Print Friendly and PDF
only search

The Tories and Labour (40 reasons to support Scottish independence, 32, 33 & 34)

Scotland has been rejecting the Conservatives for almost all of the party's history yet has often been governed by them; independence will be bad for the Conservatives, and Labour offer no hope - three more of 40 reasons to support Scottish independence.

Anthony Eden: the last Tory Prime Minister to get Scotland's backing/Wikimedia

32) No more Conservative rule

Scotland elected one Tory MP in the last general election yet still there is a Tory government in power.” Katie Sutherland, National Collective

Scotland's tradition of voting against the Conservative party isn't a recent fad. In the 45 elections between the 1832 Great Reform Act (and the foundation of the party) and today, MPs who would go on to sit on the Tory benches have won most votes in Scotland on a total of five occasions, the last of which was 49 years ago.

In each of these occasions, most of these MPs stood not as Conservatives, but for a separate Scottish led sister party “the Unionist party”. In three of the elections (1918, 1931, 1935), they were standing as a part of a “national government” coalition ticket during a major crisis. In the other two (1951, 1955), they only secured their winning vote share once their ballots are added to those from their allies in the National Liberal Party – a split from the Liberals.

Whilst, eventually, a different right of centre party might emerge in Scotland, independence almost certainly means never again having to live under a Conservative government.

33) Disaster for the Tories

conservative parties are rooted in specific circumstances, particular traditions – if that vital context disappears then so does our purpose. What’s the point of the Conservative and Unionist Party without a Union?” - Peter Franklin, ConservativeHome, 7 April 2014.

“David Cameron will resign if he loses Scotland” says Benedict Brogen in the Telegraph “A Prime Minister who allows the break-up of the United Kingdom cannot suffer such a statement of no confidence and continue in office. That much is understood in Downing Street, where a gnawing doubt about the referendum gets worse by the day.”

Unlike Brogen, I have no special knowledge of what Cameron will do – he himself has said he won't go, though the fact he had to comment at all is telling, and it is the kingmakers who would make such a call, not the king. But we can be sure of this: if it is a yes vote, it'll be a political earthquake across the UK – the sort of event from which governments rarely emerge intact. As things stand, there seems a good chance Labour will lose the next election (though, who knows?). If Scotland votes yes, Labour might lose some MPs, but the Tories will have lost the confidence of the country and the historic British state they exist to run.

This is much longer term than the next election. As Peter Franklin says on ConservativeHome, right wing parties are built around particular national circumstances. You can't disentangle the historic success of the Britain's Tories from the unchanged nature of Britain's constitution and the long shadow of empire across our self image. Scottish independence would begin to change those things and, as Franklin puts it: “would be a disaster for Labour, but a death blow to the Conservatives”.

34) The Labour Party & the lack of hope

we are going to have to keep all these cuts” - Ed Balls

If there was a genuine prospect of real change within the current British State, perhaps independence wouldn't be worth the hassle. But it's not the Tories who are guilty of there being no hope – they play the appropriate democratic role of a right of centre party. It's Labour.

A yes vote doesn't guarantee a fairer country, but it offers a chance of it. Look to the current Labour leadership: they are promising to attack young unemployed people; apologising that, whilst they were imprisoning children for being a) foreigners and b) in Britain, they were too soft on migration; they insist that they will match the Tory's cuts – and remember that this is the incarnation of Labour led by the candidate chosen by the left of the party.

A yes vote offers at least offers a opportunity to win change. The best hope if it's a no vote is a Labour government; and that gives no hope of change at all.

Liked this piece? Please donate to OurKingdom here to help keep us writing about the Scottish referendum. Thank you.

About the author

Adam Ramsay is the Co-Editor of openDemocracyUK and also works with Bright Green. Before, he was a full time campaigner with People & Planet. You can follow him at @adamramsay.

Related Articles
40 reasons to support Scottish independence - reasons 1-3
Adam Ramsay
40 reasons to support Scottish independence, 4-6: Westminster, Britain and Better Together
Adam Ramsay
40 reasons to support Scottish independence - reasons 7 & 8: interdependence and federalism
Adam Ramsay
40 reasons to support Scottish independence: 9, 10, 11: The West Lothian question & problems with devo-max
Adam Ramsay
40 reasons to support Scottish independence: 12, 13, 14: the coming British crash
Adam Ramsay
40 reasons to support Scottish independence: reason 15: austerity
Adam Ramsay
40 reasons to support Scottish independence: reason 16: the flotilla effect and why smaller countries are richer
Adam Ramsay
If you spend but don't collect taxes, you can't invest (40 reasons to support Scottish independence: 17)
Adam Ramsay
Unleash creative energy; save NHS Scotland: (40 reasons to support Scottish independence: 18 & 19)
Adam Ramsay
A new nation or an old empire?; Trident: (40 reasons to support independence, 20 and 21)
Adam Ramsay
Faith, education, linguistics and diverging paths (40 reasons to support Scottish independence: 22 & 23)
Adam Ramsay
The environmental case for yes (40 reasons to support Scottish independence: 24 & 25)
Adam Ramsay
The path to independence is well trodden; the union of 1707 has been replaced (40 reasons to support Scottish independence: 28 & 29)
Adam Ramsay
Networks defeat hierarchies; a new constitution (40 reasons to support Scottish independence, 30 & 31)
Adam Ramsay
A blow to the British class system; look who is on each side (40 reasons to support Scottish independence, 35 & 36)
Adam Ramsay
Why stay in a club you wouldn't join? (40 reasons to support Scottish independence, 37)
Adam Ramsay
Scottish nationalism or British nationalism? (40 reasons to support Scottish independence: 38)
Adam Ramsay
Change vs more of the same (40 reasons to support Scottish independence, 39)
Adam Ramsay

We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the
oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.