Not so ‘macho’ now? Fewer Italians than Swedes hold anti-feminist views, survey says
New research from anti-extremism charities reveals ‘unexpected patterns’ of opinions towards feminism across Europe
Few would consider Italy – known for its ‘macho’ politics and far-Right leaders promoting ‘traditional’ gender roles – as a hotspot for feminist values in Europe. But a new survey, conducted in late 2020 and released today, suggests this may be changing.
Of the eight European countries included in the survey, which had 12,000 respondents, people in Italy were the least likely to blame feminism for men’s feelings of marginalisation and demonisation.
Meanwhile, in Sweden – long seen as a bastion for progressive gender equality politics – more people (41%) than anywhere else surveyed said they at least somewhat agreed with the statement: “It is feminism’s fault that some men feel at the margins of society and demonised.”
Daniel Poohl, CEO of the Swedish anti-extremism group Expo, told openDemocracy that “the surprising anti-feminist views of Swedes” could be partly explained as a backlash to successful feminist movements.
After a six-month openDemocracy investigation, major aid donors and NGOs have said they will investigate anti-LGBT ‘conversion therapy’ at health facilities run by groups they fund.
But unlike the other aid donors, US aid agency PEPFAR has not responded at all.
Please sign this petition to show that it must take action now.
“Some victories of Swedish feminism in the last years could have activated the rise of strong opposite attitudes,” he said.
After Sweden, about 30% of participants in Poland expressed anti-feminist views, followed by the United Kingdom (28%), France (26%), Hungary (22%), Germany (19%) and the Netherlands (15%).
Only 13% of Italian respondents, however, expressed such views and 65% said they either strongly or somewhat disagreed with them.
Simone Rafael from the Amadeu Antonio Foundation in Germany, which commissioned the research along with Swedish group Expo and HOPE not Hate (UK), called the scale of anti-feminist opinion in Europe “very worrying”.
Nick Lowles, CEO of HOPE not Hate in the UK added that, in many countries, an “anti-feminism agenda” is now “wrapped up in the growing right-wing cultural wars which is much more aggressive, quite violent rhetoric and is used particularly by younger men”.
State of Hate
The anti-extremism groups’ survey was commissioned as part of a new report entitled ‘STATE OF HATE: Far-right extremism in Europe’. It also revealed that at least a quarter of the survey’s respondents said they have negative feelings towards Muslim people.
Almost a third of respondents reflected hostile views towards immigrants generally and more than a third reflected such views of the Roma people.
"This report shows that the threat against democracy is changing form and strategy. The far-Right of today is a transnational movement that organises supporters through networks rather than old-fashioned organisations," said Poohl, CEO of Expo.
Ahead of the 2019 European Parliament elections, openDemocracy uncovered how a dozen US Christian right ‘fundamentalist’ groups had poured at least $50m of dark money into Europe over a decade, boosting the far Right that was angling for record wins that year.
HOPE not hate’s Lowles said extremist ideologies are now “internationalised like never before” – and “resistance must be so, too”.
According to the survey, the majority of respondents in Hungary hold negative views towards immigrants (60%) and Muslim people (54%). These numbers are about twice as high as they are in the UK, where 30% hold such views of immigrants and 26% of Muslims.
When asked if they sympathised with Black Lives Matter protests against racism and discrimination against minorities, most respondents in Germany (52%), Sweden (51%) and the UK (51%) said they did. This was not the case in any of the other countries surveyed.
‘Deep mistrust’ of authorities
The report also highlighted a “deep well of mistrust” in authorities, adding that populists and extremists across Europe could attempt to exploit such an environment.
Political disenchantment was particularly pronounced in Italy and France, with 79% and 67% of respondents respectively saying that they thought their political system is wholly or partially broken. These figures were also high in Poland (63%), the UK (58%) and Hungary (55%).
“Europe's far-Right and anti-democratic scene is connected in many ways nowadays – it is anti-Semitism, Islamophobia and white supremacy thinking that the far-right enemies of democracy agree on,” concluded Anetta Kahane, CEO of Amadeu Antonio Foundation in Germany.
This report, she argued, “makes the commonalities visible that we must fight together to protect democracy and human rights in Europe.”
Get our weekly email