> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.opendemocracy.net/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# ‘Will it be settled before I die?’: Miners seek urgent fix to pension promise
- URL: https://www.opendemocracy.net/will-it-be-settled-before-i-die-miners-seek-urgent-fix-to-pension-promise/
- Published: 2026-11-18T12:47:10.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-18T12:47:10.000Z
- Description: Labour MPs in Coalfield constituencies threaten Burnham’s first Commons rebellion over delay to miners’ pension payout
- Author: Ethan Shone
- Tags: miners, pensions, Andy Burnham, John Healey, Labour

The growing resentment among many former miners over the government’s continued refusal to set out a timeline to release £1.2bn from their pension fund could lead to Andy Burnham’s first rebellion in the Commons, openDemocracy understands.

A meeting between chancellor John Healey and the chair of the Mineworkers Pension Scheme (MPS) trustees last week failed to result in any concrete steps toward transferring the remaining funds to former miners. Instead, the pair agreed to work together to resolve the matter “within the coming weeks”.

But for many miners and their families, who expected the money to be released at last month’s Budget and paid out by Christmas, this is not good enough. 

“As a widow of a miner who worked underground for many years and died of a mining-related illness, pneumoconiosis, I am so angry this surplus is not being released to the MPS trustees,” Bernadette France, a longtime activist from the Women Against Pit Closures movement, told openDemocracy.

“How many miners have to die? I am nearly 80; will I expect to get this settled before I die? There is no justification for it to be delayed,” she added. “The members’ money built this surplus; every penny belongs to them. As a Labour government, do the honourable thing and get it settled.”

Labour MPs representing coalfield constituencies are still pushing the government hard to speed up the process. openDemocracy understands they believe they have found a way to force a debate on this in the coming weeks if the issue is not resolved. 

Kate Osbone, the party’s MP for Jarrow and Gateshead East in the north-east of England, said: “I have been clear that the remaining £1.2bn in the Mineworkers’ Pension Scheme Guarantor’s Fund belongs to former miners and their widows, and I was deeply disappointed that it was not released at the Budget.

“While this Labour government has already taken significant steps to address this historic injustice, including returning £1.5bn to members, there is still more to do. I have met with ministers and the Chancellor to discuss this. Alongside fellow Coalfield MPs, we have called for the remaining funds to be released without further delay.

“I will pursue all parliamentary processes and keep fighting until all the remaining funds are with the people they belong to.”

**‘They built the wealth of our country’**

After British Coal was privatised in 1994, the Treasury agreed to guarantee workers’ pensions in exchange for 50% of any investment surplus. As the funds didn’t fall into deficit, the Treasury never paid into them, but still gained access to the reserves. The National Union of Mineworkers estimates that miners have lost out on more than £4.4bn as a result.

Former chancellor Rachel Reeves released one of the MPS’ funds in 2024 and the sole fund for the British Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme, whose members were generally better-paid, non-mining staff, last year. 

The Guarantor’s Fund is now the final pension pot to be paid out. After assurances from ministers, miners, campaigners and coalfield MPs believed Healey would release it last month – a move that would not cost taxpayers – and were left furious when his Budget failed to set out a timetable for doing so.

Dozens of members of the scheme have already died in the three weeks since the Budget, the MPS told openDemocracy. Many fear they will not live to see their hard-fought campaign for pension justice finally achieve its full aims.

Coalfield MPs have since been lobbying hard both in Parliament and behind the scenes to secure the release of the funds, and have threatened to rebel against the Finance Bill if the matter is not resolved urgently.

This pressure resulted in a meeting between Healey and Gary Saunders, the chair of the MPS Trustees, last week. The meeting took place around midday on Thursday, but the statement agreed by both parties was not released until almost midnight that night.

“The chancellor and Mr Saunders had a full discussion about the issue,” the statement said. “The chancellor has agreed to work with MPS Trustees and their advisers to find a way to resolve this issue within the coming weeks.” 

The government has continually said it will release the funds eventually. But many miners – who say they have heard similar promises from politicians in the past – are hesitant to take this in good faith, especially as no explanation has been offered for the last-minute U-turn. 

Neal Seargent, a former miner from Barnsley, told openDemocracy: “We were very disappointed that at the 12th hour, the agreement the MPS had with the government was pulled and no one will say why, or by whom. We need transparency from the government. 

“I’m not sure how many of the original miners that started the campaign for pensions justice are left – I know of at least three that are no longer with us. I run a Facebook group for my old workmates, and almost all we get now are posts about who has died recently.”

As openDemocracy reported, MPs believe the cash was not released due to a “blunder” by the Treasury the night before Healey’s speech to Parliament. Speaking after the Budget, the prime minister told ITV News that the money “does have to be scored on the public balance sheet and that is part of the challenge that we’ve got”.

Yet reindustrialisation minister Blair McDougall confirmed last week that the fund’s release will not require any changes to accounting rules. 

Jon Trickett, the Labour MP for the constituency of Normanton and Hemsworth in West Yorkshire, has been among the miners’ most vocal advocates. He told openDemocracy: “I will always stand by the miners; they built the wealth of our country. I will do everything possible to get the matter resolved, including raising the issue in parliament to force the government to fulfill their promises in weeks, not months. 

“There is an urgency about this which is clear from the correspondence I am receiving from the former miners, many of whom are angry and feeling let down. I hope the government will be as good as its word and resolve the Guarantor’s Fund imminently.”