Print Friendly and PDF
only search openDemocracy.net

Kyrgyzstan's conservatives hold their anti-LGBT rally

Against a background of possible legislation against 'foreign agents' and 'gay propaganda', Sunday's anti-LGBT rally in Bishkek does not bode well for the small Central Asian state.


On the morning of 14 June, around 40 people rallied in Bishkek's Gorky Park in support of a bill banning 'gay propaganda' from the small Central Asian state. In the first public anti-LGBT protest since early 2014, the young, mostly male crowd stood almost motionless, listening to speeches, occasionally clapping and cheering. 

Three policemen watched from the shade of a tree. After 90 minutes, the crowd broke up and departed, leaving Gorky Park to its usual neglected state. Although small and seemingly innocuous, the rally points to the growing political and social forces, which threaten Kyrgyzstan's status as an island of democracy in a region of authoritarian and repressive regimes.

Familiar faces

A mixture of Kyrgyz, Russian and Muslim cultures and ethnicities made up the crowd. Men wore traditional Kyrgyz kolpok hats, taqiyah and baseball caps. Speeches were made in both Russian and Kyrgyz. 

A mixture of Kyrgyz, Russian and Muslim cultures and ethnicities made up the crowd

The rally was advertised on Facebook by Nasaat Media, but the majority of speakers were members of the radical nationalist movement Kalys. Kalys style themselves as a social movement, with political aspirations and an organisational hierarchy. In June 2014, Kalys reported that they gathered 5,000 signatures in support of a 'foreign agents' bill. In Russia and elsewhere, this kind of legislation is used to discredit and impede the work of NGO organisations.

However, it is unclear where the majority of Kalys' supporters were on Sunday morning. In a display of professionalism, members at the rally wore plastic lanyards around their necks and red ribbons adorned with the Kyrgyz flag. However, Kalys are responsible for a series of violent attacks on LGBT groups: last month, members stormed an LGBT event and posted videos on You Tube with titles 'Kalys crushes the gays' and 'Disperse the fags'. 

Zhenish Moldokmatov, leader of Kyrgyzstan's Kalys movement Zhenish Moldokmatov, leader of Kyrgyzstan's Kalys movement 
Whether you consider them thugs or political operatives, Kalys boasts what every public organisation needs: a charismatic, articulate leader. Despite reportedly being charged with hooliganism after attacking LGBT groups on International Day Against Homophobia, Zhenish Moldokmatov, the head of Kalys, gave speeches at the rally wearing a suit and a kolpok. In Russian and English, Moldokmatov calmly told me that they were meeting to express their support to parliament for two bills.

Kalys boasts what every public organisation needs: a charismatic, articulate leader

The first bill would ban expressions of 'non-traditional' sexual relations, and the second, the 'foreign agents' bill, would require NGOs involved in 'political activities' to register as foreign agents. Both bills have passed a first reading in parliament. Another two successful readings in parliament and only President Atambayev's signature will be required before they become law. Although they appear different in intention, both bills mimic Russian legislation, signalling Kyrgyzstan's increasingly tight geopolitical bond to the region's political and economic powerhouse. Both bills also originate from the same desire to restrict what proponents view as corrosive foreign influence on Kyrgyz values, including homosexuality. 

Opposing values

In Gorky Park, participants carried signs reading 'homosexuality is sin'. When asked about Kalys's opposition to homosexuality, Moldokmatov said 'Homosexuality is strange for our values, for our religion, for our culture, and it is strange for Asian people. We are holding this meeting because in the last few weeks, some NGOs have started actively putting out LGBT propaganda. Labrys and others held an LGBT wedding that was out of step [with Kyrgyz values].' According to Moldokmatov, Kyrgyz values are 'family, our culture, our religion.'

According to Moldokmatov, Kyrgyz values are 'family, our culture, our religion'

When the event poster was made public two weeks ago, activists from local LGBT organisation Kyrgyz Indigo wrote to the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Prosecutor's Office and the President's Office, arguing that the rally constituted incitement to hatred. 

Citing the title of the poster ('We are against gays and lesbians. Are you?'), and images of clenched fists and blood splattered over the word 'gay', Kygryz Indigo argued that the rally would violate the constitutional prohibition of hate speech. 

They also argued that the 'gay propaganda' law would violate Articles 16 and 20 of the Constitution, which protect freedom of expression and assembly. As yet, Kyrgyz Indigo has received no official response. Ruslan Kim, Director of Advocacy for Kyrgyz Indigo, told me that the decision to permit the rally appears to have been based on the constitutional right of prospective participants to publicly express their views – a constitutional right that Kalys are fighting to have removed from the LGBT community.

50/50

In addition to their anti-LGBT activities, Kalys are also strongly backing the 'foreign agents' bill. Zhenish Moldokmatov explained to me: 'Kyrgyzstan has the right to check the transparency of these organisations [NGOs]. There are some that are destructive. The laws that have so far been adopted are threatening the national security of Kyrgyzstan – they are allowing organisations to propagate values that are alien to our culture. They get involved in our politics.'

This development is extremely concerning to NGOs operating within the country. They believe the bill will be used to restrict civil and human rights work. 

Kalys supporters rally in Kyrgyzstan's capital Bishkek in support of a bill against 'gay propaganda' Kalys supporters rally in Kyrgyzstan's capital Bishkek in support of a bill against 'gay propaganda' 
Tolekan Ismailova, Chairperson of Bir Duino, the leading human rights organisation in Kyrgyzstan, told me last week that after years of being attacked by religious or nationalist groups, she believes that finally the Kyrgyz Parliament is targeting her organisation. Bir Duino's offices in the southern town of Osh were recently raided by security services and, pointing to a damaged safe in her office, Ismailova explained that their Bishkek offices have also been targeted. 

Bir Duino is one of only a handful of NGOs that publicly support the LGBT community. Ismailova acknowledged that their opposition to the 'gay propaganda' bill may be another reason that they are currently being targeted. However, she said that Bir Duino believe that LGBT rights are human rights and warned that the government will not stop at the persecution of LGBT people.

At the rally, the few women in attendance were momentarily joined by two more. When I asked one of them what she thought of the rally, Rosa speculated that the only reason the men attended was because they are unemployed and bored. However, she explained that she supported their cause, saying 'How is it possible that in a Muslim country, women live with women and men with men? Maybe there are people who live like that, but it should not be out in public.'

Not everyone was fully convinced by Kalys's rhetoric however. One young man observed the rally from a bench 20 metres away. He did not wish to disclose his name, but he told me: 'Democracy has both good and bad sides. We cannot accept European values just yet because we are an Islamic country, and LGBT is a European thing.' 

When I asked him if he supported Kalys's aims, he paused and replied: '50/50.'

All photos courtesy of the author. 

About the author

Georgina Rannard is a Senior Fellow at Humanity in Action, and is currently finishing a PhD in Economic History. Follow her on twitter @lapicescongoma


We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the
oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.