The Cumbrian coal mine is a case in point. Its main financial backer is EMR Capital Group, an Australian private equity firm that specialises in coal and mining. If the mine is shut down by Cumbria County Council, as is currently being explored following a damning report from the government’s own Climate Change Committee, this would undoubtedly affect the profitability of the mine’s Australian investors. As things stand, the UK’s climate policies would prevail and the investors would have to have no choice but to stand down. However, if an ISDS clause is agreed as part of the UK-Australia trade deal, this could lead to a challenge that costs taxpayers millions and severely hampers the UK’s transition to net-zero.
Australia is undoubtedly an important ally of the UK. Its cultural, historic and diplomatic ties run deep. However, this does not make it an environmentally friendly trading partner. A country more than 9,000 miles away that specialises in large-scale agriculture, mining and fossil fuel energy production is not a good partner for a government that hopes to be the “greenest ever”. So what should be done?
The UK must urgently reconsider its trade offer to Australia and make any new deal fully contingent on aligning with legally binding climate targets. The government should also produce a full environmental impact assessment and present this to MPs along with the deal before it is ratified. Finally, the deal should receive full parliamentary and public scrutiny, with a guaranteed vote for MPs.
Putting the brakes on a trade deal with Australia won’t be enough to ‘green’ the UK’s trade policy. A far more radical overhaul of our approach to trade deals is needed. However, it will be a clear signal to the UK’s partners that this government is serious about climate change, and demonstrate leadership ahead of the COP26 summit later this year. A green trade agenda would be good for our farmers and food standards at home and create new jobs. Most importantly, it would protect the planet.
The volcano gods are, after all, a jealous bunch.
Comments
We encourage anyone to comment, please consult the oD commenting guidelines if you have any questions.