Cornwall Forward
Across the Political Spectrum
With three councilors on the Cornwall Council and having beaten Labour in Cornwall's Euro-elections Mebyon Kernow is looking the healthiest it has for years. Can MK build on these successes by harvesting support from a public disillusioned with the London based parties? They are certainly steadfast supporters of radical democratic renewal.
The Cornish Greens in their manifesto -A Fresh Start for Cornwall- have reiterated their call for the "devolution of power to Cornwall including a full Cornish Assembly with regional powers", and support from the prominent Green Party candidate, Peter Tatchell, seems to be unending [1][2].
Even the Tories seem to be speaking Cornish these days. No small affairs considering their power sharing arrangement with a group of independents in the Council that contains many a supporter of Cornish recognition and devolution.
The Liberal Democrats in Cornwall
Ousted from the Council as they may be the Liberal Democrats have still produced some interesting material in Kernow. MP Andrew George has combined his constitutional investigations with a larger vision of Cornwall's potential to suggest a new beginning (pdf). George's interest in the Cornish question is a long standing affair but recent movement was sparked by Notary Public John Kirkhope's research into the Duchy following the work of our other constitutionalists [1] [2] [3]. The general conclusion is that if recognised Cornwall's de jure constitution as a Duchy would afford it a very large degree of self-government.
Then earlier this summer MP Dan Rogerson produced his Government of Cornwall Bill. Even though the bill is unlikely to achieve much in the immediate future it has still been described as adding much needed fuel to the Cornish devolution debate. Although regrettably unheard of by Rogerson's fellow party members out side the Duchy all the Cornish MPs have backed the bill in addition to supporting the campaign for a 'Cornish Census' for 2011.
The Lib Dems have claimed on numerous occasions that Cornwall's new Unitary Council could be the starting point for a journey to a Cornish Assembly (pdf), but can local be transformed into national government?
The European Region of Culture Campaign
Although steering well clear of Cornish nationalism and party politics the aspirations of Cornwall Culture and its leadership of the European Region of Culture Campaign are clearly regionalist. The campaigns objective to make Cornwall one of Europe's fist 'regions of culture' marries well with EU regional recognition and perhaps therefore true regional government. The campaign has been severely criticised for ignoring authentic Cornish culture and heritage as well as snubbing established players in the field but this essentially good idea still looks set for success.
Grass Roots
A healthy Transition Town culture seems to be taking root in Cornwall with the aim of producing self-reliant robust communities across the Duchy. Not so far from some of Transition Cornwall's aims the Trelawney Alliance are saying -NO- to unsustainable mass housing development. Perhaps some pointers could be taken from London Citizens on mobilising our communities.
Tying it all up
So swift trade with plenty of action but what seems to be missing is a joined-up approach. Isn't the Cornish Constitutional Convention supposed to be acting as the focal point for change? If it can't then where should we turn to find the cohesion that is clearly needed? Now perhaps more than ever Cornish aspirations should be formulated, clearly stated and fed into the larger and much needed debate on democratic reform in the UK.
I doubt it will provide definitive answers but perhaps the conference -Cornwall in Europe: a perspective from minorities- organised for the 28th of October by the Federal Trust will provide some bearings for the way ahead.




Comments
A very useful summary, thanks Philip for bringing together many useful links and threads. With Cornwall set to be a Tory vs LD battleground next year we may expect more wooing of the Cornish electorate from the two big parties, whilst the truth is that the smaller MK and Green forces actually have more sensible suggestions.
The trouble with big party electoral promises is that they are very quickly forgotten once the election is over (as happened with the LD commitment to an assembly back in 2004) - it is things like the transition movement and the campaign for a Cornish Assembly which are far better bets for lasting resilient change. It is our right to take the power over our own lives, not some London government's right to grant us scraps from their table.
The trouble with trying to bring regional powers down to the unitary council which has been foisted on an unwilling populace, is that from the grass roots viewpoint it would represent a further centralisation of power in Truro - it is only any good if the whole picture is examined and powers are also devolved down to reformed local districts - call them boroughs, towns, districts or even "community network areas", what matters is that they reflect people's sense of identity and place on the ground.
This is certainly the thinking within the Greens, and chimes with the Transition movement's focus on localisation. It also makes a lot of sense sitting here 50 miles from Truro - the last thing I want locally is more incompetent governance from Truro; self rule for Landulph ! (and every other parish).
Incidentally the link to the Federal Trust has no information about any Cornish conference I could see...
RogerCO
SE Cornwall
The Federal Trust hasn't updated its list of forthcoming events yet but the conference is happening. If you want more details feel free to contact them: http://www.fedtrust.co.uk/ The Cornish Democrat
This an excellent article, summarising the latest developments and pointing to new ways forward.
There are lots of good people promoting a Cornish self-rule agenda and I am proud to offer my support for their efforts.
But I do believe that as well as the insider parliamentary lobbying, historical research and legal challenges, there also needs to be a non-violent Gandhian-style direct action protest movement to push Cornish self-rule onto the local and national agenda.
The battle for gay equality shows how it can be done. Two decades ago, gay rights was pretty marginal, but by a ceaseless protest campaign by OutRage! and other gay groups it became centre stage. All anti-gay laws (bar one) were repealed within 10 years. The numbers involved in this campaign were quite small and it was done on a shoe-string. This shows the Cornish groups could make progress, with determination and imagination.
A very good article Philip.
It seems to me that for some time now the burgeoning apparatus of 'South West' Quangodom has perhaps been the biggest single factor in the disempowerment and disenfranchisement of the Cornish.
However, it now seems likely that a general Quango bonfire may be in the offing (whoever wins the next election).
What is the informed opinion on
a) whether we will finally be rid of these awful, distant, colonial bureaucrats controlling so many aspects of our lives and
b) how we might best capitalise on their demise ... ?
gen oll an gorhemmynadow a'n gwella
Pednithan
self-rule for Lanlivery (and every other parish)
A truly well constructed article that puts the current political situation into some semblance of context.
I would just like to add a point, however, that I feel puts the whole position of our Cornish Duchy into its correct constitutional framework, in order to resolve the Cornish Question and its apparent position as an 'inconvenient periphery'.
The hurdle that clearly has to be jumped is, that Cornwall's relationship, constitutionally and historically, is with 'the Crown' and not with England.
Peter T: would a similar campaign work re an English parliament? Don't you think there was a wider movement re Gay Rights?
Do you refuse to support Cornish devolution Anthony B? Any particular reason for your silence on the subject of the actual article? The OK line seems to be that I should feel lucky that 'Cornish nationalism' is mentioned at all on this blog as clearly an English Parliament is the only solution.....silly Cornish people.... The Cornish Democrat
Peter Tatchell's suggestion is an interesting one. Maybe some media attention-grabbing protest actions highlighting specific grievances would really help raise the profile of the Cornish self-government movement. Perhaps you should get Peter T on board in terms of organising them!
Cornish Solidarity closed the Tamar Bridge in the 90's and the Cornish Stannary Parliament took a blowtorch to a number of English Heritage signs delivering them back to EH in person, but perhaps we need to step up the efforts. The Cornish Democrat
And make sure the 'national' (i.e. London-based) media are present!
Campaigns for bilingual signposts and a Welsh-language television service proved successful even though they didn’t garner much attention outside Wales. When the second home arson campaign started in 1979 the BBC usually announced in grave tones that Welsh ‘extremists’ had been at work. That label of ‘extremism’ completely closed down the debate on the problems of rural communities in the ‘national’ media, problems which many in Cornwall, England and Scotland can now identify with.
The below comes from the Federal Union and is organised by the Federal Trust. Contact details for the conference are provided below.Wednesday 28 October 2009 - LondonCornwall in EuropeThis conference will be an opportunity to learn more about one of the historic regions of the United Kingdom and Europe from representatives of Cornish cultural and intellectual life. Organised jointly by the Federal Trust and Cornish cultural group CERES, it will also be an opportunity to understand better the European links and networks in which Cornish representatives participate. 4.30pm-7pm, at London Metropolitan University, 31 Jewry Street, London EC3N 2EY.For more information, please send an e-mail to info@fedtrust.co.uk or call 020 7320 3045. The Cornish Democrat
This in from the Celtic League: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/celtic_league/message/3150 The Cornish Democrat
When Welsh MPs were lobbying for a Secretary of State for Wales in the early 1940s one of the sops offered up was an annual Welsh Day Debate, with the first being held in 1944.
Have Cornish Nationalists considered lobbying for something similar? It would be largely symbolic but it would force some form of debate on the floor of the house.
All suggestions have been noted and passed on. Many thanks to those who took the time to respond. Apparently either the great democrats at OK are too busy or the empowerment of the Cornish people is not important enough. The Cornish Democrat
A Cornish Assembly would be good news for those of us who are concerned to preserve the Celtic languages. Any of its members who were speakers and scholars of Cornish could join with cognate members of the Dail, the Northern Ireland Assembly, the Scottish Parliament, the Welsh Assembly, and the House of Keys to create a Celtic Languages Forum in which elected Breton speakers and scholars might also participate. Such a forum as I envisage would be much greater than the sum of its parts.
A Cornish Assembly would be good news for those of us who are concerned to preserve the Celtic languages. Any of its members who were speakers and scholars of Cornish could join with cognate members of the Dail, the Northern Ireland Assembly, the Scottish Parliament, the Welsh Assembly, and the House of Keys to create a Celtic Languages Forum in which elected Breton speakers and scholars might also participate. Such a forum as I envisage would be much greater than the sum of its parts.
Post new comment