A shock to the system; Wales feels our collars!

The Welsh Assembly's criminalisation of electric dog collars should be welcomed
Tony Curzon Price
Tony Curzon Price
24 March 2010

The Welsh Assembly's criminalisation of electric dog collars should be welcomed. And not for the benefit of our pets – the collars might be just fine for all I know. Nor for the nannyism, which is always unwelcome. But for the example of what devolution has done to the political process. In case you didn't catch the item, anyone using an electric-shock collar on a dog or cat in Wales can face up to 6 months in prison. (But not if used on humans, we presume: Humphreys, Hitchens-like, was about to try the collar on himself, egged on by Sarah Montague. Even if he had been broadcasting from Cardiff, that would have been OK.)

The woman from the kennel club said something like: "We are very pleased that the Welsh assembly went further than we had been lobbying them to ..." She went on to say that Westminster was now also researching the question for possible national legislation.

Why do I like this so much? Here is a pressure group making change happen in one locality, making national headlines with that decision and getting the issue on the agenda nationally. This is one of the undisputable benefits of decentralisation: we feel real affinity for what happens in Cardiff. If it works or does not work there, it could work here. We pay attention to it in a way we don't pay attention to legislation in France.

The electric dog-collar case lets us imagine what a properly devolved politics might look like. Take the other bit of nannyism from this morning's news: the recommendation that smoking be banned in cars, car parks and even open parks "where children play", because of the risk to children's health. It feels both absurd and intrusive. How will it be policed, by special children's smoke wardens paid by results? By in-car CCTV and smoke alarms? The Welsh decision bans something from being used outright and like it or not seems clear and straightforward.

But the devolution point also comes in. The proposal to ban smaking where children might be found would feel a lot less threatening if it applied only in some locality that was unusually tolerant of nannyism. Then we could watch and possibly learn from it in terms of costs and consequences. And as we discover today how Chancellor Darling plans to make a start on plugging the holes in the public finances, we can meditiate on what a pity it is that we can't try out 10 different ways of rebalancing the tax system.

Hang the parliament for a hope of real devolution, I'd say.

Live discussion: Peter Oborne and ‘The Assault on Truth’

Oborne’s new book covers “Boris Johnson, Donald Trump and the emergence of a new moral barbarism”. Get the inside story on the state of the art of lying in politics and the media from three journalists who have seen it all.

Join us for this free event on 25 February at 5pm UK time/12pm EST.

Hear from:

David Leigh Journalist; former investigations editor, The Guardian

Peter Oborne Author and columnist; former chief political commentator of The Daily Telegraph

Chair, Mary Fitzgerald Editor-in-chief, openDemocracy

Save our NHS data

The UK government has snuck through a massive £23m NHS ‘data deal’ with controversial spy tech firm Palantir.

It gives this CIA-backed firm – whose spyware has been accused of creating ‘racist’ feedback loops in US policing – a major, long-term role in handling our personal health information, and in England's cherished NHS.

We believe that we, the public, should have a say about these lucrative deals before they happen, not after.

That’s why we’re bringing an urgent legal challenge: demanding public consultation on this massive deal. To do this we need your help.

We must act now to stop government secrecy around these massive deals – and to make sure our personal health information and privacy rights are protected. ‘COVID cronyism’ and secrecy must end.

Who is bankrolling Britain's democracy? Which groups shape the stories we see in the press; which voices are silenced, and why? Sign up here to find out.


We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData