Home

Tomorrow's Europe and the language problem

J Clive Matthews
19 October 2007

Nice overview article from one of Britain's leading pro-EU writers, Timothy Garton Ash, on the events of last weekend over at the Guardian. I can't say I spotted him amongst the attendees, but there were quite a few.

Garton Ash seems to have come to similar conclusions about the poll as I am heading towards, however: "More interesting than any result is the experiment itself." The reason? Simply because this was indeed the first time that people from all 27 member states were brought together in one room and allowed to chat amongst themselves in their own languages, all simultaneously interpreted.

Garton Ash mentions the Tower of Babel - a comparison made more than once during the weekend's events. Indeed, the Tomorrow's Europe poll was like the biblical Babel story in reverse - many languages effectivley becoming one and enabling co-operation, rather than one language becoming many and preventing it.

But, of course, there are always the practicalities to get in the way. There were a number of technical hitches throughout the weekend, interpretation fading in and out, and occasionally jumping to another language as the channels got crossed. Some of the interpreters were more skilled than others, leading to the occasional sensation that something significant had been missed. The sheer impossibility of having a proper discussion between people of 27 countries speaking in more than 20 languages when that would necessitate around 50 interpreters working at the same time ensured that the small groups were broken down to ensure participants were deliberating in no more than three different languages at once.

And if the practicalities got in the way even for a group of just 362 people, just what are the chances of breaking down the language barriers amongst the 500 million people that make up the EU as a whole?

"This," Garton Ash notes, "not any mind-numbing minutiae of a treaty, is the European challenge: to create fellow feeling while still speaking different languages."

In this, did the Tomorrow's Europe succeed? From what I saw of it yes - yes it did.

Had enough of ‘alternative facts’? openDemocracy is different Join the conversation: get our weekly email

Comments

We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram