Quote of the day

My students taught me that everything was personal - history, politics, foreign relations - but this approach creates boundaries as well as connections

Syndicate content

Navigation


View 4 comments

Greece: the political ecology of disaster

The raging forest fires are a political scandal as well as an environmental catastrophe, says Chronis Polychroniou.

Greece is experiencing an environmental catastrophe. Forest fires are raging through the centre and south of the country, from the Peloponnese to the island of Evoia, near Athens. Sixty-three people have been killed and scores more injured as of 26 August 2007 (a figure that seems certain to rise); many thousands of people have been forced to flee their homes, amid the destruction of entire villages and cultivated landscapes.

Chronis Polychroniou is head of academic affairs at Mediterranean College in Athens, Greece

The crisis has been escalating since late June, when the most intense heatwave in Greece in over a century saw temperatures climb above 40 degrees Celsius for six consecutive days. One forest fire spilled over Mount Parnitha, twenty-five kilometers north of Athens, and turned into ashes the last oasis of lush greenery and semi-wildlife to be found in the Attica region. The scene was an apocalyptic one of utter desolation and destruction, with blazing fires and billowing smoke rising high into the sky. To the fury of many of Attica's 4.5 million people, the authorities had miscalculated the direction of the winds.

In a single day, some 130 different kinds of birds, forty-five different types of mammals including a very rare type of a deer, and thirty different types of amphibians and reptiles vanished in the monster fires that devoured Mount Parnitha.

The Peloponnese fires that raged on the weekend of 25-26 August - as many as 190 separate blazes in total, which provoked the declaration of a state of national emergency by the government - have again exposed the incapacity of the state. A lack of government coordination meant that the armed forces were not deployed, even as ancient Olympia was threatened by the wildfires. The public statements of prime minister Kostas Karamanlis and (especially) his hapless public-order minister Byron Polydoras have become ever more unconvincing. It may be true that, as a frenzied government campaign announces, arsonists are to blame for many of the fires (and some alleged perpetrators have been arrested); but Polydoras's talk of "asymmetrical threats" is an ill-judged endorsement of the language of geopolitics.

Furies of destruction

This crisis demands a longer perspective and a larger mindset than Greek politicians are currently offering. Since the mid-1980s, Greece's forests have been shrinking at an alarming rate, and few of them - even before the current tragedy - retained their historic beauty and diversity. With summers becoming hotter every year and the craving for land development and construction ever more insatiable, wildfires have been growing more severe and destructive. The result is to face the nation with the prospect of an ecological nightmare that will condemn Greece's current and future generations - Athens is already the most polluted of all European capitals - to inhuman conditions.

The ecological and environmental crisis engulfing Greece also highlights the deep flaws of the contemporary Greek political and social landscape. The inefficient and dilatory official response to the burgeoning crisis has revealed a public-administration system staffed by poorly trained personnel (who in key areas collude with bribery-fuelled illegal building in forested areas); a political elite which caters largely to the needs of its financial patrons, and bickers over which of the leading parties (the ruling New Democracy and the opposition Pasok) steals more from the national treasury when in power; and a disillusioned, cynical citizenry.

Would London or New York tolerate large-scale illegal construction in area designated as forest parks? In Greece, as near to the centres of power and legitimacy as the outer suburbs of Athens, even the public-utility companies become part of the corrupt "exchange system" as in many cases they end up providing the owners of the new structures with access to electricity and water.

This, then, is a civic and political disaster as well as an environmental one. The Greek state is visibly ill-equipped to cope; it is dependent on technical assistance from its European Union partners in the short-term effort of firefighting and fire-prevention, and has no developed long-term plan that meets the needs of forest restoration and ecological management. Greek governments' lack of political will and governing capacity in dealing with the problem of forest fires (including those started deliberately) represents the national disgrace of the entire political and judicial system.

Winds of change

All nations at important moments in their history face pivotal moments when they must urgently address pressing matters of great collective concern if they are to avoid regression. For Greece, such a moment has arrived. Unfortunately, neither of the two major political parties that have taken turns to govern the nation since the end of military rule in 1974 have displayed the administrative competence or the intellectual understanding now required to address the ecological threat confronting the country. If the general election scheduled for 16 September 2007 goes ahead in the wake of this crisis, it may become an opportunity to deliver a verdict on the incompetence of the New Democracy government; but the problems exposed by the wildfires evidently go far deeper than a mere change of administration would correct.

The nation is in dire need of new, bold, courageous leadership. It urgently requires a long-term strategy that pioneers will a sea-change in the country's approach towards the environment. Shortcuts will be very dangerous. Complacency may be fatal. Moral consciousness must be awakened and a grand vision needs to be developed to avert the nation's ecological collapse.

It is a genuine shame that a country that gave form and shape to democracy and civil virtue and once prided itself on the cultivation of aesthetics as the true meaning of life today displays astounding mental perversity in sacrificing the environment and its ecological system on the altar of greed and political clientilism. This is a true Greek tragedy.

May the wind-breathing gods of change come to life and spare my country from the political ecology of disaster. If they do not, even worse is to come.

Average rating
(4 votes)

Trackback URL for this post:

http://www.opendemocracy.net/trackback/34453
from Parody in Blue on Thu, 2007-08-30 18:28

The fire crisis is far from over. There are resurgent fire fronts in the Peloponnese and fire crews are battling to keep the flames from reaching populated areas. The Karamanlis government is now engaged in an unprecedented cash-on-demand exercise in

from buzz on Tue, 2007-08-28 08:35

"It is a genuine shame that a country that gave form and shape to democracy and civil virtue and once prided itself on the cultivation of aesthetics as the true meaning of life today displays astounding mental perversity in sacrificing the environment ...

further links
 
Copyright © Chronis Polychroniou, . Published by openDemocracy Ltd. You may download and print extracts from this article for your own personal and non-commercial use only. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation. Contact us if you wish to discuss republication. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.

Anthony Barnett said:



Tue, 2007-08-28 20:54

This is the statement I have just recieved from PASOK the main opposition party:

In the face of the greatest environmental catastrophe in modern Greek history, PASOK President George Papandreou last night called for national unity and mobilisation in order to contain the crisis and provide immediate relief to the victims. "Our immediate priority is that no more lives be lost, no more houses and livelihoods destroyed. We must save whatever we can of our beautiful natural environment. We must save our historic monuments, the symbols of Hellenism. We must mobilize all our forces for the urgent reconstruction of our nation."

Papandreou criticised the New Democracy government for seeking to cover up its failure to manage the crisis by diverting responsibility to "asymmetrical threats" and "an organised plot by arsonists". "The truth is that arsonists exist and have always existed; and all Greeks demand that they are brought to justice and punished…Instead of dealing with this national crisis in a serious and responsible manner, even at the eleventh hour, the government is cultivating fear, insecurity, extremism and division."

Government officials have even implied that PASOK and political extremists could be behind the fires. The government has invoked anti-terror laws and arrested arson suspects - including pensioners and children – even as fires rage unchecked across the country. "These asymmetrical threats are asymmetrical nonsense…If there are no facts, if there is no reliable evidence, then this "asymmetrical threat" is no more than a pretext for the government to cover up the paralysis of the state, and its own failure to prevent this national tragedy. A national tragedy that constitutes a crime against the nation, against the Greek people, against the environment, and against future generations."

Papandreou called for compassion, solidarity and urgent action to help those in need. To this end, PASOK is drafting a plan for the social, economic and environmental reconstruction of the afflicted areas. "A reconstruction plan that will put a crippled nation back on its feet based on rules, principles, meritocracy and transparency. That will bring back hope, prospects, and a smile on the face of every Greek citizen." Read the full English text of Papandreou's speech here

login or register to post comments | email this comment

ianniscarras said:



