openDemocracy and internet governance

6 January 2006
Given my views (as expressed here on openDemocracy at the opening of last year's World Summit on the Information Society in Tunis) I was surprised to learn from Paul Weyrich this morning that according to the president of America's Survival Cliff Kincaid I am in fact working for an organisation which "advocates granting the UN control over the Internet to help this scandal-ridden organisation regain its prestige throughout the world".

I thought I'd better double-check before handing in my notice. A quick scan of our ongoing debate "Governing the net", therefore, came as a relief. Messrs Weyrich and Kincaid, however, clearly forgot to scroll down the page.

If they had, they would have found cool analysis of the initial stages of the WSIS process from Solana Larsen and James Cowling, and, further down, a debate between Stefaan G. Verhulst of the Markle foundation and ICANN's pioneer and founding chair, Esther Dyson, differing over the relevance of ICANN and the need for reform over the coming years.

The most recent two entries in the debate, myself and my good friend and colleague Bill Thompson, represent two very differing views on internet governance. Whereas he sees a UN-controlled ICANN as a way to strengthen an organisation that needs our backing, I can't think of anything worse than "a conglomerate of technophobe heads of state working out what to do with it".
Differing views are always welcome on openDemocracy  - I should know, I'm the managing editor. And I'm sure we would welcome a contribution from both Mr Weyrich and Cliff Kincaid for these pages, as I'm confident that when they write for openDemocracy, they would do their research first.
Had enough of ‘alternative facts’? openDemocracy is different Join the conversation: get our weekly email


We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData