Home

Bibi’s upset comeback

After a last minute electoral upset, Israeli Prime Minster Benyamin Netanyahu will almost certainly form a new government. What does a fourth term for Bibi mean for Israel, Palestine and the wider region? 

Kevjn Lim
19 March 2015
Benyamin Netanyahu addresses a crowd of supporters after his surprise victory.

Benyamin Netanyahu addresses a crowd of supporters after his surprise victory. Demotix/David Bar Dov. All rights reserved.

Benyamin Netanyahu, already Israel’s longest-serving prime minister, is about to put together his fourth government. Two hours before midnight on 17 March 2015, exit polls by Israel’s three main television channels indicated a tie of roughly 27 seats each between his party, Likud, and the opposition Zionist Union.

By the next morning however, the tally respectively showed 30 to 24, a clear margin of victory for Netanyahu’s party which grew by 50% compared to 2013. Gambling on a joint list to challenge Netanyahu, the Zionist Union, an alliance of Yitzhak Herzog’s Labor Party and Tzipi Livni’s HaTenuah ('the Movement'), may have secured significant gains compared to 15 and 6 seats respectively in 2013, but not nearly enough to form a government.

Even a clear electoral victory must still be followed by horse-trading.

Votes streaming to these two neck-to-neck contenders enfeebled most other parties but pushed to third place a highly improbable party whose constituents have been historically marginalised in Jewish Israeli politics - Israeli Arabs. The four Arab parties had merged to form the Joint List, in order to overcome the barrier for representation in the Knesset, recently raised to 3.25%. Still, the 14 seats won will fail to make any substantive difference, at least for now. 

Horse-trading

In a fiercely contested parliamentary democracy based on proportional representation, even a clear electoral victory must still be followed by horse-trading, capped at 42 days, that would normally bring into existence a governing coalition of 61 seats at minimum out of the Knesset’s total of 120. In 2009, then Kadima head Tzipi Livni won by a narrow margin the largest number of seats, but it was the runner-up, the current prime minister, who eventually managed to create a governing coalition. 

As it stands there are two probable coaltions. A rightwing nationalist-religious coalition led by Netanyahu’s Likud (30) which would include Naftali Bennett’s Jewish Home (8), the Sephardic ultraorthodox Shas under Aryeh Deri (7), United Torah Judaism (6) and Bibi’s erstwhile campaign partner, the archconservative Avigdor Lieberman (6), would secure 57 seats – 4 short of the threshold. Conversely, a center-left coalition encompassing the Zionist Union (24), Yair Lapid’s Yesh Atid (11), Zehava Galon’s Meretz (4), and the Joint List would still be 8 seats short of the necessary minimum.

Which is why this makes Moshe Kahlon, the popular head of Kulanu (‘All of us’), Israel’s most powerful politician at this precarious moment. Kahlon only relatively recently split off from Likud but has stated he would join any coalition that accepts his platform of pocketbook reforms and his singleminded bid for the finance ministry. Should Kahlon’s 10 seats join the nationalist-religious coalition – an almost foregone conclusion – Bibi would have a broad government with 67 mandates. Should Kahlon surprise everyone by looking center-left instead, the latter – with Arab participation – could still carry the day. A third possibility, also extremely unlikely the way things are going right now, is a national unity government with Kahlon playing third wheel.

Banking right 

Like 2013, the elections this time round – brought forward owing to irreconcilable disputes within the previous Netanyahu government – wasn’t about foreign or security policy but rather about long festering domestic bread-and-butter grievances. But the impact of the new government on the broader outlines of Israel’s foreign policy will matter tremendously.

The impact of the new government on the broader outlines of Israel’s foreign policy will matter tremendously.

If Netanyahu’s second government (2009-2013) presided over a deterioration of Israel’s international standing, his third government (2013-2015) very publicly wrenched to breaking point Israel’s relations with its most important ally, America. With Republican prompting, Bibi decided to undercut the White House by directly addressing Congress about the demerits of the emerging Iran deal.

Netanyahu’s domestic constituency was likely as important a target audience as America’s lawmakers, if not more. Hours before the 17 March elections Netanyahu made what was then widely interpreted as intensifying desperation. In hindsight, however, it proved a high-risk/high-gain gambit.

Netanyahu publicly backpeddled on the 'two-states-for-two-peoples' pledge he made at Bar Ilan University in 2009. ‘If I’m elected, there’ll be no Palestinian state’, he vowed. On election day itself, he banked even more sharply right and raised hell by warning that Israeli Arabs, ostensibly funded by foreign governments, were pouring out to vote en masse and ‘twisting the true will of all Israeli citizens.’

More of the same

And so, coalitional negotiations pending, it appears we’re on the verge of a fourth Netanyahu government. Netanyahu hasn’t yet proven an ability, or perhaps the political will, to dislodge himself from the narrowest possible definition of national security, certainly not with him repeatedly pointing to the looming twin threat posed by the Islamic Republic and the Islamic State. With Bennett and Lieberman, though weakened, still guarding his far flanks, Netanyahu’s new government is unlikely to deviate much from its Israel-vs-the-world mindset, while remaining sanguine about keeping in over 4m non-Israeli Palestinians.

Having already ridden roughshod over its US ally on an Iran deal that has yet to reach a conclusion acceptable to Israel, the initial impression is that a fourth Netanyahu government is unlikely to quickly ditch the grosser instruments of statecraft for a more subtle appraoch.

Netanyahu’s new government is unlikely to deviate much from its Israel-vs-the-world mindset.

Meir Dagan, the ailing former head of Mossad, Israeli's intelligence service, called Netanyahu ‘the person that has caused Israel the most strategic damage when it comes to the Iranian issue.’ More understated though perhaps no less scathing was the charge by Yitzhak Ben Yisrael, Israel’s leading military scientist, that Netanyahu’s government had turned on its head the Ben Gurion adage that ‘Gentiles only talk while we Jews do.’

The elections’ final figures look set to entrench Israel’s nationalist-religious camp, even though an empowered Likud also means a greater margin of maneuver for Netanyahu when it comes to intracoalition bargaining, especially with its more extreme members. Having invested so much of his rhetoric – and to be fair, a quantum of effort – in matters of national security, there is something approaching consensus among Israel’s security czars that Bibi has nonetheless brought Israel one step closer in the opposite direction. Having said this, after defying the odds in a close election, Bibi may yet surprise us again.

US election: what's at stake for the rest of us?

Our editor-in-chief, Mary Fitzgerald, is on the ground in key battleground states ahead of the US election.

There's never been more at stake. But the pandemic has kept many foreign journalists away. Hundreds of international observers who normally oversee US elections aren't there.

Hear Mary describe what she's seeing and hearing across the country, from regular citizens to social justice activists to right-wing militias arming themselves for election day.

Plus: hear from the journalists behind openDemocracy's latest big 'follow-the-money' investigation, which lifts the lid on how Trump-linked groups have exported their culture wars across the world.

Join us for a free live discussion on Thursday 29 October, 5pm UK time/1pm EDT.

Had enough of ‘alternative facts’? openDemocracy is different Join the conversation: get our weekly email

Comments

We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData