Skip to content

Is Downton Abbey the best we can do?

Downton Abbey’s blend of nostalgia and wishful-thinking has been entertaining, but it raises questions about class that have yet to be resolved even now.

Published:
house_0.jpg
house_0.jpg

Flickr/crapatdarts

, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

Downton Abbey has closed to visitors at last. Compared to the original Upstairs, Downstairs, it was something of a disappointment. Downton was a soap opera of incident rather than a drama of character. If the period look was superficially credible (and well-acted), the period background of manners and language was questionable. Wholly inaccurate was its depiction of class attitudes of a century ago when in reality servants were seen as little more than robots without inner lives of any consequence.