openDemocracyUK

Muddle Muddle, Toil and Trouble

John Jackson
20 May 2010

I was startled this morning to hear a Tory MP say on the Today programme that the objection to David Cameron’s wishes with regard to the 1922 Committee (he wants ministers to be eligible for membership) was that he, David C, had plainly forgotten that he was now ‘the executive’ and that as such he was separate from and accountable to Parliament.

I do not suppose that the Prime Minister has forgotten that for one moment and find the ease with which that MP equates the Parliamentary Conservatives with Parliament as such worrying. Such an assertion can be based only on either breath-taking ignorance or, more likely, a belief that, whatever is said at the hustings, our Parliament is made up by representatives of the political parties and not by representatives of the people.

The implications of that belief are undemocratic and most objectionable not least because these parliamentary party committees meet privately, in secret, and are a mechanism whereby pressure is put on governments to keep to the ideological purity of party ‘lines’.

The very necessary accountability of the executive to Parliament must involve the whole of Parliament (not just those MPs who owe allegiance to the party ‘in power’) and be conducted openly. We are not very good at this and the past thirteen years has shown what happens when an executive regards Parliament as something of a nuisance.

I hope that David Cameron  does whatever he thinks right to moderate the influence of those ‘elders’ who tend to gravitate towards membership of  the 1922 Committee and use that membership to temper the keenness of their younger back-bench brethren for progressive change. You know the technique – ‘If you want to be well regarded in this place m’boy----‘.

I hope also that someone in the constituency of that muddle headed Tory MP, who did not vote for him but trusts him to look after all his constituents interests including the holding of government to account, asks him publicly what on earth he was talking about.  

Coronavirus: Sign our petition


To: Rishi Sunak, Chancellor of the Exchequer

We welcome the steps already taken by the government to support people and businesses affected by the coronavirus.

But today, we are calling on the government to introduce an immediate liveable income guarantee for everyone living in the UK – without conditions on job seeking, migration status, savings, partner income or any other limiting factors.

This must guarantee every adult in this country an income equivalent to the real living wage (£9.30 per hour, or £372 per week).

It’s grossly unjust that the most vulnerable in our society are hit hardest by this pandemic.

To save lives now, we must urgently catch everyone in the safety net.

Who is bankrolling Britain's democracy? Which groups shape the stories we see in the press; which voices are silenced, and why? Sign up here to find out.

Comments

We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData