Is anyone at home? The British media and 'What's the story' on the Pro-Israel lobby

Anthony Barnett
Anthony Barnett
11 December 2009

Two weeks ago, in conjunction with Channel 4 and Dispatches, openDemocracy published a careful pamphlet on the Pro-Israel Lobby in Britain by James Jones and Peter Oborne. You can buy it here. or you can read it on-line here, with a fine publisher's introduction by Tony Curzon Price and here is the Channel4 Distpatches presentation.

It is based on the Dispatches programme that went out on Channel 4 on 16 November. Last week I bumped into one of our leading journalists. He asked what was new with oD. I told him about the pamphlet, thinking he'd be interested. I said how it mapped the extent of the Israeli lobby and the donation patterns of the Conservative Friends of Israel (CFI).

That's not new, he said. Everyone knows that "What's the story."

There was no question mark to the way he said 'What's the story' - it was a dismissal. I was too surprised to argue back effectively. So here is part of my answer.

Donate to keep openDemocracy free

According to Oborne and Jones, after William Hague said that the 2006 Israeli assault on the Lebanon was "disproportionate" Stuart Polak of the CFI "was able to secure a meeting with David Cameron in which the Tory leader gave what was understood as an undertaking not to use the word "disproportionate" again". Now this has been reported on one of our few current affairs programmes, in the print in the pamphlet and on the web. It has not been denied. Surely this is a story.

It is also just one of the specific revelations in their account. The authors do not argue that the Israeli lobby is wrong or illegal. They suggest that if it wants to present itself as a British lobby perhaps Israeli businessmen (some, it seems, with investments in occupied territories) should not be among its funders and that it should be open and transparent about what it does.

Jones and Oborne's work has broken a taboo (which they also vividly describe). The sweep of their research is persuasive and compelling. It is a vindication that they have not been publicly attacked. But nor have their efforts been reported in the press, with the honourable exception of the Guardian. There have been no questions raised in parliament or discussions on the BBC.

But then we know it already, don't we.

Stop the secrecy: Publish the NHS COVID data deals

To: Matt Hancock, Secretary of State for Health and Social Care

We’re calling on you to immediately release details of the secret NHS data deals struck with private companies, to deliver the NHS COVID-19 datastore.

We, the public, deserve to know exactly how our personal information has been traded in this ‘unprecedented’ deal with US tech giants like Google, and firms linked to Donald Trump (Palantir) and Vote Leave (Faculty AI).

The COVID-19 datastore will hold private, personal information about every single one of us who relies on the NHS. We don’t want our personal data falling into the wrong hands.

And we don’t want private companies – many with poor reputations for protecting privacy – using it for their own commercial purposes, or to undermine the NHS.

The datastore could be an important tool in tackling the pandemic. But for it to be a success, the public has to be able to trust it.

Today, we urgently call on you to publish all the data-sharing agreements, data-impact assessments, and details of how the private companies stand to profit from their involvement.

The NHS is a precious public institution. Any involvement from private companies should be open to public scrutiny and debate. We need more transparency during this pandemic – not less.

By adding my name to this campaign, I authorise openDemocracy and Foxglove to keep me updated about their important work.

Who is bankrolling Britain's democracy? Which groups shape the stories we see in the press; which voices are silenced, and why? Sign up here to find out.


We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData