open, democratic values as Britain within the EU. Mr Straw acted honourably in Srebrenica last July, acknowledging the failure of the international community to prevent the 1995 massacre, declaring: “I bitterly regret this and I am deeply sorry for it.” So, Mr Blair, next time you meet Mr Janša, please do say “sorry about your Dad,” and make it public. You know what the British did to him. And you should now treat these people as friends. Slovenia 1945: Memories of Death and Survival after World War II, by John Corsellis & Marcus Ferrar, is published by I.B. Tauris.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Posts: 1
Joined: 2007-01-05
Re: SORRY ABOUT YOUR DAD: A GESTURE BRITAIN OWES TO THE SLOVENES
I support your view that a formal apology needs to be given. The British should be ashamed of thier part in this slaughter. I am a first generation Canadian, the son of a Slovene refugee. My father was a 16 year old farm boy who fled through the Lubelj tunnel to escape the post war Communist purge. He moved through the camps at Viktring, Lienz and Spittal and in 1949 emigrated to Canada. I am just completing your book and must commend you and John Corsellis for the skill in writing this gripping story of human suffering and resilience. I now understand why the Slovene's hate the British. The book glued my father's stories into a chronology and provided the context of the situation and an appreciation of the mental anguish and physical suffering that each refugee suffered. My father would like to read the book to fill in the background of the events but I'm not sure he can relive the memories and the emotion of the experience. Thank you for capturing this unfortunate event in history and allowing the children of the refugees to understand this part of their personal history.



Posts: 1
Joined: 2007-03-09
Re: SORRY ABOUT YOUR DAD: A GESTURE BRITAIN OWES TO THE SLOVENES
My father was a Slovene soldier who found himself following the line of young men sent to Austria only to be sent back to Slovenia to a certain death. He was one of the few who survived thanks to his quick thinking and knowledge of the partisan regime who he had fought for in the beginning of the war. As his son my heart goes out to the thousands of sons and their families who have been touched by this grave act done by the British. My father was fortunate enough to live and eventually escape the Communist regime in Slovenia after the war. His stories will resonate through the generations that will follow me and my own son. I can only say how important it would be more than 60 years after this strategy to have someone like Mr. Blair acknowledge the suffering and lack of closure thrust upon the memory of those young men and their families.



Posts: 1
Joined: 2007-03-25
Re: SORRY ABOUT YOUR DAD: A GESTURE BRITAIN OWES TO THE SLOVENES
Please enlighten me but we are speaking of the Slovenian Homeguard here are'nt we? The Slovenian Domobrans or Domobranci ? Were they not the allies of the Nazis ?


Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><b> <i> <br> <p> <div> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
More information about formatting options