The strange death of Republican America

Sidney Blumenthal
4 November 2008

On 29 July 2008, President George W Bush appeared at the Lincoln Electric Company in Euclid, Ohio, where he spoke about energy and then asked the audience for questions. The opportunity for people in a small town in the midwest to pose a question directly to the president of the United States is a rare one, possibly a once-in-a-lifetime experience. "And now I'd like to answer some questions, if you have any", said Bush. But his request was returned with silence. Bush filled the air with an awkward joke: "After seven-and-a-half years, if I can't figure out how to dodge them, I shouldn't..." The audience tittered nervously. Bush continued, "If you don't have any questions, I can tell you a lot of interesting stories." The crowd laughed again, but no one raised a hand. "Okay", said Bush, "I'll tell you a story."

Sidney Blumenthal is a former assistant and senior adviser to Bill Clinton, former United States president. Among his books are How Bush Rules: Chronicles of a Radical Regime (Princeton University Press, 2006) and The Strange Death of Republican America (Union Square Press, 2008)

Sidney Blumenthal's interview about The Strange Death... can be heard on this openDemocracy podcast (parts one and two)

This article was (with minor editorial variations) first published in the Huffington Post on 4 August 2008

Sidney Blumenthal wrote a fortnightly column for openDemocracy from September 2005-November 2007. A selection:

"Bush's Potemkin village presidency" (22 September 2005)

"The Republican system" (20 January 2006)

"The infallible president" (25 July 2006)

"A state of denial" (3 October 2006)

"Taxi to the Dark Side: an open letter" (17 October 2007)

"Walter Lippmann and American journalism today" (31 October 2007)

"The choice" (21 November 2007)Despite the daily tracking-polls and the back-and-forth of the candidates, the underlying story of the 2008 presidential campaign has until the very day of the election remained the Bush presidency and how it brought about the end of the long era of Republican political dominance that began in 1968 with the election of Richard Nixon. That story is the subject of my book, The Strange Death of Republican America: Chronicles of a Collapsing Party.

Bush has the lowest sustained popularity among modern presidents. The Republican Party has fallen farther behind the Democratic Party in party identification and favourable ratings than it has in decades. Democrats are poised to make dramatic gains in their numbers in the House of Representatives and the Senate. The previously little-known Senator Barack Obama could have vaulted to become the Democratic nominee only as a response to Bush. Senator John McCain's emergence as the Republican nominee is also one of Bush's consequences. Without the crackup of the conservative movement and the fragmentation of the Republican primary field, McCain would not have had his opening. His candidacy is as much a manifestation of the shattering of the Republican phalanx as Obama's. Whatever the outcome of their contest, the party as it was is over. Today no one can even envision when the Republicans will control the presidency and both houses of the Congress as they did as recently as 2006.

Bush's decline is an end to more than a family dynasty; it is an end of political empire. Bush, "the decider", was the implementer of complementary radical plans for an imperial presidency and a one-party government to be ruled for generations by Republicans.

Back to the future

Dick Cheney, whose secret-service code name when he was President Gerald Ford's chief of staff, "Backseat", suggested his invisible influence, was the originator of the imperial presidency. It was a overarching idea he took from the Nixon White House, when he was then counsellor Donald Rumsfeld's deputy, and elaborated as vice-president into a doctrine of an unaccountable and unfettered "unitary executive" that had the right unto itself even to order torture.

Bush's chief political strategist, Karl Rove, whom he has called "The Architect" and "Turdblossom," was the designer of the grand realignment that would lock in Republican control for time immemorial.

But Bush's fiascos - from Gulf to shining Gulf, from the Coalition Provisional Authority in Iraq to FEMA in New Orleans - were the culmination of Republican ideology, and they have unravelled Republican strengths built up over forty years.

Though the Republican era is drawing to an end, a new Democratic one is not inevitable. Its dawning will require not only winning the White House and the Congress but also governing together successfully, which has not been possible since Lyndon Johnson was president.

In the meantime, the growing intensity of the day-to-day campaign in this election has had the effect of turning the focus away from the Bush presidency. Bush has achieved the weird effect of being the incumbent, still responsible, and increasingly ignored as somehow irrelevant. The silence that greeted Bush in Euclid, Ohio is symptomatic of his fading while still being present. Insofar as it has kept him in the picture, the Democratic campaign will have remembered a cardinal law of politics: that voters can be led into the future only by making the election a referendum on the past.

Had enough of ‘alternative facts’? openDemocracy is different Join the conversation: get our weekly email


We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData