Skip to content

Why the UK Left is wrong to be so dismissive of non-violent struggle

It’s become fashionable to dismiss peaceful forms of resistance to injustice – but the evidence suggests they should be taken seriously

Why the UK Left is wrong to be so dismissive of non-violent struggle
Insulate Britain protestors stop traffic on the motorway | Mark Kerrison / Alamy Stock Photo
Published:

Non-violence is under attack.

Many influential figures on the Left in the UK dismiss, misrepresent or ignore the concept of non-violent struggle, also known as civil resistance. Indeed, two books have recently been published that explicitly criticise non-violence – Andreas Malm’s ‘How To Blow Up A Pipeline’ and ‘In Defense of Looting’ by Vicky Osterweil. In a June 2020 editorial, the revolutionary Leftist magazine Salvage proclaimed: “Salvage glorifies the burning down of the Minneapolis third police precinct [in response to the murder of African-American man George Floyd]”.

Below I respond to some of the myths often repeated on the Left about non-violent struggle.