Re-imagining the American Dream: a decade of sisterhood with Positive Women’s Network

Women living with HIV are mobilising to demand visibility and rights in the US. Our collective voice, vision and leadership offer hope.

Sonia Rastogi
5 September 2018

rastogi (1).jpg

Members LaTrischa Miles, Naina Khanna, Vanessa Johnson, Evany Turk and Pat Kelly at PWN’s 10 year anniversary and national summit for women living with HIV. Photo credit: Positive Women’s Network - USA, 2018.

“Imagine what it would look like to create a space for 300,000 women and girls living with HIV to have a political home,” Naina Khanna, executive director of Positive Women’s Network - USA (PWN), told me over Skype, this May. She explained: “We cannot only fight for space at existing tables, we also need to create new tables.”

Ten years ago, 28 diverse women living with HIV in the US, including women of trans experience, set out to create precisely this political space. Through PWN, a group of mostly women of colour leaders harnessed their collective power to fill a void in voice, agency and visible leadership by women living with HIV in America.

Around the same time that PWN was founded, I received an HIV diagnosis. As a young woman of colour and daughter to immigrants who was raised to believe in the white narrative of the American Dream, I was struggling to articulate my own politics, let alone process the anger, confusion and sadness of an HIV diagnosis.

It would take another year for me to meet another person living with HIV. Luckily, that first person was a woman of colour who guided me to PWN.

“I came into myself when I linked into this collective voice of women living with HIV.”

I came into myself when I linked into this collective voice of women living with HIV. The power of language, of discovering your own truth, then speaking this truth to power with others is a cathartic experience. It is an experience that many women living with HIV have had when they’ve engaged with PWN.

Months after its founding in 2008, PWN members heard that other organisations were preparing policy recommendations for the incoming presidential team. No one had submitted recommendations on women living with HIV. Both McCain and Obama had made commitments to a national HIV/AIDS strategy, but it was unclear who would win.

For PWN, this was non-negotiable: women living with HIV had to be at the table defining their own priorities. Hundreds of hours of phone calls and many drafts later, PWN submitted the first-ever policy document authored entirely by women living with HIV to a sitting presidential administration. This marked PWN’s entrance onto the national stage.

Eight years later, the communities that PWN represents faced an increasingly hostile social, political and cultural climate in the run-up to President Trump’s election in 2016.

The evening after the election, PWN organised an emergency community call for people living with HIV to check-in, validate emotions and bridge the isolation so familiar to people living with HIV. “It made me realise we were going to have to be here for our communities in new and different ways,” Khanna told me.

As 2016 came to a close, PWN “took an intentional position to stand in active defiance [of Trump’s administration]. This is a dangerous place to be when you are a non-profit, but it is a characteristic response from PWN – we have to do it because our lives depend on it, not because we have a grant to do it,” said Barb Cardell, the board’s chair.

“We have to do it because our lives depend on it, not because we have a grant to do it"

This defiance has included: scaling-up community organising; promoting the leadership and expertise of women living with HIV; bolstering efforts to shift cultural narratives around women and HIV; and most importantly, committing to stand for human rights and dignity of all people living with HIV.

“We are dedicated to hearing our membership in whatever form it comes across,” Cardell emphasises. She explains that, personally, “PWN changed me into the person I wanted and needed to be – it unshackled me.”

“Often women living with HIV are dismissed if they get emotional or angry," she added. "PWN acknowledges and validates that this rage and pain is real – it comes from surviving traumas we never should have had to survive. We honour the lived experience of women living with HIV and support them wherever they are at.”

rastogi (2).jpg

Barb Cardell advocating for the Affordable Care Act and the right to health. Photo credit: Positive Women’s Network - USA, 2018.

Last year, PWN launched a six-part intersectional policy agenda that responds to the political moment and linked with reproductive justice, disability rights groups and mainstream policy think tanks to fight against attempts to repeal the Affordable Care Act.

As the US now heads into heated midterm elections, in November, PWN has deepened its political engagement by launching the PWN Action Fund, to endorse progressive candidates. Five statewide chapters are also leading local ‘get out the vote’ efforts.

“There are over a million people living with HIV in this country. Imagine the power of those voters,” said Khanna, describing PWN as “committed to non-partisan, progressive voter organising to increase turnout of voters who are informed about our issues.”

Today, PWN is a recognised leader and key player in the US advocacy and policy landscape. It now has thousands of members nationally, with six statewide chapters and state leads in another 13 states, while remaining committed to working internally and externally to deconstruct the ways race, patriarchy and misogyny structure power.

“Every movement has started symbolically. People say symbols don’t matter, but they do”

PWN started as a network unapologetically by and for women living with HIV. “Symbolism is everything,” founding member Vanessa Johnson told me. “Every movement has started symbolically. People say symbols don’t matter, but they do”.

Now, PWN is “laying the groundwork for the next phase,” she said. “Social justice has to be our focus. We have a roadmap of how we are going to take the next step, how we look at health in America, how we as women organise and how we ensure everyone is able to live a quality life and authentically express their power.”

Ten years on, PWN’s values continue to guide my own engagement with the world. These include the centering of the voices and leadership of the most impacted communities; practicing unbending accountability to your constituents; and changing the balance of power through a social justice lens.

In 2015 and 2016 I was working on the frontlines of South Sudan’s civil war alongside many others delivering life-saving services to women, girls and communities affected by decades of conflict. It was PWN’s values, training and approach that give me hope and the will to know what to do in overwhelming and painful situations.

Where humanity seemed the darkest and most corrupt, these values let in a kaleidoscope of light.

Get 50.50 emails Gender and social justice, in your inbox. Sign up to receive openDemocracy 50.50's monthly email newsletter.


We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData