Skip to content

Labour rights won’t make criminal gangs go away

‘Decent work’ isn’t always possible. Advocates should stop shying away from criminal justice in anti-trafficking

Labour rights won’t make criminal gangs go away
Law enforcement officers inspect a work place during a crackdown operation on cyber-scamming centres in Shwe Kokko in south east Myanmar in February 2025 | STR/AFP/Getty Images. All rights reserved
Published:

The Beyond Trafficking and Slavery (BTS) project on openDemocracy has been documenting and directing discourse around the counter-trafficking and anti-slavery movement for a decade. During that time, it helped bring about several key changes to the field.

These include: moving the discussion beyond criminal justice to focus attention on the structural issues underpinning human exploitation. Shifting perceptions of trafficked people from passive victims of fate to active survivors shaping their own stories. And modernising conceptions of ‘slavery’ to capture the systems exploiting those downstream for the profit of those upstream.

These are all important achievements. Stakeholders are right to celebrate the widening of the conversation to also focus on labour rights. But there is a risk of the pendulum swinging too far in this direction, if BTS is suggesting that criminal justice is never the right response to trafficking.