A leading charity has raised concerns about the impact that the Milburn Review’s proposals to cut disability benefits for young adults will have on unpaid carers.
Former Labour minister Alan Milburn this week published his long-awaited government-commissioned report on young people who are not in education, employment or training, known as NEETs.
The next election could come any time, and we are determined to expose the flow of dark money in politics before then. To do so, we need to recruit 500 new monthly donors by the end of 2026. We're a third of the way there – but still have a long way to go.
Will you help us fight those funding the politics of hate, with a monthly donation today?
Among his most notable recommendations is a suggestion that ministers should scrap the two main disability benefits for 18- 24-year-olds in England and Wales: the Universal Credit health payment (UCH) and the Personal Independence Payment (PIP).
Unlike UCH, which is means-tested, PIP is paid regardless of a claimant’s employment status, and acts as a “passport” that opens up access to other benefits and entitlements. These include Carer’s Allowance and the carer’s element of Universal Credit, both of which are available to unpaid carers looking after a PIP recipient.
Unpaid carers are usually family members whose ability to take on paid work is limited by their caring responsibilities. Helen Walker, the chief executive at Carers UK, noted that removing PIP from young adults will not remove the need for this care, but could push some households into financial difficulty if their carers also lose access to financial support.
“Many unpaid carers have given up employment, reduced their working hours or sacrificed career opportunities to provide care,” she said. “If a young person’s PIP entitlement ends and their parent or other unpaid carer consequently loses Carer’s Allowance, households could face two simultaneous reductions in financial support.
“Any reform of disability benefits must protect both disabled young people and the unpaid carers who support them. The need for care does not disappear simply because the benefit system changes.”
Under Milburn’s plans, most unemployed young Disabled adults would receive a new benefit at the same rate as the basic non-disabled Universal Credit payment. Some would also be eligible for a new Additional Cost Allowance, effectively a replacement for PIP, designed to contribute to individual disability-related costs that are “significant, well established and ongoing”, rather than being paid at a set rate.
Only a small number of very severely Disabled young adults would be able to claim a new long-term disability benefit. Walker urged the government to publish a comprehensive impact assessment report setting out the consequences that the potential changes would have on unpaid carers.
“The government must clarify whether new disability benefits proposed to replace PIP will provide a qualifying route to Carer's Allowance and the Universal Credit carer element,” she said. “We also need reassurance that carers currently receiving Carer's Allowance because of a young person's existing PIP award will retain entitlement during and after the transition.
“It is unclear how the assessment processes for PIP and the proposed Additional Cost Allowance will determine eligibility, and what implications this will have for access to Carer's Allowance.”
While the government says it is still considering Milburn’s recommendations, it has so far welcomed the report’s findings. In an initial response this week, prime minister Andy Burnham said: “Our direction is already clear: a fundamental overhaul of how we support young people.”
Yet carers’ benefits aren’t the only entitlements that the proposals would put at risk.
A person receiving the enhanced mobility element of PIP – paid to those whose illness or disability causes the most severe problems getting about – can choose to exchange part of their benefit income for a car, wheelchair-accessible vehicle, or powered wheelchairs and mobility scooters under the Motability Scheme.
This and other transport-related support could also be threatened by removing PIP, said Julia Modern of Inclusion London, a charity campaigning for equality for Deaf and Disabled people.
“A young person not meeting very strict NHS eligibility for a wheelchair may no longer be eligible for a Motability wheelchair or a wheelchair-accessible vehicle in exchange for their PIP mobility component. A young person facing inaccessible public transport may no longer be eligible for the concessionary travel or Blue Badge, which lets them get to work or college.”
“Three-quarters of people receiving Universal Credit Health are already living in deprivation,” Modern continued. “Removing PIP and UC Health for 16-24-year-olds would push them further into deprivation and away from work, and would have knock-on effects in many areas of life where these benefits act as a passport.”
Councils, many of which are already in financial difficulties, may also lose out as a result of the proposed changes. Under the current adult care system, local authorities often take some of PIP claimants’ benefit income to cover social care charges, such as one-to-one home care and use of day centres.
“While we think that no one should have to pay for social care, under the current funding system, councils will be left with significant gaps if they are no longer able to take PIP from young people,” added Modern.
“Milburn very clearly signals that he intends the government to make similar cuts to UC Health and PIP in adult disability benefits in the future, and wants his youth cuts to be a model for them.
“But the additional employment support that he proposes is an investment that would eventually pay for itself through reduced benefits claims and increased tax receipts. The government does not have to decimate financial support for Disabled people and push us further into poverty, to invest in more accessible employment for those who need it most.”
The Department for Work and Pensions told openDemocracy that the government will carefully consider all the Milburn Review’s recommendations and issue a full response in the coming weeks.