The Milburn Review is a highly ambitious piece of work that starts with the right principle: young people want to work. They’re capable and have aspirations. NEETs – that horrible term for 18- 24-year-olds who are not in education, employment, or training – have not failed; they have been failed by the system.
Yet the report, which was published this week and whose recommendations the government is considering, manages to almost entirely overlook the fact that young women often face barriers to work that are directly linked to their gender.
Every day, we at Young Women’s Trust hear from young women who desperately want to work but are unable to do so due to a lack of childcare or mental health needs that employers are unwilling to accommodate. Others tell us they spend long, repetitive days producing hundreds of job applications, which disappear into the void of AI-based recruitment portals with no reply. It’s no wonder that so many say they’re losing hope for the future.
Young women make up nearly half of all NEETs, and the vast majority are deemed ‘economically inactive’, meaning they are not in a position to work or apply for jobs. For a third, this is because they are caring for children, compared with just 6% of young men. Quite apart from the fact that raising children is far from ‘inactive’ – it is both hard work and economically productive – the Milburn Review made little mention of the specific needs of these young women.
The 267 pages of recommendations contain next to nothing on the importance of having accessible, affordable childcare that fits around the hours that young women actually work. Many are seeking employment in social care or hospitality, sectors where workdays rarely fit the standard 9-5 offered by most childcare providers.
Similarly, if employment schemes and new training opportunities are to genuinely work for young women, they must offer flexible hours so that young mums and carers can fit them around childcare – another fact overlooked by the report.
We’re seeing entry-level jobs that give young women their first step on the career ladder disappear fastest. Milburn’s proposal to reduce employers’ National Insurance contributions for young people in the retail and hospitality sectors may go some way to addressing this, as may the recommendation to open up more entry-level jobs in the NHS and the public sector – typically large employers of women. But we also need to see more done to open up young women’s access to the male-dominated sectors, such as defence and construction, that are backed for growth.
Young women tend to be overrepresented in insecure and precarious work, leaving them with little power and dependent on their managers deciding whether or not to offer them additional shifts. Such power imbalances enable workplace sexual harassment, discrimination and violation – all of which we know to disproportionately affect young women.
It’s unsurprising then that our research has found that insecure work can affect young women’s mental health and lead to them being pushed out of work, or deciding to leave. Each time this happens, it can cause a further knock to their confidence that makes it harder to obtain employment. A vicious cycle.
This is particularly worrying given young women are already more likely to have common mental health problems than any other demographic, and a third of those we support tell us that their mental health has prevented them from applying for a job. We’re glad, then, to see quick-access mental health support with a fast track for unemployed young people as a cornerstone of Milburn’s recommendations.
It’s essential that Andy Burnham’s government focuses on quality, secure work that young women can sustain – not just any work at any cost. Milburn’s suggestion that ministers dilute plans to clamp down on zero-hours contracts will ring alarm bells for young women who need job security if they are to thrive.
There’s no doubt that the Milburn Review is laudable, ambitious, and potentially transformative. But it needs to be so for all young people; it needs a gender lens. Work works differently for young women and young men. The barriers they face when it comes to finding and staying in work are different, so the solutions must be, too.
Measures put in place to tackle the increase in the number of young people who are NEET must be assessed for their impact on young women and men separately, with outcomes measured by gender. Only then can we ensure that no young woman is left behind because of barriers that exist purely because she is a woman.