openDemocracyUK

Colston has fallen. Who’s next?

The UK has honoured many slavers, plunderers and perpetrators of massacres. Here’s a list of some more candidates for de-plinthing. Add your own.

Adam Ramsay
Adam Ramsay
8 June 2020
Statue of Cecil Rhodes at the University of Cape Town being removed, 2015.
|
Wikimedia

British history is a story of empire, slavery and plunder. And so it’s not surprising that the statues, street names and buildings in our cities so often commemorate slavers, plunderers and the genocidal.

This weekend, a statue of the slaver Edward Colston in the centre of Bristol was pulled down and thrown into the harbour, symbolically reflecting the thousands of people thrown into the sea from his slave ships when they got sick on the crossing from their kidnap in Africa. 

The statue of Colston, though, isn’t unique, or even unusual. Across the UK, many of our most famous buildings, streets and monuments are named after people deeply implicated in the worst crimes of empire. Here is a small sample of some of the most controversial memorials – please add more, from the UK and beyond, in the comments below.

Edinburgh: Henry Dundas

Melville_Monument,_Edinburgh.jpg

Henry Dundas, later the first Viscount Melville, occupies the biggest plinth in the city, at the centre of St Andrew’s Square in the heart of the Georgian New Town. Dundas was controversial even in his own era – burned in effigy in towns up and down the east coast of Scotland for his suppression of movements for democracy. 

He is perhaps most notorious today for his time as British Home Secretary in the late eighteenth century. In that role, he opposed William Wilberforce and so ensured that the abolition of the trans-Atlantic slave trade was delayed for more than a decade. Dundas was also known for dominating the affairs of the East India Company, leading to a common saying in his lifetime: “Scotland and India Dundas ruled, and he fed one with the other.” (You can read about my little campaign to get a more accurate plaque on his statue here.)

Cardiff: Thomas Picton

sirthomaspicton.jpg

A statue of Thomas Picton in Cardiff City Hall’s ‘Welsh Icons’ collection.

There are more statues of Thomas Picton in Wales than there are of women. The most senior general to die at Waterloo, he is the only Welsh person buried at Westminster Abbey. Before battling Napoleon, though, he was governor of Trinidad, where he oversaw the enslavement of thousands of people. Picton’s time in Trinidad ended in controversy, even in his own era, when he ordered the gruesome torture of a mixed-race teenage girl, accused of stealing some money from her serial rapist.

Oxford: Cecil Rhodes

Oriel.png
Cecil Rhodes, Oriel

Rhodes, perhaps most famous for having Northern and Southern Rhodesia – the colonial names for what are now Zambia and Zimbabwe – named after him, was a white supremacist whose ideas inspired Hitler and prepared the ground for apartheid. The statue of Rhodes at the University of Cape Town in South Africa was removed in 2015. But, despite numerous attempts to encourage Oxford University to follow this example, a carving of him remains in Oriel College, Oxford.

Plymouth: Francis Drake

Drake.jpg
Francis Drake, Plymouth

Plymouth has a large statue of Francis Drake. And while British children are often taught to consider Drake a hero due to his circumnavigation of the globe and his role in defeating the Spanish Armada, he started his career as a slave trader.

Liverpool: Benjamin Disraeli

Statue_of_Benjamin_Disraeli,_1st_Earl_of_Beaconsfield_(4741418941).jpg
Benjamin Disraeli, Liverpool

The two-time Tory prime minister was famous for his often brutal expansion of the British empire, including through the Anglo-Zulu war. He is memorialised in a statue outside Liverpool’s architectural centrepiece, St George’s Hall. While many former British prime ministers would qualify for this list, Disraeli’s role in developing British imperialism is in much need of more historical prominance. 

Shrewsbury: Robert Clive

Clive.jpg

Robert Clive – known as Clive of India – made himself a multi-millionaire by plundering vast resources from South Asia. A statue to honour him decorates Shrewsbury Square.

Glasgow and London: Colin Campbell, Lord Clyde

Lord Clyde.jpg
Lord Clyde, George Square, Glasgow

Campbell was a career soldier who was appointed commander-in-chief of British forces in India in 1857, suppressing the first Indian war of independence. He commanded a regiment in the first Opium War and organised the army sent east for the second – forcing the addictive drug onto China with military might. 

He has statues in both George Square, Glasgow, and Waterloo Place, London.

Edinburgh and London: King Charles II

Charles II.JPG
Charles II, Parliament Square, Edinburgh

After the restoration of the monarchy, Charles II founded the Royal Africa Company, which had a monopoly on British trade in slaves between West Africa and the Caribbean. The company was run by his brother, the duke of York, later James II, and started the large-scale involvement of England in the slave trade.

Denbigh: HM Stanley

Screenshot 2020-06-08 at 17.47.31.png

Stanley is most famous these days for greeting David Livingstone with the words "Dr Livingstone I presume?". But he was also a mass murderer who, according to contemporary accounts shot Black Africans "like monkeys". According to some accounts, while travelling on river-boats, he would calibrate his rifle by shooting African children on the bank. He was knighted in 1899 and a statue of him was unveiled in Shrewsbury in 2011.

London: James II

London has far too many such statues to list here, but these are a few of them:

James – who as the duke of York ran the Royal Africa Company – has a statue in Trafalgar Square.

William Beckford, who owned about 3,000 slaves in Jamaica, has a statue at the Guildhall, London.

Sir Thomas Clayton –who has a statue at St Thomas’s hospital – was a factor in Bermuda.

National Maritime Museum, London

If you're looking for somewhere particular to find such commemorations, The National Maritime Museum includes a veritable forest of statues of of slavers, genociders and plunderers, from James Cook to Walter Raleigh and many more besides.

Add your examples below...

With thanks to those who fed into the list above.

*This article previously repeated widely reported claims that Penny Lane in Liverpool is named after the slaver James Penny. However, local historians have since informed us that this probably isn't true, and the piece have been updated. Stanley and Clive have been added.

Peter Geoghegan: dark money and dirty politics

Democracy is in crisis and unaccountable flows of money are helping to destroy it. Peter Geoghegan’s new book, ‘Democracy for Sale: Dark Money and Dirty Politics’, charts how secretive money, lobbying and data has warped our democracy.

How has dark money bought our politics? What can be done to change the system?

Join us for a journey through a shadowy world of dark money and disinformation stretching from Westminster to Washington, and far beyond.

Sign up to take part in a free live discussion on Thursday 13 August at 5pm UK time/6pm CET

In conversation:

Peter Geoghegan Dark Money Investigations editor at openDemocracy and the author of ‘Democracy for Sale: Dark Money and Dirty Politics’.

Mary Fitzgerald Editor-in-chief, openDemocracy.

Who is bankrolling Britain's democracy? Which groups shape the stories we see in the press; which voices are silenced, and why? Sign up here to find out.

Comments

We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData