About Yves Gingras

Yves Gingras is professor of history and sociology of science at the Université de Montréal and Director of the Interuniversity Research Center on Science and Technology (CIRST).

Articles by Yves Gingras

Nobel by association: beautiful mind, non-existent prize

__________________________________________

Science and mysticism: a tainted embrace

Scientists often complain about the rising influence of mystical and religious beliefs, a trend they regard as detrimental to scientific inquiry. Since at least the mid-1970s, a common feature of science's public profile is for a leading practitioner to denounce beliefs in (for example) astrology or "alternative" or "parallel" medicine, and lament the public's ignorance of true science.

The most high-profile example (though far from the only one) is Richard Dawkins, whose prolific and relentless pursuit of unreason has won him both acclaim and execration. But this very polarisation of response indicates a problem in the way that the issue of science and mysticism is presented and discussed in the public arena. The media's preference for sound and fury over calm, logical, evidence-based argument, and the temptation even among serious intellectuals to allow provocation and polemic to lead their case, means that the question of whether scientists' own indulgence in mysticism can undermine the integrity of their profession goes undiscussed.

This week's editor

Heather McRobie


Heather McRobie is a regular contributor to 50.50

Syndicate content