Skip to content

Kazakhs are wary of neighbours bearing gifts

We asked ordinary people in Kazakhstan which great power they liked most. Despite its assistance during the COVID-19 pandemic, China didn’t do so well.

Kazakhs are wary of neighbours bearing gifts
Chinese medical experts at Ürümqi International Airport prepare to depart for Kazakhstan, April 9, 2020. | Photo (c): Zhao Ge/Xinhua News Agency/PA Images
Published:

The COVID-19 pandemic has sparked a new front in great power competition — global health posturing. Whether it is assigning blame, providing medical aid, or modelling the most effective response, great powers are waging an information war against each other. China is aggressively defending its crisis management methods in the face of rising criticism from the international community. Alongside its "face mask diplomacy," China is touting its governance model as the most efficient in dealing with crisis situations. But how well positioned was China before the crisis really hit?

Some answers can be found in Central Asian states such as Kazakhstan, long an object of Chinese soft power. As the crisis developed, we surveyed ordinary people in Kazakhstan for their opinion on the different great powers, and which they believed had best coped with the pandemic.

First among equals?

In February 2020, we organised a nationally representative survey in Kazakhstan as part of a project on geopolitical orientations. In it we asked respondents about the degree to which they approved of the presence of various major powers in world affairs.