Can Europe Make It?

Bernard Maris, the fury of capitalism and the fury of terrorism

Have we been reduced to the 'clash of civilizations' where, in the name of security, a state of emergency forces all to close ranks in a staged, imaginary conflict where all possibility of dissent is erased? In memoriam.

Mario Pianta
Mario Pianta
10 January 2015

Bernard Maris, an economist at the Bank of France, was at the meeting of editors of Charlie Hebdo on 7 January 2015 in Paris. He, too, died under the bullets of the killers - Oncle Bernard, author of a column in the satirical magazine, in which he explained the mysteries of finance.

He was not a cartoonist, but he shared with Charb (the director), Wolinski (the best known cartoonist) and the other victims an impatience for mainstream ideas and an antipathy for power. He was an old-style French intellectual, a scholar of Keynes and a public figure. He had been active in Attac France and was now a friend of Michel Houellebecq, the writer whose new controversial novel ‘Submission’ imagines a Muslim president for France. A frequent guest on radio France Inter, he clashed regularly with journalists of the French business newspaper. His books include the two volumes of “Economics, an Antimanual ” (Éditions Bréal, 2003, 2008), demolishing free market dogmas.

In what kind of convulsion of history do Islamic extremists at war with western power manage to kill one of the voices who denounced it? Which cognitive dissonance - even more than ideological blindness - prevents them from understanding the internal conflicts of capitalism?

Obviously, for those who want to erase freedom of expression, there are no differences that matter between western 'infidels'. Likewise, for the new European fascism, all Muslim citizens and immigrants are potential terrorists.

Have we been reduced to the 'clash of civilizations' where, in the name of security, a state of emergency forces all to close ranks in a staged, imaginary conflict where all possibility of dissent is erased?

The conflict that matters, the trench in which Oncle Bernard was writing, is not this one. He worked to denounce the ‘fury of capitalism’. Similarly, in the Islamic world - in the Middle East as in Europe - the key conflict is an internal one, the clash between opposing ideas on society and politics, even more than on religion.

The senseless death of Bernard Maris brings us back to our duty to oppose injustice, and first and foremost the one produced by our countries, our power, our consumption.

His death brings us back to a commitment to political debate - he had voted yes to the French referendum on the European Constitutional Treaty. But recently changed his mind: he thought the euro should be abandoned.

His death may help us to look ahead as he did - he thought that the future was beyond markets and commodities, in a sharing economy with meaningful jobs, cultural commons and social solidarity. Between the 'ants' and 'cicadas' who were on the covers of his “Antimanual”, his sympathy went to the latter. He was born in Toulouse and was 69 years old.

Is the pandemic changing attitudes towards migration?

Will Canada give its undocumented essential workers their rights? And where are the immigrants in the country’s policy debates?

Join us for a free live discussion on Thursday 26 November, 5pm UK time/12pm EST.

Hear from:

Daniel Hiebert Professor of geography at the University of British Columbia

Andrew Parkin Executive director, Environics Institute, Toronto

Usha George Professor and director, Ryerson Centre for Immigration and Settlement, Ryerson University, Canada

Keith Banting Professor emeritus and Stauffer Dunning Fellow, Queen’s University, Canada

Chair: Anna Triandafyllidou Canada Excellence Research Chair in Migration and Integration, Ryerson University

Get weekly updates on Europe A thoughtful weekly email of economic, political, social and cultural developments from the storm-tossed continent. Join the conversation: get our weekly email


We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.
Audio available Bookmark Check Language Close Comments Download Facebook Link Email Newsletter Newsletter Play Print Share Twitter Youtube Search Instagram WhatsApp yourData