The Sri Lankan Tamil community may not be the largest of the diaspora communities represented in London or other such greatly diverse cities around the world, but the numbers and conviction they have mobilised in recent days to highlight the plight of their brethren at home have been exceptional. The demonstrations by Tamils in the centres of London, Toronto and other cities have been spectacular, defiant and spirited displays of grief and anger: men, women, and many young people have gathered with colourful flags and banners, staged sit-ins, and chanted slogans, while several of their number have promised to fast unto death.
Nirmala Rajasingam is a Sri Lankan Tamil activist who lives in exile in London. She is a member of the steering committee of the Sri Lanka Democracy Forum (SLDF), an international network of progressive diaspora voices. She was the first woman to be detained under the Prevention of Terrorism Act in the early 1980s, survived the government-engineered Welikade prison massacre, and was subsequently freed from prison by LTTE guerrillas. She left the LTTE as a result of the lack of internal democracy within the movement and its serious human-rights abuses.
Nirmala Rajasingam is the sister of Rajani Thiranagama, founder-member of the University Teachers for Human Rights (Jaffna), who was assassinated by the LTTE for her outspoken views. They are the subjects of the documentary film No More Tears Sister (National Film Board of Canada) Their slogans are simple: "Genocide!", "Pirapaharan is our leader!", and "We want Tamil Eelam!". These references to the leader of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) and the aspiration to an independent state in northern Sri Lanka are accompanied by the touting of images of this figure and the waving of flags showing the Tiger emblem. Several parliamentarians in Britain and Canada have voiced support for the demonstrators.
The humanitarian situation in parts of northern Sri Lanka - especially in the narrow strip of land around Mullaitivu - is indeed desperate, as the Sri Lankan army's advances have continued and as they lay siege to LTTE redoubts where approximately 100,000 civilians are confined - the latest stage of a long war that has persisted since 1983 (see "Sri Lanka's displaced: the political vice", 8 April 2009).
The cries of genocide have risen with the intensification of the military campaign and a sharp turn for the worse in the fortunes of the Tamil Tigers. They have spread too beyond the official Tiger propaganda stream (radio, TV and newspapers); the blood-splattered images and messages have inundated cyberspace: via Facebook and YouTube and other cyberspace outlets, via a torrent of emails, the drenching claim is simple, direct and frightening: genocide. This campaign has mobilised even those who had never been politically involved before.
The sorrows of commitment
The genocide alert is at heart about the trapped civilians in Mullaitivu. But the truth about the horrific circumstances in which civilians are stranded there is not stated in full. They are caught between two armies, each of which seeks to use them as pawns in this war. The government forces have shown no inhibition in bombing and shelling indiscriminately into crowded civilian areas, schools and hospitals as long as their military objective of crushing the Tigers is achieved. But the civilians are dying not only as a result of such bombardments or in crossfire; for credible reports indicate that Tigers are not allowing civilians to move out of the line of fire and escape to government-controlled areas, and may be going further to prevent attempts to flee.
It has long been established that many children have been forcibly recruited into the ranks of the Tigers, and that such cadres are forewarned that their families would be wiped out if they surrender. Now, as the Tigers' military situation becomes more and more desperate, the logic of their own anti-civilian approach is apparent: for the Tamil civilian presence now provides the only chance of ensuring the Tiger leadership's survival.
It is striking, however, that in all the demonstrations not a single cry, slogan or placard seems to demand that the Tigers should let the civilians go or cease their own assaults on them. The silence of the diaspora community on this issue is deafening. The general support for the Tamils' cause has in the public arena collapsed into one soundbite. There is no recognition in these demonstrations of the fact that the military objectives of the LTTE are no longer reconcilable with the safety of the trapped civilians. There is a disjunction between propaganda and reality here that reflects the way the logic of Tamil Tiger propaganda has become internalised by much of the diaspora. This does nothing to help Sri Lankan Tamils.
Such spectacular demonstrations have the potential to send a powerful message to the international community about the true nature of the predicament of the trapped civilians. Why then do the demonstrators fail to highlight this. Why have they not also raised their voices against Tiger atrocities as well as the government's? Why do they elide the horrifying predicament of the civilians with the political interest of the Tigers?
What makes these questions even more pertinent is that the huge demonstrations in the west that endorse the LTTE are in direct opposition to the waning popular support for the LTTE amongst Tamils in Sri Lanka itself. The eastern region of Sri Lanka where many Tamils live - and which has lost far more of its young people and children in this war than any other Tamil region - has largely abandoned support for an independent state. The Jaffna peninsula in the north has been largely uninvolved for more than a decade or so in the separatist cause; there, the vast majority of civilians have submitted to uneasy cohabitation with the army simply because amid available options, they prefer an absence of war. The LTTE's cynical and callous use of civilians for its war effort has also over the years undermined its status within the Tamil population in Sri Lanka.
There are other considerations absent from the demonstrators' concerns. The escalating military campaigns have placed great pressure on civilians for months, yet there have been no demonstrations to highlight the plight of those commandeered to retreat and follow the Tigers in the wake of government army advances - for example, those from the Mannar area in the western part of the northern province, who had to follow the trail of the Tiger retreat all the way across the Vanni jungles to their current pocket on the eastern coast of the Vanni. Many of these civilians had been corralled out of Jaffna at gunpoint by the LTTE in 1995 during the first big and enforced Pol-Pot-style exodus.
The frenzied demonstrations have begun only when the military defeat of the LTTE appears a real prospect. Again, the confusion between humanitarian protest and political solidarity with the LTTE is evident. But this still leaves open the question: what explains the widespread support that the LTTE enjoys in the diaspora despite its declining fortunes in Sri Lanka, and the atrocities it commits against ordinary Tamil people there?
The political war
The answer to this question lies in part in general conditions experienced by the Sri Lankan Tamil diaspora community, and in part in the particular role of the LTTE in establishing its political dominance within it.
The Tamils in the west have like many other migrant communities from the global south faced racist discrimination, exclusion, social isolation and economic deprivation. Their search for membership of and integration with "host" societies is, even in the best of circumstances, difficult. The result is that Tamil communities often lead culturally and socially a ghettoised life in which they - in an attempt to preserve "Tamil cultural and social heritage" in these new environs - construct anew a self-conscious way of "being Tamil" or of "living as Tamil". This has meant the mushrooming of Tamil cultural organisations, self-help groups, Tamil schools, businesses and temples. This pattern is in itself not an unusual phenomenon with migrant communities. But with the Tamils, there is an unusual twist.
The LTTE in the course of its military and political campaign decimated all other political opinion within the Tamil polity in Sri Lanka, in order to establish itself as the "sole representative" of the Tamil people. At the same time, it began to flex its muscles within the Tamil community in the west. Its representatives moved in on community groups, temples, Tamil schools and businesses and took control of many of them. In time its stranglehold over the diaspora communities - including through methods of intimidation, assault, and threats to families in Sri Lanka - became an accomplished fact. Paris and Toronto were prime examples of the phenomenon, where unquestioning compliance was demanded and wrought.
The intimidation of independent media outlets is a key arm of this strategy. The LTTE has for a generation sought to dominate the "Tamil narrative" - martial, dogmatic, missionary, zealous, leader-fixated - with many tales of military valour, of brave conquests against a marauding Sri Lankan army, of resolute "final wars", of "operation motherland redemptions". To a great extent it has succeeded.
The Tiger lobbyists, fundraisers and propagandists in the diaspora are relentless in attempting to enforce submission to this narrative and its command performances. Even for events such as "martyrs' day" celebrations or the funeral of the LTTE ideologist Anton Balasingam, thousands are mobilised and bussed in. Every tragic event is turned into a fundraising opportunity.
Also on Sri Lanka in openDemocracy:
Alan Keenan, "Sri Lanka's election choice" (17 November 2005)
Alan Keenan, "Sri Lanka: between peace and war" (14 May 2006)
Meenakshi Ganguly, "Sri Lanka: time to act" (10 September 2006)
Nira Wickramasinghe, "Sri Lanka: the politics of purity" (17 November 2006)
Irfan Husain, "Sri Lanka: giving war a chance" (8 February 2007)
Nira Wickramasinghe, "Multiculturalism: a view from Sri Lanka" (30 May 2007)
Sumantra Bose, "Sri Lanka's stalemated conflict" (12 June 2007)
Meenakshi Ganguly, "Sri Lanka under siege" (30 January 2009)
Meenakshi Ganguly, "Sri Lanka's displaced: the political vice" (8 April 2009) A whole class of Tiger operatives has become affluent through being involved in the Eelam enterprise. Many have vested interests in its continued mobilisation, independent of the political situation or tragedies involving civilians. Moreover, the Tamil diaspora also sports a financially powerful and influential class of educated professionals and businesspeople who are also in many ways implicated in the Eelam roadshow and help to buttress it for social and other reasons.
The diaspora gaze
The outcome of this lengthy process of political manipulation is that the vast majority of Tamil homes in the diaspora are exposed to "Tamil" news that is heavily weighted towards LTTE propaganda - and it is a perspective that feeds into news about the rest of the world, not just Sri Lanka, as well. The LTTE channels provide a daily diet of culture and politics: everything is seen though the Tiger lens, including the international community's attitude to the conflict in Sri Lanka and to the Tigers.
The diaspora Tamil community has been acculturated to the LTTE message for a good part of two decades. But the message is the work of more than intimidation; its potency draws on and appeals to that aspect of life in exile which makes meaningful and satisfying the sense of abstract belonging to a homeland - especially if there is no tangible possibility of return in the immediate future. A "captive" audience that lives to a great degree in its own social and cultural bubble, determined to hold fast to the "Tamil culture" finds the mythical call for an independent Tamil state all the more attractive.
In this way the enterprise of preserving Tamil culture and Tamil way of living is wedded to the political quest for the independent state. At a moment when Tamil nationalism of the strident and dogmatic - indeed totalitarian - kind espoused by the LTTE is beginning to lose its flavour with Tamils in Sri Lanka, it is very much alive in the diaspora; and the Tigers are determined to use the serious military setbacks that they have experienced to entrench it further.
When in Sri Lanka itself the Tigers peddle the dream of an independent state of Tamil Eelam, many people recall aspects of the LTTE's own record: the 1995 exodus, the eviction of Muslims, abductions of their children, the waste of lives, the internal and internecine killings, the fanatical hero-worship. Their tangible experiences are evidence that the Tigers' brand of uncompromising politics leads to suffering and death. The result is increasing questioning and dissent - including about Sri Lanka's political future, the interests of the Tamils and how a sustainable and democratic future can be built after decades of war.
For diaspora Tamils living far removed from the day-to-day problems of living with the Tigers in battle, it is much easier to support the LTTE's zero-sum solution.
For the Tiger lobby and their its large bank of support - as well as for many young diaspora Tamils whose compassion and concern is as yet unmatched by independent sources of information and argument on events in Sri Lanka - the complex questions of democratisation, demilitarisation, cohabitation with other communities and the search for political settlement of the conflict appear to be immaterial. The suffering of civilians only helps to further reinforce the "imaginary" of an independent state of Tamil Eelam as the only solution. The destructive logic of the Tiger cause is to annihilate political reason and progress in favour of a totalitarian fantasy of power and control. Those who dream from afar have a responsibility to think harder, to look deeper, and to break through to reality.



Comments
A super analysis. very refreshing compared to the biased analysis of most foreign journalists
Round and round the Eelam
Like the tamil people.
One step, two step,
We all fall down.
Seated upon tiger skin,
Garlanded with snake,
Preach Momma preach,
We all fall down.
***Per Srilankan government publication The great chronicles of Srilanka chapter 22 para 14, http://lakdiva.org/mahavamsa/,
Sinhala queen Viharamahadevi had … urge to drink the water used to wash a sword that had cleaved the head of a warrior of (TAMIL king) Elara , whilst standing on that same head.
Sword on the Srilankan Flag originates from this horrible history.
*** in 1948 millions of Tamils were stribed of their citizenship, Tigers were not there at that time.
** in 1956 sinhala only act was passed tigers were not there at that time.
*** in 1960s sinhala colanisation was inplemented tigers were not there at that time.
*** in 1972 Bhudism was implemented as only religion, tigers were not there at that time.
Important racial riots
Srilankan Tamils also victims of riots 1915 , 1956 , 1958, 1977 , 1983 , 2001 , mid 2006 , oct 2006 during which TAMILS WERE killed, maimed, robbed and rendered homeless are no longer isolated episodes. Many temples, burnt down also Jaffna Library was burnt down. Destroying 100000 books . At many occasions it was organised and assisted by sinhala political parties and sinhala military.
Peace talks and negotiations.( unilaterally halted or abrogated by Srilankan government)
Following peace talks AND PROPOSALS within parliamentary democracy were unilaterally halted or abrogated by Srilankan government . many believe it is because of majoritarian and MAHAVAMSA political pressure.
1956 Banda –Chelva pact , 1965 Dudly –Chelva pact , 1970 fp proposal , 1979 presidential commission report , 1983 all party conference , 1985 thimpu talk , 1985 thimpu proposal , 1986 Indian proposal , 1987 indo lanka accord , 1989-1990 president Premadasa talks , 1992 parliamentary select committee reports , 1995 devolution package , 2003 ISGA PROPOSAL , 2005 POST TSUNAMI ptoms , 2007 ALL PARTY REPORT.
It is on this backround we have to look at the srilankan problem,
And all democratic forces MUST RESPECT 1977 election mandate of tamil people TAMIL EELAM.
IN 1977 ALL 100% OF tulf CANDIDATES WON THE ELECTION WHO CALLED FOR TAMIL EELAM.
Nirmala as ex-LTTE women is carrying out her own hatred against LTTE.
I agree like any other LTTE had made mistakes in its political path.
Now the issue what Srilankan government is doing? is it realy against LTTE or against Tamils?
why then Tamils are kept in such concentration camps. what kind of political solution government is having for Tamils?
Nirmala fail to say nothing much about Srilankan government. why?????????????????
Srilankan problem must be seen through following history,
· As per Ceylon government publication (http://lakdiva.org/mahavamsa/) The great chronicles of Lanka 1912 Chapter 22 Para 14 , Sinhala queen VIHARAMAHADEVI had a peculiar cravings, including …….urge to drink the water used to wash a sword that had cleaved the head of a TAMIL warrior , whilst standing on that same head, the soothsayers at Kings court, who predicted that 'The queen's son, when he has vanquished the Tamils would built up a united kingdom of Lanka ,• As per Ceylon government publication( link http://lakdiva.org/mahavamsa/) The great chronicles of Lanka 1912 Chapter 22 Para 27 When the two sons were ten and twelve years old the king, who would fain put them to the test, when it was said to them: `Never will we fight with the Tamils; with such thoughts eat ye this portion here,' Tissa dashed the food away with his hand, but Gemini who had (in like manner) flung away the morsel of rice, went to his bed, and drawing in his hands and feet he lay upon his bed. The queen came, and caressing Gemini spoke thus: `Why dost thou not lie easily upon thy bed with limbs stretched out, my son?' `Over there beyond the Ganga are the Tamils, here on this side is the Gotha-ocean, how can I lie with outstretched limbs?' he answered. When the king heard his thoughts he remained silent.The above is from THE MAHAVAMSA sacred book and bible of Srilankan thereavada Buddhist. This book was translated into English by Mr Wilhelm Geiger in 1912. chapters 1 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 28, and 33 openly spreads hatred against Tamils. ·
It is on the above background last Tamil kin Elara was killed by King Duttugamini. Duttugamini first implemented SWORD CARRYING LION FLAG IN LANKA.