Wed, 2007-08-29 08:00
The fires do constitute a tragedy, all one has to do is to pass by some of the entirely burnt regions - including farmland as well as forest land - to realise that this is the case. If 'snoke' in a TV binge-inspire response to human suffering has become hardened to emotion, so much the worse for him or her. The question however is why this has occurred to such an extent at this time. It is important to remember that apart from climatic conditions which are optimal for the spread of wildfires, the future of the Greek forests has been a major issue over the last year in the Greek political system. The current government of the right-wing New Democracy party has tried to change the constitution in order to permit widespread development on forest land and also on the coasts, following the Spanish model of 'Build, Build, Build'. The previous Socialist government failed to complete the long promised land registry, leading to the withdrawal of EU funds for the project, perhaps due to corruption. The current government has made no effort to renew it, leaving Greece as the only EU country without a land registry (and also without a Ministry of the Environment, something astonishing given the importance of the issue). A forest registry is set to be completed in about a year, meaning that the expropriation and building on forest land should be harder thereafter. In this context it should be clear that now was the optimal time for those who wish to exploit the forests for personal gain to act. Though it would be wrong to put all the blame on the current government, given that the previous one was also remiss and Greece's patronage networks and the funding of parties by construction companies mean that politicians have an incentive to overlook forest destruction and illegal development, the current New Democracy government has been the worst on the record in this respect. Souflias, the Minister of Public Works - through his policies - has all but condoned the undermining of protection of the forests. He has for example been fanatical in his support of the redirection of the Acheloos river to fund increased (EU funded) cotton production in the region where he is elected and he also stated that Natura areas should be opened up for development. Greece's economic wealth stems to an extraordinarily large extent on tourism, which means on the environment. Having voted for New Democracy at the last election, I have come to the conclusion that a government that does not understand the importance of the environment, a government which in other words has done so much to undermine the future prosperity of Greece does not deserve to remain in power after the 16th September elections. Iannis Carras, Athens, Greece.
login or register to post comments | email this comment

sooke said:



Thu, 2007-08-30 10:34
The sky is falling! The sky is falling! Lets see - all the forests and wildlife of Greece are gone, temperatures are higher than ever, pollution is the worst in Europe, and the government is corrupt. Any corroboration for all these claims? Chronis Polychroniou sensationizes this tragedy to the point of absurdity. Sixty three deaths does not make an apocalypse. How many Greeks die in car accidents each year? It is articles like this one that reveal more about the storyteller than the story.
login or register to post comments | email this comment

Greek Tragedy said:



Thu, 2008-02-07 14:21

Indeed Greece is a shithole with no bottom to this abyss of government corruption and corruption in multi-national companies. Ordinary people get treated like dirt in Greece and there is no meritocracy based on skills, knowledge and aptitude or ability. The media, television and the government is ruled by rogues, criminals and people of “total nothingness”. Basically the only thing that will save Greece is a bloody revolution. What can one say when the only ambitions of Greeks are to own a Cayenne or some other overly priced gas guzzling SUV, when government, local authorities and companies are behind the destructive fires of last summer which burnt at least a third of the country - where the price of a coffee is 5 euros where people are threatened by their managers to work up to 11 at night in multinational companies with no extra pay because they too are subject to fraudulent tactics, where people do not know their basic human rights and even if they do there is no way of fighting for these, where the justice system is constantly bribed and all judges and lawyers involved in black money and shady contracts, where the minister of employment employs illegal immigrants with no social security and moreover, was hiding income and property from the IRS and he is still free rather than having being locked up in jail for 30 years, where nobody wants to get involved in anyhting of substance, where unemployment is rife among qualified personnel almost 30% (do not believe government figures - they are false) because jobs are held by people of “nothingness” earning 600 euros per month - illegal pay according to EU law - I too, was a victim in the last company I worked for Proodos S.A. - Seafreight Department where the obnoxious and inferiority complexed manager coerced me and threatened me on a daily basis to stay in the office until 11 at night with 1000 euros pay - where everything sucks - where people purposefully and willingly destroy the environment for profit where if people do not take power into their own hands Greece will turn into a disaster without rebait and without return.

Unfortunately Greece is not worthy of anything anymore - all people care about is to buy a Cayenne or another environmentally unfriendly gas guzzling SUV, destroy their forests and natural habitats, appear on a cheap show on the abismal and subcrap Greek television, work in companies with euro 600 per month up to 11 o’ clock at night and the only things banks do is to dish out more loans as though they were chocolates.

I will do my best to discourage people from visiting my country be it for business or holidays - we deserve the worst!!

PROUD TO BE GREEK BUT DISMALLY ASHAMED OF LIVING IN GREECE.

login or register to post comments | email this comment