Gotabahaya was one of his military commanders. Current secretary of defence also a Gothabhaya.
· In 1815 British empire concur Srilanka , abolishes sword carrying lion flag. Sword carrying lion flag abolished taken to London , UK.
· IN 1948 during independence of then CEYLON, current presidents father Rajapakse claimed back the SWORD carrying lion flag back from British and proclaim AS NATIONAL FLAG.
The flag was designed such a way that sword being pointing at the bands representing minorities.
This makes one to wonder whether it is the start of post independence war against Tamils?
Important legislations of Srilanka.
· 1948 citizenship act, millions of Tamils loose citizenship.· 1956 Sinhala only act, Sinhala becomes only official language. Tamil workers forced learn Sinhala or loose employment rights and all government communications made in Sinhala only. · 1971 a system of standardisation of marks was introduced for admissions to the universities, obviously directed against Tamil-medium students· 1972 Bhudism declared as religion of the state.· 1979 prevention of terrorism act pave way to arrest and torture of Tamils for indefinite time and without charge.
Important racial riots
Srilankan Tamils also victims of riots 1915 , 1956 , 1958, 1977 , 1983 , 2001 , mid 2006 , oct 2006 during which TAMILS WERE killed, maimed, robbed and rendered homeless are no longer isolated episodes. Many temples, burnt down also Jaffna Library was burnt down. Destroying 100000 books . At many occasions it was organised and assisted by sinhala political parties and sinhala military.
Peace talks and negotiations.( unilaterally halted or abrogated by Srilankan government)
Following peace talks AND PROPOSALS within parliamentary democracy were unilaterally halted or abrogated by Srilankan government . many believe it is because of majoritarian and MAHAVAMSA political pressure.1956 Banda –Chelva pact , 1965 Dudly –Chelva pact , 1970 fp proposal , 1979 presidential commission report , 1983 all party conference , 1985 thimpu talk , 1985 thimpu proposal , 1986 Indian proposal , 1987 indo lanka accord , 1989-1990 president Premadasa talks , 1992 parliamentary select committee reports , 1995 devolution package , 2003 ISGA PROPOSAL , 2005 POST TSUNAMI ptoms , 2007 ALL PARTY REPORT.
CURRENT PRESIDENTS FAMILLY
Current presidents Father Rajapakse GAVE historical names to his children. One child being named as Mahinda name of Buddhist monk who wanted to make Srilanka as Buddhist only country, the son mahinda introduces “Mahinda thoughts” being implemented currently . Other child WAS named as Gotabhaya, name of military leader who first carried sword carrying lion flag ( in around) 600 BC to kill Tamils and invaded Tamils home land killing last Tamil king Elara. Now in 2009 new born Gotabhaya carrying out same killings of Tamils and sword carrying Lion flag being carried around in Tamil home land and all over the world to celebrate victory over Tamils.
conclusion
It is on this back round in 1977 TULf called for independent state of Tamil Ellam, all 100% candidates won their seats, it is the MANDATE OF TAMIL PEOPLE.
Instead of blaming tigers we have to look for prospective solutions and question Sinhala political history.
otherwise there will be a strong suspicion that who is funding who?
Nirmala,
I read your article with great interest. You captured the Tamil diaspora situation very well. It certainly helped me to make sense of a few things I had trouble understanding.
As you imply the dream of a utopian Ealam is probably so ingrained in the minds of many diaspora tamils, that they are now panicking as that dream is shattering. They seem to be unwilling to even consider the possibility that Tamils can live in peace with the Sinhalese, as 4 million of them already do in the rest of the country.
Mistakes have been made in the past, but Sri Lanka has learnt and grown. Tamil enjoy an equal status in the constitution, and a near equal status in society. All citizens have access to free-education in Sinhala or Tamil. Govt Depts operate in Sinhala, Tamil and English. There are Tamils in senior govt roles, and through out many sectors. They are successful in trade and industry. The end of the war will further improve this position.
I think we can afford to be hopeful now..
Mr observer you said " equal rights and rspect???????"
if it was true that MR has any respect for tamils WHY HE DID NOT VISIT IDP'sDURING HIS VISIT TO KILINOCHCHI??????????????????
Sir you must not have never stepped foot in Sri Lanka or are not or have never met a Tamil of the island. Otherwise I would say it is you who have a Utopian ideal of the Sri Lankan state.....
Just from my bad experience in Srilanka as a tamil I always support tamil tigers.... coz' they are the only solutions for the suffering tamils in srilanka...
I was in Jaffna for about 13 years, in colombo about 15 years and in Australia for for about 4 years and went through all kind of horrible bloody war and know the truth about LTTE and the Srilankan government... please don't think LTTE has just come down from Hell or heaven... they are from us, our own brothers and sisters...
war was not just started straight a way, Tamils protested for about 30 years in a very peaceful way against the utter genocide and discrimination enforced by the singhala governments, but all resulted in blood.... for instance in 1958 the government brought "only singala law" and the tamil politicians did a hunger strike in front of the parliament against this discriminatory law, but singhala politicians kicked them off the parliament and killed and burnt many tamils and parcelled 40 heads of killed tamils and send them to jaffna.... like this animalistic cruelty it happened many times and as a result tamils lost patience and took the weapon in their hands...
if you temporarily keep a tamil name and hold a tamil national identicard you'll realise how badly the tamils are suffering in tamil... we never felt we are the citizens of Srilanka, coz' we were so badly discriminated in all aspects and parts in Srilanka...
Srilankan governments are full of thugs, criminals and fully corrupted... how can the tamils achieve our legitimate rights from these criminal governments... the biggest killer and the murderer is Mahinda Rajapaksha...
We lived with LTTE, we know all the truth about them... its true they made some mistakes... but, they sacrificed so much for our suffering people.... if they are not a genuine freedom fighters they won't be lasting this long and they won't be getting support from Tamils allover the world....
LTTE always requested the presense of neutral media in the war zones... but, srilankan government never gives permission to any media to get in to the conflict zones... also, government was killing people who say anything against them... its really tragedic.. so we can't accpect the claim that LTTE is using the people as human shields... please remember, for years people were shifting with LTTE from the places which were captured by Srilankan Army... so, we have to accept the fact that many people want to stay with LTTE ... I was in the war situation many times and all the people I konw supported LTTE even if they were close to death by war..
tamils (all over srilanka) proved many times that tamil tigers are the only representatives of them, but international community has continuously refused that with the influence of the horrible Srilankan government... tamil people in Jaffna and east are now kept shut by the hitlor mahinda Rajapaksha... not that because they don't want the freedom from these animals... but, they can't talk against them... coz' they are governed by horrible blood thurst animals...
unless Srilanka give equal rights to all its people these ethnic problems are never gonna be ended, but the equal rights are dream for many with these unreliable corrupted governments...
I agree with the writer on most of the material, but I question the Statement " The government forces have shown no inhibition in bombing and shelling indiscriminately into crowded civilian areas, schools and hospitals as long as their military objective of crushing the Tigers is achieved." If this was true the war would be over by now. Nobody including the British and Canadian Politicians seem to sit back and think that if the SLDF used heavy weapons as claimed by the LTTE dispora the mission would have been accomplished long ago at less cost in human lives to the army. I have been living in New York for the past three decades and think like an American. If the Islamists did what the Tamil Dispora is doing and paraded in the great cities of the west championing the cause of Bin Larden and calling him the saviour of Islam, what would be the outcome. Will these same British and Canadian Politicians take their side???. In conclusion I say that the Sri Lankans can handle their affairs on their own without outsiders jumping in on the LTTE bandwagon for Political gain. Leave them alone to solve their problem.
Unlike Bin laden’s activities, Tamil Eelam demand came from a political history, TULF called for Tamil Eelam in 1977 General Election after failing to achieve Tamils rights through parliamentary democracy. In 1977 Election Tamils gave mandate for creation of Tamil Eelam. Although LTTE had failed in some aspects LTTE is the only organisation defending Tamils democratic Mandate. Mahavamsa Ideology stands to destroy Tamils. Srilanka will see its end sooner or later. Lies cannot stand for long time. Tamils rights are violated by a sovereign government that is the issue world is looking at NOW.Please see history below in my other comment
Yes Nirmala, we all know LTTE have made some mistakes. T
his article is your own extremism of your experiences with LTTE, since you left back in late 80's the LTTE have become moderate, their political tactics have improved. We all know LTTE have made some mistakes so have other poltical groups by being in bed with the sri lankan state.
Overall the state has done far more damage to tamils, so focus on the real issue of tamils.
There are tamils living quietly in sri lanka, tamils being kidnapped murdered in south sri lanka, the tamil ministers who cannot speak against the government , Tamil businessmen scared of being kidnapped. The war is against tamils. Focus on the systematic genocide since 1948
I respect your own views on Tamils and that should happen in a democratic world which only can bring forward our community. However I respectfully DISAGREE your generalisation of Tamils and Tamil Diaspora. Eventhough I know you and your team's background and your adamant views on Tamils over decades...I don't want to discuss that here. I believe that Tamil community needs to reach out to the world and build our community with highest values accomating different views. But I am talking about positive and constructive discussions to move our community forward to correcting our mistakes. This is different from your intentions. In my mind, you few people too have some strong views not accomating any outside views - I have met few of your team members - they are the same for the last 10-15 years - anti-LTTE. I am not defending LTTE, but 100 people can be wrong, even 1000 people can be wrong - BUT ENTIRE COMMUNITY CAN'T BE WRONG. Many of the Tamil Diaspora live in a western world for many years, like you, they also interacted with Western Values, they are no restriction or limitation - Still why those highly educated people believe in Tigers? Beyond fantacy or fun or in your term lobbying - THERE SHOULD BE SOMETHING MORE. WHY YOU PEOPLE DON'T BRING THAT SOMETHING TO THE PUBLIC EYES? IF YOU HAVE DONE SO, TAMILS BE A UNITED COMMUNITY.
An interesting analysis. People all over the world MUST understand that the Tamil struggle has started as a result of continuos denial of human rights, equality, freedom, equal opportunities in education and employment opportunities and use of violence although Tamils initially started the struggle through non-violence means.
The world MUST condemn the Racist Apartheid Sinhala regime rather than the LTTE. LTTE is a product of Sinhala hooliganism and State Terrorism. LTTE is not a product of the Tamils. I still DREAM the days I was at Jaffna during the 50s and 60s. It was a WONDERFUL place to live in peace and harmony at that time.
where is the history? what happened to the atrocities commited by the SLA against the Tamil people? what happened to all the race riots? how sweet that you hide these, how sweet you only mention what serves your purpose, you keeness to put down the LTTE.
Each tamils knows the pain & suffering caused by the sri-lankan government in its war against the tamil people. there is no need for propaganda.
the Dispora is calling for a Ceasefire to stop the genocide, how is that not helping the tamils back home?
your personal vendetta against the LTTE is clearly visible in your article, keep you personal vendetta but dont attack the solidarity of the tamil people.
I think you need a lesson in reality if you can forget the race riots and SLA atrocities and think for a second that the Government of Sri-lankan will treat a tamil as an equal individual.
Stupidest article I have read.You maybe affected by your sister's death,but you are sick in your head, to take a decison like this . I am personally affected by this war and my family and relatives are also affected directly. The war is CONDUCTED by a corrupt government which has a VERY LARGE NUMBER OF MINISTERS for any population in the world. A very corrupt AIRLINE DEAL "MIHIN". HOW MUCH DID YOU GET FROM THIS CORRUPT GOVERNMENT.
"The eastern region of Sri Lanka where many Tamils live - and which has lost far more of its young people and children in this war than any other Tamil region - has largely abandoned support for an independent state.
The Jaffna peninsula in the north has been largely uninvolved for more than a decade or so in the separatist cause; there, the vast majority of civilians have submitted to uneasy cohabitation with the army simply because amid available options, they prefer an absence of war."
Nirmala,
I thought you are an intelligent woman, at least someone who could come up with some logical arguments.
We all know the situation of the areas occupied by the Sri Lankan armed forces. i.e Jaffna peninsula and entire east. Can anyone voice any political opinion other than that of supporting the government, in these areas?
Your government (Sri Lankan) and their security forces are keeping them in open jails and telling us that these people are uninterested in thier oplitical rights.
Can you lobby your governmentto do a referendum in these areas to find the opinion of the people. So the whole world will know wha is the aspirations of the Tamil people?
Sinnaiah Sivakumar
I know I am wasting my time. I also know there is an organised well funded team working behind the scene to distrupt and destroy Tamil Nationalism. Just one question: Can you demonstrate to the world at least 100 Tamils behind you. The question you have to ask yourself is, why? and you should not conclude "all Tamils are dum". I know you had some passion to Tamil cause, definitely you have some talents as well. If we all can bring our energy in one direction - may not be in your view Tigers but for Tamil Homeland - We can achieve our goals and create a democratic Tamil Homeland with highest values. Please come out from your FANATIC mindset and try to think otherway around. I know you are tied up with your network - still I believe you can contribute positively to build a lost nation.
hi nirmala
i appericiate your leap to revenge on tamils, who live in a democratic country like canda they can critise any body for their deeds.
do you know what realy happening in sri lanka
dont try to make false statements and kill more taimls.
thiose who knows the situation well is who is living and dying day by day
Dear Nirmala,
I appreciate your time and efforts to put your perspective in writing. I respect your views and analysis.
First of all, this struggle, sufferings, young Tamils to take AK47 and victims become suicide bombers, as a result of continuous discrimination, no rule of law, attack, no Sinhalese in ever charged for crimes committed against Tamils, Tamil women and children are raped with impunity, Killing Tamils may not be an offence but killing an animal, destruction of Tamil properties by Sinhala state forces and hooligans. Tamils are treated worse than slavery in their own land. Do you think, a Tamil blows up their body for fun or die in a gun battle? Tamils are family oriented, hard working, conservative, disciplined and want to live in respect and dignity.
Although I do not support or defend the LTTE, they brought some dignity, bravery and respect to the Tamils. Tamils people respect the LTTE as their defenders. There may be attrocities, violence and criminal activities of certain elements of the LTTE but overall most Tamils including the elite suuport the LTTE - This is as per the demonstrations that is talking place all over the world.
Tamils people deserve equality, respect, dignity, freedom, democracy, apply rule of law equally, independent justice system, respect to Human rights, no discrimination and so on.
The successive Sinhala Racist Apartheid regimes are responsible for the crimes and the situation today. Their failure to address the Tamil issue by these Sinhala racist governments have vertually destroyed the one time beautiful country. The Sinhalese thought that if they have few Tamil puppets on their side they can win the Tamils. It is a FALSE idea and it NEVER works.
One thing I admire is that this struggle has brought all Tamil Diaspora together, closer than ever before. This struggle has led the issue of AIADMK Manifesto - If Tamils are not treated equally in Sri lanka, Eelam is the ONLY solution. What a change!! Rajapakse MUST be tried for Genocide, War Crimes and use of WMD - Chemical weapons.
The struggle is for the freedom of Tamils and not LTTE. This is all about Tamils and nothing else!!
if you are a real believer in democracy ,after reading all this comments , come on make your statement YOU GOT IT WRONG OTHERWISE NONE WILL SEE YOU AS A DEMOCRATE BUT ONLY AS A PAWN FOR MONEY, POWER , FAME ETC
in the past for LTTE now who??????
This is the central flaw in your analysis: You describe the Tamil Diaspora's current re-invigoration and political uprisings as a result of 'LTTE' brainwashing and that the average Tamil immigrant is highly isolated and inundated with LTTE imagery only. I would counter this pessimistic appraisal of the Tamil Diaspora's intellect with the fact that a great deal of the pro-LTTE activities are being organized by and driven by Tamil Youth, Second and Third generation members of the Tamil Diaspora. These Youth aren't the same 'adults' who solely rely on Tamil sources for their daily information and entertainment. These Youth are usually highly mobile and culturally well adopted with multiple and relevant cultural sources. They aren't bombarded by and isolated by the LTTE narrative - they in fact have multiple cultural points of reference provided by linguistic proficiency, or even a lack of Tamil proficiency. What has actually happened is that the Sri Lankan state has completed and proven the main LTTE narrative: that the LTTE is the lone representative and only protectors of the Tamils of Sri Lanka. To rationale members of the Tamil Diaspora who had been skeptical about the LTTE's claims that without the LTTE the island's Tamils are doomed, and that anyone questioning their prerogatives was in fact endangering the survival of the Tamil people as a whole have now been silenced by the ongoing events of the island. As the LTTE has lost ground, Tamil civilian casualties have mounted. The LTTE's unsavoury practices have paled in contrast to the Genocidal Sri Lankan state's willingness to commit mass atrocities against Tamil civilians. The International Community's silence as Tamil civilians die en mass to fulfill political agendas doubly damns LTTE critics and reinforces the LTTE's position.
As the 1983 pogroms radicalized youth into choosing militancy, the current massacres of Tamil civilians has radicalized and solidified Tamil Nationalist Resistance to the Sri Lankan state once more. Indeed the Sri Lankan state has either knowingly or unwittingly played into the LTTE narrative, or as the LTTE would say, the Sri Lankan state's Genocidal intent is simply apparent once more.
A note on why Tamil supporters of the LTTE haven't been openly critical of the LTTE's practices - simply because the International community has been highly critical of the LTTE for so long without securing fundamental humanitarian safe guards for Tamil civilians from the Sri Lankan government. It is offensive to harp on the allegations of the LTTE controlling the movement of their population when the Sri Lankan state does no less, limiting Tamil movement en mass throughout the island, even putting thousands in internment/concentration camps. The IC has regularily attacked the LTTE's actions while failing to even lift the blockade of basic supplies to Tamil civilians by the Sri Lankan government, or closing the internment camps, or even securing independent monitors. There seem to be many credible sources about LTTE actions, while the international community cannot even recognize SLA artillery falling on UN hospitals in the safe zone or be critical of a defense secretary who admits to that war crime on public television.
It is shocking you are so disconnected to the basic predicaments of the Tamil Diaspora. And Madam one does not need a more independent source of information then to have their aunt tell them their cousins had his head blown off by an SLA artillery shell - or did you wait for the New York Times to confirm your own sister's assassination and conviction of her killers?
This is the central flaw in your analysis: You describe the Tamil Diaspora's current re-invigoration and political uprisings as a result of 'LTTE' brainwashing and that the average Tamil immigrant is highly isolated and inundated with LTTE imagery only. I would counter this pessimistic appraisal of the Tamil Diaspora's intellect with the fact that a great deal of the pro-LTTE activities are being organized by and driven by Tamil Youth, Second and Third generation members of the Tamil Diaspora. These Youth aren't the same 'adults' who solely rely on Tamil sources for their daily information and entertainment. These Youth are usually highly mobile and culturally well adopted with multiple and relevant cultural sources. They aren't bombarded by and isolated by the LTTE narrative - they in fact have multiple cultural points of reference provided by linguistic proficiency, or even a lack of Tamil proficiency. What has actually happened is that the Sri Lankan state has completed and proven the main LTTE narrative: that the LTTE is the lone representative and only protectors of the Tamils of Sri Lanka. To rationale members of the Tamil Diaspora who had been skeptical about the LTTE's claims that without the LTTE the island's Tamils are doomed, and that anyone questioning their prerogatives was in fact endangering the survival of the Tamil people as a whole have now been silenced by the ongoing events of the island. As the LTTE has lost ground, Tamil civilian casualties have mounted. The LTTE's unsavoury practices have paled in contrast to the Genocidal Sri Lankan state's willingness to commit mass atrocities against Tamil civilians. The International Community's silence as Tamil civilians die en mass to fulfill political agendas doubly damns LTTE critics and reinforces the LTTE's position.
As the 1983 pogroms radicalized youth into choosing militancy, the current massacres of Tamil civilians has radicalized and solidified Tamil Nationalist Resistance to the Sri Lankan state once more. Indeed the Sri Lankan state has either knowingly or unwittingly played into the LTTE narrative, or as the LTTE would say, the Sri Lankan state's Genocidal intent is simply apparent once more.
A note on why Tamil supporters of the LTTE haven't been openly critical of the LTTE's practices - simply because the International community has been highly critical of the LTTE for so long without securing fundamental humanitarian safe guards for Tamil civilians from the Sri Lankan government. It is offensive to harp on the allegations of the LTTE controlling the movement of their population when the Sri Lankan state does no less, limiting Tamil movement en mass throughout the island, even putting thousands in internment/concentration camps. The IC has regularily attacked the LTTE's actions while failing to even lift the blockade of basic supplies to Tamil civilians by the Sri Lankan government, or closing the internment camps, or even securing independent monitors. There seem to be many credible sources about LTTE actions, while the international community cannot even recognize SLA artillery falling on UN hospitals in the safe zone or be critical of a defense secretary who admits to that war crime on public television.
It is shocking you are so disconnected to the basic predicaments of the Tamil Diaspora. And Madam one does not need a more independent source of information then to have their aunt tell them their cousins had his head blown off by an SLA artillery shell - or did you wait for the New York Times to confirm your own sister's assassination and conviction of her killers?
My response to the article, in particular to - why the demonstrators are not asking for the Tigers to let the civilians go - is that that if they did the Tigers in the strip of land around Mullaitivu will be slaughtered by the GoSL's military.
Strategically, the price of breaking the backbone of the Tigers on the domestic front is the Tamils in Sri Lanka lose out on their representative who has had meaningful negotiating strength at Peace Talks.
The loss of Tiger territory reduces the LTTE's power . Thus, strategically what the GoSL has achieved is the end (at least for now) of the meaningfulness of the threat of secession.
Certainly, there is the claim to land (a prerequisite for secession) on historical grounds. However, without military or administrative control of land the threat of secession is a weak threat. The claim of genocide holds possibilities to return to the quest for achieving secession. Thus, the civilians are a pawn in a greater game, albeit unethical - even if the goal be freedom from domination, in this case race based.
Overall, there is more to say, but I hope this conveys a deeper perspective when viewed from a broader strategic perspective.
Whilst the international community is being solicited to assist in ending the immediate humanitarian atrocities, which over the years both sides have more than engaged in, the pressing need in these times is a discussion on what are the end results/outcomes we seek to achieve.
It is for those ends/outcomes that strategy needs be developed and for that purpose it is useful to discuss the thinking that informs such strategy.
What you say about the armed struggle is not justified.Casualties and deaths inevitable in the war. Many times humanitarian laws were meaningless when both party engaged with weapons. When Bush and Blair bombarded Iraq to destroy weapons of Mass destruction. 1000s of civilians killed as a consequence. Aftermath of the war, no weapons of mass destruction found. Bush and Blair were not tried for killing innocent people on a pre concept.
Israeli army bombed hamas in palestine and killed many civilians. Israel war mongers did not allow any foreign media inside the war zone. Entire world watched some of the war videos/ pictures leaked from the war zone. Israelists were not convicted for war crimes either.
Banning LTTE also Bush's 'zero tolerance idea ' on terrorism. LTTE policians should have confronted Bush and uplifted this ban. Why LTTE diaspora not raised this issue earlier? Where are the LTTE political leaders? As many diaspora say the Tamil cause is correct thel violent methods tarnished the Tamil cause.
Why LTTE can't surrender and release the 50000 people held as hostages and human shield?
A point of view by a peace loving Sri Lankan Tamil having spent 30 years in Sri Lanka and the later 30 years in the U.K.
The truth is as follows as I was a Sri Lankan Tamil born and brought up in Sri Lanka grown with the Sinhalese, Muslims and Jaffna Tamils.
I am a Colombo born Tamil; I know my father came from Tamil Nadu in 1912. My mother also Colombo Tamil, born in Gampaha and her grand parents may have come from Tamil Nadu. My mother's side all were Ceylon Government Railway (CGR) workers, under British administration and my father had a Government service with the CGR for 40 years in Colombo.
After my father’s retirement from Railways we lived in Kandy, I was a Trinitian went to Trinity College in Kandy. I had very good Sinhala and Muslim schoolmates and friends. We had good Teachers from Batticaloa, Jaffna and a very strict Sinhalese Principal. Sri Lankan Government services not oppressed me.
At this time of Sinhala and Tamil New year, I can remember the good old days, my mother used to give me a tray full of home made sweets to my Sinhala and Muslim neighbours to distribute and in turn we received sweets from them. I had great times with my Sinhalese and Muslim friends in harmony.
There were some problems in University places, jobs, land and political freedom not fairly distributed among people. These are basic problems in any developing country has to go through after independence from British Empire. The majority of Sinhalese, Tamil and Muslims were poor. When SWRD and Mrs. Srimao Bandaranaykes’ came to power, there was severe oppression. However, there were good mediators on Sinhala, Tamil and Muslim sides. There were democratic processes, if one correctly utilise the political processes, all problems can be resolved by negotiations and not by taking Arms and Bombs. I can remember those days when G.G Ponnampalam, Dudley Senanayake and J.R. Jeyawardena, Premedasa were PMs. There were good politicians like Budduhideen Mohamed, Dr. N. M. Perera, Selvanayagam, Kadhrkamar and Ananda Cumara Swamy. There were bad forces within Jaffna people never followed the main line Politics with good leaders like Selvanayagam. There was a cancer growing within the Tamil groups to Separate Sri Lanka and rule, unfortunately who joined these groups are all separatists.
Even at that time, Jaffna Tamil people say that ‘I am not belonging to Jaffna’. Therefore, ‘I am a Northerner’ origin from Tamil Nadu, as I speak different Tamil.
Jaffna Tamil people say they speak pure Tamil and Tamil Nadu Tamils speak bad Tamil this is generally showing the superiority in their behaviour. The Tea estate Tamils were frowned upon as they were migrant workers brought by the British administrators to work in the Tea plantation. The Tea estate Tamils were very poor, ‘hand to mouth’ situation, there is nothing to look forward to, Thondaman lead these poor people in a union called ‘worker’s congress’.
Contrast to this, Jaffna Tamils (now a major LTTE group) from North and East of Sri Lanka, had good education by hard work. Their productive fertile land and coastal area for fishing were naturally giving advantages over rest of Sri Lanka. They were secularised and isolated and they tend to organise themselves in a self governing manner away from Colombo administration. They always try and find differences in communities and tend to secularise and isolate themselves perhaps this is how they wanted.
Jaffna Tamil’s secular idea of differentiating themselves from others is an ideology they practiced. LTTE not going to support for a unified Sri Lanka to include Indian Tamils and Muslims in it.
LTTE want a land of their own to practice what they believe is separatism and segregation. Their thinking formed the present armed group of LTTE.
LTTE’s are tactical people; whenever they need help they seek help from Tamil Nadu, yet they treat themselves a superior race than Indian Tamils. I am not going in to the roots of Jaffna Tamils. There are significant numbers of Jaffna Tamil sympathisers in Tamil Nadu causing political leadership problems in the Indian electoral system. This is dirty politics between parties to gain votes the voice of every party leader changes according to the nation’s tune of the Tamils. The party politics of Tamils in Tamil Nadu has a say in the Indian administration. Sri Lankan Tamil problem is a Political game for India.
LTTE paid the heaviest price in the history of Tamils through this unwanted civil war. They are now reaping the harvest sown by their ideological LTTE leaders. Isolation and secularisation made their suicidal type mental make up is very strong in a hypnotised manner, even as young as 5 years old waging the tiger flag and marching to the Hyde Park of London, for a cause further destroying the humanity and infuriating the host community and the peace loving people of the world. Especially the demonstrations in London to stop the war are not going to help LTTE unless there is sincere political hand shake to work with the government. If LTTE gets what they want, the Indian Tamils and Muslim settlers also have to flee from North and East of Sri Lanka.
LTTE group were armed to full fill their ideology and to reach their political ambition through civil war. World Tamils have no nation of their own therefore; well to do LTTE foreign settlers are supporting to divide a nation in to two sovereignties at any cost.
The time has come for these North and East people to live in harmony with other members of the communities, dismantling their tiger shields away. Some Tamils show their colonisation in the host communities too. They are not alone, there are Indian Tamils ands Muslims too, along with the Sinhalese in Sri Lanka. We need a common platform to solve our problems. It is our responsibility to build our Nation strong and economically healthy and to provide opportunity for all to prosper.
I have well observed LTTE’s mentality for years and my family’s personal experience as I have grown and lived in Sri Lanka for 30 years and living in U.K for the past 30 years. There should be one government and people should learn to live together respecting each other. Tolerance is the key, look for the common factors of humanity and don't look for the differences.
I have seen how Scotland went for separate Political platform in 1987 after a referendum and devolution of powers still keeping and respecting the main administration of the United Kingdom. The Sri Lankan Tamils should have followed a similar path and negotiated a referendum for their internal affairs and legal matters in their own political platform under the administration of Sri Lanka. These possibilities not explored, now completely wiped out by the LTTE’s terror wing and blindly following an offensive campaign to destroy humanity.
Those culprits, who supported LTTE for arming, should be responsible for driving these poor Northern and Eastern people in to this vast human disaster. Those LTTE political wing leaders are hiding under ground after causing maximum damage to the Tamil race untold in the history of Tamils. Where are these political leaders after Anton Balasigham no one coming out to face the world? Are they hiding in the bunkers with Gin and Tonic and flashing their pre recorded message on the Tamil satellite TVs, while their own race going through immense suffering.
LTTE paid a heavy price in this avoidable civil war. Those intellectual young men and women were wasted for a wrong cause. If Jaffna Tamils had good leaders, North and East of Sri Lanka would be thriving with trade with other countries due to its natural harbours and coastline. Abundance natural resources for manufacturing Cement and Chemicals, fisheries and harbours above all Jaffna Tamil’s intellectual mind. It is a shame that they got in to this mass hatred for Sinhalese people and the bad propaganda and the TV Medias used by the LTTE for propaganda, to hate their own fellow citizens. There were no Tamil leaders, who had broad minded vision to form a prosperous country within the legal frame work of Sri Lanka; yet holding a prime negotiated position, within that Tamils can practice their culture and religion without hatred, contributing to the democracy and the economy of Sri Lanka and gaining the support of the Sri Lankan Government.
In this war, those Northern and Eastern Tamil elders not practiced tolerance; instead they resorted for terror and segregation this is because they were forced to believe in the armed struggle by some Tamil mobs. This only made the Jaffna people to believe in hatred. There are no diplomatic efforts made by the negotiators in the LTTE group to gain world sympathy. They have a task to prove the world that they are not the banned LTTE terrorist group. There are peace loving Tamils also in Sri Lanka want to live in harmony with the Sinhalese and Muslims.
Dismantling the US endorsed LTTE terror symbol is a tough one, as LTTE have well rooted international terror campaign. LTTE supporters, while having a lavishing life style in Europe, Americas, Australia, they sponsored Prabhakaran and his allies to absorb and convert the poor people of North and East of Sri Lanka. Morally wrong move, pure selfishness to divide the nation. If that happens no one can live in Sri Lanka. The LTTE symbol is a symbol of terror and any peace loving community will not sympathise with this terror symbol and the organisation with its past records.
In the recent LTTE mob attacks to the Sri Lankan High Commission in Norway and throwing Nehru’s statue from Indian High Commission at London are not going to help LTTE’s peace process. Pure madness and indecency in a civilised Society and mobs out cry without a peaceful leadership within LTTE group. There is eminent danger exists in Canada, London and other countries where LTTE is well settled with the host community, yet colonising and isolating themselves from the peaceful world.
My talk with many ordinary Europeans reflects consolidation of their understanding of LTTE and making no sympathy for LTTE. What is left is to sincerely join hands with Sinhalese and make peace efforts wholeheartedly to make a new beginning by the help of the world.
Now the matter is humbly left to the Secretary of state for foreign and Commonwealth affairs David Milliband M.P, Rt. Hon. Des Brown MP appointed by the Prime Minister of U.K., to solve this Tamil issue and all those members of U.N to make a sincere effort to save the Tamils at this last minute. We do not need poor Sri Lankan Tamils suffering owing to the wrong doings of the LTTE.
LTTE in its present form should not be given the power for a new beginning in Sri Lanka; it is the Tamil people of Sri Lanka who decide their destiny in a referendum and possible devolution of powers to live in their native soil. I pray Her Majesty the Queen and the British Government to take this good cause forward to the U.N and mediate with Honourable Rajapakse for a new beginning for Sri Lankan citizens. I am sure Honourable Rajapakse will do the best for his citizens. God help him.
I also think MR Rajapakse will do the needful. Please disaminate your views among younger tamils who had never seen the right picture. Thank you again for seeing the picture clearly.
COMMENT FROM SRI LANKAN TAMILIN UK:
I am a Sri Lankan Tamil of Indian origin, born and brought up in Sri Lanka, now live in U.K. When George Bush and Tony Blair bombarded Iraq on false information about WMD (Weapons of Mass destruction), they killed thousands of innocent civilians including children and women. When UN Security Council surveyors arrived at the war site for post war inspection to detect WMD, no trace of WMD found. Bush and Blair never went to prison for killing innocent people due to their wrong pre concept. When Israel bombed Hamas, not a dog from world media allowed to the fighting zone. Israel accomplished their war plan and then pulled out, despite crocodile tears shed by western politicians. Same standards practied in Afghanistan. There is double standard for western war mongers and our ‘just war’ to eliminate this deadly LTTE terror group, depressed this beautiful tiny island for years and untold suffering to poor Tamil people of North and East.
I believe that the final war operation has to be conducted in surgical precision to destroy LTTE’s war machinery. My deepest sympathy for those innocent Tamils held as hostages and human shield to protect LTTE. Brig. Nanayakkara has to plan and attack targets with surgical precision to end this bloody war. Thanks to, Prof. De Silva's for his useful Satellite information. Keep up your good work and free Sri Lanka from terror.
We never get another opportunity to dismantle LTTE war machinery. I am sure Karuna realised this at the end. Hon. Rajapakse’s prime responsibility is for the people of North and East. Which he is doing splendidly under huge pressure given by western politicians, who practice double standards. We, peace loving Sri Lankan Tamils are with you Hon. Rajapakse.
After failing many attempts for a peaceful negotiated solution, going madly on the terrorist route is where North and East Tamils went wrong. Possibly, they were guided and driven wrongly very deeper in to killings and violent. The violent seeds were sown repeatedly without any intervention from any Tamil peacemaker. After all, Tamils know the bitter lessons of the past world wars, the horrible destruction of townships and innocent people in Vietnam, Iraq, and Palestine, Afghanistan etc.
Tamils are very clever and very peaceful people, very creative people yet opted for an armed struggle. Pity that time, lives and money wasted finding armed solution for the social, civil problems.
Time and money can be earned, not human lives.
There was a time when Norwegians came forward to mediate peace, but LTTE were extremely adamant not to take a lower seat.
Unconditionally, LTTE sat firm on ' no negotiation without pre condition'
The political side of LTTE should have settled for a lower step
'Give and take' policy should have been tactically followed and set on a political platform to steer in to main line politics with the Sinhalese.
Where are all the levelheaded good Tamil Political leaders?
Anton Balasingham, Tamil Sevam all sacrificed their lives; any good came out of these. More violent and more angry LTTE.
Year 2006 was LTTE turning point, when signs of cracks appearing within LTTE.
At that time all the Diaspora people sitting enjoying ' Gin and Tonic' and not doing nothing personally to their loved ones back in their own soil.
Diaspora groups are pre occupied, while having a lavishing life style in western world and giving the pounds, dollars, and Kroner for a luxury life for Mr. V.P.
Badly guided, single mindedness LTTE leader went ahead with what they felt right, without proper political leadership from Diaspora Tamils.
Suddenly when all collapsing, all Diaspora university students heard the news, they have a Tamil Eelam. They never had seen the soil or the originality of their own people suffering without food and clothing.
Among Tamils- top Lawyers, top Doctors, and top political architects - All are now waking up for the ' last call' when Tamil ship is sinking! Is there a last minute escape?
The biggest ever disaster was killing Rajiv Gandhi..........
Continued the disastrous path to present crises.
In 2006, LTTE should have gone for lesser point in the negotiation , accepted a referendum for Tamil voice to be heard then steered clear to a devolution of power and of course the people's voice would have heard far and loud in to the main stream politics.
All chances were missed due to foolishness and lack of thought and lack of political leadership within Tamil groups.
What are the chances now?
LTTE is a banned organisation when 'zero tolerance' announced by Bush.
We all know there are double standards practiced by Western world, Britain follows U.S ideas. Then our France and Germany, Sweden buys the same.
When George Bush and Tony Blair bombarded Iraq on false information about WMD (Weapons of Mass destruction), they killed thousands of innocent civilians including children and women.
When UN Security Council surveyors arrived at the war site for post war inspection to detect WMD, no trace of WMD found. Bush and Blair never went to prison for killing innocent people due to their wrong pre concept. When Israel bombed Hamas, not a dog from world media allowed to the fighting zone.
Israel accomplished their war plan and then pulled out, despite crocodile tears shed by western politicians.
Same standards now practised in Afghanistan using Pakistan as the doer of U.S ideas.
Does any one think U.S, Britain, or any country will help LTTE in its present terror form?
Simon Hughes giving orange juice to Hunger striker is like giving a sweet to crying child! Pathetic
Boy Milliband tried with all his Oxford tricks with Rajapakse!
India is nicely sitting tight with its political ambition!
Can we revive our voice proving that Tamils are peace loving democratic people or is it too late?
Why are we still carrying terrifying Tiger face on the flags?
Is LTTE still bloodthirsty?
LTTE has terrorised the world to an extent, no one willing to give a helping hand at this last minute.
Unfortunately peace loving Tamil people are 'wrongly labelled' as Terror group along with LTTE. Peace loving Tamils and LTTE are inseparable.
Now Tamils are reaping harvest of the violent seeds sown earlier.
Not heard in the history of Tamils.
Vanni peace loving Tamils are going through immense suffering and death.
What is the use of liberating North and East of Sri Lanka after killing so many of our kids, kins, and turning the prosperous land in to land mines?
Only what is left for the Diaspora Tamils is to pray God sitting on the tiger skin, wrapping the tiger flag around the waist and cyanide capsule around our neck, and watching Deepam TV propaganda machine!
ALTHOUGH THE WAR IS FINALLY OVER AFTER 30 YEARS, there are still comments appearing here threatening to continue the violence. The commentors' only reasons for making such threats: somethings that happened 30 - 50 years ago.
Why not forgive and forget, and work towards a peaceful future united? Why do people like this always feel the need to rewind and relive history over and over again?
We don't. And do you know what, I suspect Tamils back in Sri Lanka don't support Tigers. I expect they're fed up with the non-productive violence of the last 30 years.
I'll say it again, if you want to change things for the better in Sri Lanka, then learn from the American Civil Rights movement, not from a discredited and failed terrorist group. If you cannot change your approach, you are doomed to yet more failure. And that would be a pity, because Tamils do have legitimate grievances. But they will not be solved by violence.
Look, I know a lot of the Canadian Tamils lost relatives in the war. I'm sorry for them. I really am. I'd like to take one of the protesters by the hand and fly with him to Holland or France and have them walk with me through the cemeteries containing the bodies of thousands of Canadian freedom fighters. I'd tell him/her that ten times that many Canadian citizens at home also shed tears of despair. But it was war. Didn't matter who started it, people including loved ones get killed. Protesting, reliving, denying, threatening, & nurturing it won't change anything. There are no winners, you just move on. Remember those who died taking part in the most vulgar of man's passion and be grateful you're alive with a chance to live your life free of war's shackles.
It's over people. Get over it. If insist on having a home land go try to create one in Tamil Nadu (isn't that where you all came from??). Might be tough though I don't think Indians want you over there either because you blew up their PM.
May be it's time to learn to get along and learn to respect your host country as well.
Can you just stop with your lies for god sake? The Singalese sponsored riots and slaughtering way before Prabaharan was born. DOn't tell me a different version of SL Govt disinformation now...
You are traitor for tamils How much money you get from Miiliband and gordon brown every tamils know what gordon browns double stand. if he is really concerned about tamils why didnt he not say that LTTE is not Terrorrists?
A shame! A sneaky escape! No Cyanide capsule for the Leader. He gave it to all his men and child soldiers as a true BritishTamil The only way to have peace in Srilanka is to treat Tamils with equal rights like UK treat all citizens with equal rights
Sri Lanka has shown the way to many countries how to ruthlessly crush the separatists, be they motivated by religion, ethnicity or culture. Countries which are grappling with this problem need to emulate the island nation. The struggle may be long , fiercely war-like taking a heavy toll of human lives but if pursued with grit and determination it would end up in success. The problem of separatism has been bedeviling India in Kashmir, Russia in Chechnya, China in Xinjiang, Philippines in Mindanao and many other countries. We all British must admire the dogged determination of Sri Lankan forces in mercilessly crushing the LTTE ignoring the appeals of other countries including US Canada, human rights organizations and even the United Nation urging it to declare a ceasefire and strive to seek a political l solution to the ethnic problem. Now the game is over. UK, on its part, would do well to exercise utmost vigilance that the LTTE cadres do not sneak into UK and try to use London as a rallying zone for the Tamil Tigers. We also hope that DAVID MILLIBAND, George Brown, would not shed tears nor pen down an elegy in praise of slain Prabhakaran.
The war HAS ended! Can't you get it through your thick ignorant skull. Why would you say the war hasn't ended? Are you actually planning on continuing on this war which kills massive amount of your own people. It's unbelievable how you protest that 'our innocent people are dying' when you really mean is 'help! save LTTE, or our egos will be crushed'. As for Prabhakaran he is a coward! Using his own people to create human shields while he trying to escape without byting the synide pill. What kind of a leader is that? What a coward! lousy bastered. All he ever wanted from tamils are money! He may have been thinking he wanted to fight for freedom but he soon forgot his purpose with his level of power to kill massive numbers of people and obtain money through the use of fear. All you blood sucking LTTE just remember, we are trying to save your own backsides down here. We are trying to also keep our sinhala nation safe along with every other race living on it. It is our right to ensure LTTE does not obtain power to destroy our country. Don't cry to Western countries now because deep down they know the truth themselves! When the country is reformed then they will see what and who was holding it all back! When tamils were killing our people we didn't cry for Western help. We didn't go around protesting in countries and disrupting other's lives. Gutless terrorists. Get over it! Move on with your lives. Its OVER now. Stop blaming the government for the reckage of your own people, because you guys did that to yourselves without any assistance from us.
Simply a bitch
Sri Lanka ‘turns back’ Mercy Mission Ship - Rejects Tamil Diaspora Humanitarian Aid
http://vannimission.org/2009/06/08/press-release-8th-june
This is how DEFENCE.LK responds President of Sri Lanka's call for reconciliation?
Protecting them from access to humanitarian aid?
Sri Lanka is now focused on the "3 R's:" Rehabilitation, Reconstruction, and Reconciliation?
I think not.
They are like an vindictive neighbor who goes to city hall to find every statute that can be used to make life hell for their Tamil neighbors.
What a bunch of petty & pathetic bureaucrats.
I see that http://defence.lk also picked up Mr. Luce's article for there web site.
Guess this means Jim Luce's got a green light for his retirement plans in Sri Lanka
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jim-luce/in-sri-lanka-the-basics-f_b_212286.html
The first legal record of ethnic cleansing of Sri Lankan Tamils:
According to Clause 3 of the Kandyan Convention of 2 March 1815, "... hereby declared enemies to the government and excluded and prohibited from entering those provinces on any pretense whatever, without a written permission for that purpose by the authority of the British Government, under the pains and penalties of martial law, which is hereby declared to be in force for that purpose; and all persons of the Malabar Caste [Tamils] now expelled from the said provinces, are under the same penalties, prohibited from returning, except with the permission before mention" as per the request of the Sinhalese chiefs who signed.
http://vannimission.org/2009/06/08/press-release-8th-june
We diaspora are not oblivious to the genuine good deeds that Sinhalese are doing to help IDPs, nor are we oblivious to the callous use of bombs against those same civilians or the pleasure some Sinhalese take from the sight of their defeated enemy. I hope no one views Sinhalese as an evil “race” since any geneticist can tell you Tamils & Sinhalese are the same race. Sinhalese may perhaps have more Bengalese genomic similarities than Sri Lankan Tamils but it’s a negligible difference.
Therefore Tamil Nadu is just as much a Sinhalese homeland as it is for Sri Lankan Tamils. Embrace your Dravidian heritage.
Give up this delusion that your languages Aryan derivation means you are Aryans, you're not!
Any real reconciliation attempt will be impossible due to the need for freedom of the press in Sri Lanka, freedom of speech, safety from white vans & para-military types, all are required before your local Tamils can even speak to what they want. We diaspora will have to speak for them in courts of law around the world, street corners, wherever… TAG you’re it!
My father tamil mother british I think tamil terrarist have a very unjust -stupid i would say demand...because these tamil terrarists are demanding a 35% of the country’s landmass and over 75% of its surrounding sea for a separate Tamil state. Constituting only 6.5% of the country’s population, over half of the country’s Tamils currently live amongst the majority Sinhalese.
Is tamil terrarist can this stuid and every tamil terrarist living in UK can stupid enough to stand for such funny demand! what do they smoke?
Post new comment